Verified Document

Ethical Values And Situational Moral Essay

Of course, in principle, lying to the public is still morally wrong; however, there is a fundamental difference between lying to protect the interests of your company in a manner that allows your company to continue putting the public at risk and lying to protect the interests of your company in a manner that merely minimizes the potential future harm to your company arising from past mistakes, provided appropriate steps are implemented to correct the situation in the future. The best possible solution to the ethical dilemma presented would comprise the following components:

commitment from the company president to thoroughly investigate the allegations of the state public safety director.

A commitment from the company president to implement all the steps necessary to resolve the problems identified by the state public safety director.

A public statement that acknowledges the importance of working with the state public safety director's office to ensure the safety of all vehicles operated by your company.

A commitment from the company president to settle any civil suits arising from liability in connection with previous failures to ensure the safety of company vehicles if those failures resulted in financial and other types of harm to individuals involved in accidents with company vehicles.

The intent of these components is simply to rectify the situation to prevent any future harm caused by previous failures on the part of the company to maintain the safety of its vehicles and to compensate innocent victims of such company failures without causing unnecessary financial harm to the company. Misrepresenting the truth and taking no action to solve the problem would result in continued risk of harm to the public safety, health, and welfare.

On the other hand, it is not absolutely necessary to admit the truth of the problem to the extent the purpose of that non-admission is limited to minimizing damaging the reputation and future viability...

Conversely, it is not morally acceptable to misrepresent the truth to the extent the purpose of the denial is to avoid making the changes necessary to protect the public from potential harms caused by your company's failure to maintain necessary maintenance procedures. Provided you can emphasize your company president of the importance of improving maintenance procedures as necessary to provide adequate improvement to the condition of your company's truck fleet, you could satisfy your moral obligation to the general public while mitigating the potential harm to your company. If so, a statement such as the following might be the best possible solution to the problem:
At Acme Trucking Corporation, we are tremendously disappointed by the allegations levied against our company by the state public safety director. We believe that our maintenance procedures and standards are state of the art within the interstate trucking industry. We are confident that a full investigation of the matter will exonerate Acme of any wrongdoing in the unfortunate circumstances that precipitated the state public safety director's inquiry, but we remain absolutely committed to preserving the health, safety, and welfare of the public and we will fully cooperate in any and all investigations of our operations and procedures.

We have already confirmed to our satisfaction that the findings of the state public safety director are in error and that none of Acme's policies or procedures contributed in any way to the accident that triggered the state's inquiry, but we applaud and support the public safety director's persistence and vigilance. We have scheduled an immediate comprehensive review of all Acme maintenance and record-keeping practices and we have issued a formal directive to all Acme facilities to submit to a full safety audit designed to identify any and all necessary changes to ensure the health, safety, and welfare of the public, and to implement them irrespective of any costs to Acme."

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethical Theories the Three Basic Ethical Theories
Words: 2729 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Theories The three basic ethical theories share a number of similarities, because they each attempt to describe and explicate the ethical decisions made by humans as well as the logic (or illogic) that is used to inform any particular behavior. Utilitarianism offers what is perhaps the most sound ethical theory due to the way it chooses for itself the goal of its efforts, but it is hampered by disagreement regarding

Ethical Theory Ethics Given What
Words: 1039 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

Utilitarianism is most often used by healthcare organizations like insurance companies: to keep costs down for the many, a potentially valuable treatment may be denied to the individual because it is deemed experimental or unnecessarily costly. As unpalatable as the idea may be, no patient can be tested for every single conceivable illness he or she might contract. There must be some prioritization of high-risk groups. During his or

Morality Good Virtue Character
Words: 1972 Length: 6 Document Type:

Moral Good and Moral Value Determining moral "good" is a fundamental philosophical study. Only the lazy philosopher would revert to codes of ethics. Ethical standards come from somewhere, and generally those standards can be grouped into three main categories of analysis: consequentialism, deontological ethics, and virtue or character ethics. While these three modes of thinking about the moral good can sometimes interact with one another to create more complex moral analyses,

Moral Intelligence
Words: 1682 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Understanding Moral Intelligence Introduction Moral intelligence is a crucial aspect of our cognitive abilities that guides us in making ethical decisions and understanding right from wrong. It is the capacity to understand the ethical principles that govern human behavior and to apply them in daily life. This unique form of intelligence goes beyond traditional measures of intelligence, such as IQ, and focuses on the development of a person's character and values. Unlike other

Ethical Systems: Relativistic Before Discussing Any Ethical
Words: 1388 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Systems: Relativistic Before discussing any ethical system it is important to understand what the terms ethics and ethical systems mean. Trevino & Nelson, (2007) define ethics as "the principles, norms, and standards of conduct governing an individual or organization," and the right action, or moral behavior in a particular situation is determined based on ethics, whereas, ethical system refers to the underlying ethical principles used by an individual in making

Ethical Problems in Business Principle: Ethics May
Words: 1450 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Ethical Problems in Business PRINCIPLE: Ethics may be termed as the inner guiding moral principles, values and beliefs people use to indicate and identify what is acceptable and appropriate behavior whilst straying away from the opposite (Jones, 2007). However each individual may perceive different behaviors as acceptable and appropriate depending on the individual's own self-interests, attitudes, beliefs and values. To dig further into the aspects of business ethics, it is primarily a notion for

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now