Verified Document

Ethical Issues In Nursing Scenario The Scenario Essay

Ethical Issues in Nursing Scenario

The scenario in this study involves a nurse who has intentionally disregarded the elderly patient's expressed wishes to receive pressure area care. The patient finds the procedure uncomfortable, embarrassing, and painful. The nurse continues to turn the patient in spite of the patient's wishes. This study will answer if the nurse is justified in turning the patient and if so, on what ethical grounds and if not then why not. This case will be discussed in light of the principles of bioethics and at least one ethical issue.

The work of Lakeman (2000) entitled "Nurses as Tools: Instrumentality and Implications for Nursing Ethics" states "Nurses are left in a particularly compromised position when required to administer compulsory treatment. The task of administering the treatment is often left to nurses who are legally required to follow "doctor's orders." There is little room for conscientious objection by nurses, as a moral objection is perceived as a challenge to the clinical judgment of doctors and the ethos of psychiatry. That nurses must 'do as they're told' in relation to the compulsorily detained and treated person does not, however diminish their personal moral responsibility for their own actions." (p.4) Lakeman (2000) additionally states that medicine "…is often presumed to have greatest competence in moral decision making, followed by other groups such as nursing who have some, but a lesser understanding (partial insight) of medical knowledge, and lastly by the patient who is deemed to have the least competence." (p.4)

Consent for Treatment

Consent for treatment is particularly important in the ethical consideration of healthcare providers. Consent "is the cornerstone of patient's rights." (Lakeman, 2000) In the case where a patient is incompetent, only a legally appointed guardian may make decisions concerning treatment. (Lakeman, 2000) For consent to treatment to be meaningful, a person must be able to understand the information he/she is given, which must be sufficient for him/her to evaluate the available choices, and he/she must feel free...

Determining the appropriate amount of information or a person's ability to understand and evaluate it can be difficult in a health care context, and the very nature of the health care relationship and health care setting can lead to implicit if not explicit coercion.(Ethicsnetwork.org, nd)
Ethical Obligations of the Nurse

First, health professionals have an obligation to endeavor to enhance autonomy and facilitate the likelihood of a patient being able to make an autonomous decision. Second, where a patient is unable to make an autonomous decision, it is the duty of the health professional to act in the patient's best interests. However, even in these situations, an effort should be made to discover any previous preferences of the patient, or current wishes, in order to respect his/her autonomy as far as possible." (Ethicsnetwork.org, nd) Beneficence is usually considered to rely on an objective view of what would be best for the patient." (Ethicsnetwork.org, nd)

Analysis of an Ethical Problem

The work of Jonsen, Siegler and Winslade (1998) states the suggestion that each clinical case, when involving an ethical problem should undergo analysis through sue of four topics stated as follows:

1. Medical Indications;

2. Patient Preferences;

3. Quality of Life; and

4. Contextual Features. (Jonsen, Siegler, and Winslade, 1998)

Otherwise, stated analysis is conducted through the "social, economic, legal, and administrative context in which the case occurs." (Jonsen, Siegler, and Winslade, 1998)

Medication indications are related to the clinical discussion content including diagnosis and treatment of the patient's condition.

Patient preferences speak of the patient's values and "personal assessment of benefits and burdens" all of which are ethically relevant. (Jonsen, Siegler, and Winslade, 1998) Additionally stated is "If the patient is mentally incapacitated at the time a decision must be made, we must ask, "Who has the authority to decide on behalf of this patient? What are the ethical…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Browning, J.S. (2007) Ethical Issues in Nursing Practice; Identifications and Comparisons Across Clinical Specialty. Ethical Issues. 12 Jul 2007. Retrieved from: http://stti.confex.com/stti/congrs07/techprogram/paper_32839.htm

Johnstone, M.-J. (1999). Bioethics: a nursing perspective. (3rd ed.). Sydney: Harcourt Saunders.

Jonsen, AR, Siegler, M and Winslade, WJ (1998) Clinical Ethics: A Practical Approach to Ethical Decisions in Clinical Medicine, 4th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1998.

Kurtz, R.J., & Wang, J. (1991). The caring ethic: more than kindness, the core of nursing science. Nursing Forum, 26(1), 4-8.
Lakeman, R. (2000, 3-7 September). Nurses are more than tools: instrumentality and implications for nursing ethics. Paper presented at the Australian and New Zealand College of Mental Health Nurses 26th International Conference - Mental Health Nurses for a Changing World: Not just Surviving. Broadbeach, Queensland. Retrieved from: http://www.testandcalc.com/richard/resources/nurses_as_tools-paper_anzcmhn_2000.pdf
Wilson-Barnett, J. (1986) Ethical Dilemmas in Nursing. Journal of Medical Ethics 1986, 12, 123-126. Retrieved from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1375348/pdf/jmedeth00258-0013.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethical-Legal Nursing Discussions - Part II Moral
Words: 3541 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Ethical-Legal Nursing Discussions - Part II Moral Distress and Moral Integrity Comment by Ileana: OverviewMoral Distress in Advanced Practice NursingThe meaning of moral distress has been changing in nursing. No definition fits all dilemmas. Moral distress includes cultural beliefs, religious beliefs, educational level, and outside forces that influence thinking. It is important to learn that moral distress is an emotion managed by coping and emotional intelligence. Analyze the difference between moral distress

Ethical Issues of South Africa's
Words: 2537 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

South Africa consequently had to arrange for a down payment of $600 million at a rate perceived to be extraordinarily high. It was too late for the country to induce any negotiations of the deal. Serious agreements ensued thus maneuvering South Africa to pay back much of the nation's hard currency debt in a short period. This led to the emergence of a new democratic regime stemming from an

Nursing: Ethical Issues
Words: 1040 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Analysis #2 Nursing Issue/Dilemma Nurses face dilemmas of an ethical nature on a regular basis. This effectively means that from time to time, nurses are called upon make ethical decisions -- decisions that could have a huge impact on the well-being of patients. One of the current ethical issues being faced by nurses is whether or not to lie to patients. Recently, it was revealed that psychiatrists and nurses caring for

Ethical Issue in the Medical Field
Words: 1098 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethical Issue in the Medical Field Nurse practitioners at just about all levels and fields of practice encounter a variety of ethical problems throughout the span of their daily operations. In the preceding 30 years there has surfaced a remarkable global grant on nursing ethics providing complete philosophic evaluations involving the types of problems nurse practitioners encounter and also the procedures that may be best utilized for coping with them. The

Ethical Issues in Qualitative Research Qualitative Research
Words: 624 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Ethical Issues in Qualitative Research Qualitative research is research performed on relatively small sample groups. The research tends to be very specialized and does not require large amounts of numerical information for its conclusion to be drawn. While qualitative research is for the most part accepted into academia, there are still some concerns that arise with qualitative research that are not present in quantitative research. These concerns include conflicts of interest,

Nursing Scenario Analysis the Global Challenges of
Words: 655 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Scenario Analysis The Global Challenges of HIV / AIDS and the Living Environment People living with HIV / AIDS face physical, social and emotional needs that are genuine and must be acknowledged. As the AIDS epidemic spreads globally because of immigration and proliferation of unprotected sex and drug use, more communities are becoming affected by HIV / AIDS. Right from the point the disease is identified, people experience various forms of discrimination

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now