Verified Document

Ethical Dilemma In The First Scenario, The Essay

Ethical Dilemma In the first scenario, the vice president of a beer company has been asked to organize a lobbying effort to reduce the drinking age to 18. From a strictly legal perspective, there is nothing wrong with this request. The company has the legal right to lobby government for legislative changes that it wants to see. Indeed, the Citizens United ruling expands the privilege of free speech in elections to all bodies, individual or corporate. From a legal perspective the company can organize such an effort and if it is successful will have achieved its objectives through legal channels.

The ethics of the issue are a little fuzzier. There are different ethical perspectives that can be used to analyze this issue. One perspective is the consequentialist perspective. A consequentialist looks to the outcomes of one's actions to determine the moral worth of those actions. The different outcomes here can be wide-ranging, and are largely uncertain. The company's efforts will have the following outcomes whether the lobbying is successful for not -- it will be a PR disaster. There are enough anti-alcohol groups and watchdogs that there is basically no way for the company to lobby in secret. These groups will waste no opportunity to vilify the company for undertaking this lobbying effort. Whether this demonization would have an effect on the revenues or profits of the company is not known, since many anti-alcohol groups consist of non-drinkers anyway.

The utilitarian perspective is a consequentialist point-of-view that holds that the ideal solution is the one that produces the greatest good for the greatest number. In this case, while the shareholders of the company would certainly get a short-term boost from a lower drinking age, this must be weighed against the effects on society at large. What those outcomes might be depends on who you ask -- certaintly...

The real answer can actually be found by looking to other areas that have a dirnking age of 18 -- Louisiana, Quebec, South Africa and most of Europe. With a range of different cultures and societal approaches to alcohol to draw on, these regions will tell the story of what the outcome is most likely to be. With the possible exception of New Orleans, these areas are not generally subject to apocalyptic mayhem.
The deontological perspective holds that the ethics of an issue can be guided by a "categorical imperative," meanining that some choices cannot be justified by their effects, only by the rightness of the action. What defines a categorical imperative in this situation is open to interpretation. Certainly a Muslim would say that there is such an imperative and that it originates with God. Others would reject such an imperative. There is, in our society, no particular categorical imperative that would guide actions in this case, because of the separation of religion and state.

Morally, however, the laws in place for a reason. It is the prevailing view -- rightly or wrongly -- that people under the age of 21 are not capable of making responsible decisions concerning alcohol. Thus, the government has taken away that choice for them. This view tends to be guided more by religious sentiment than any empirical evidence, and indeed there is a wealth of evidence to support the idea that young adults respond better to legal access to alcohol than they do to clandestine consumption. There are more opportunities for supervision, for example, when youth are allowed to drink in public.

The most reasonable way to look at this issue is through the consequentialist lens, because governments are typicaly concerned with managing outcomes and the current drinking laws are…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Alexander, L. & Moore, M (2007) Deontological ethics. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved November 24, 2012 from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-deontological/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethical Dilemmas: Forensic Psychologists Assessing
Words: 4087 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

4, para.2). Therefore, the presence of an underlying mental illness that did not render a defendant unable to appreciate that he was committing a crime or compel him to commit it, may still be sufficient to mitigate the crime. Furthermore, a lack of mental ability that does not rise to the level of mental retardation may be introduced to mitigate the crime. Therefore, the forensic psychologist needs to be able

Ethical Dilemmas in Treatment Process Scenario --
Words: 672 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Dilemmas in Treatment Process Scenario -- Client presents with many issues that generate ethical dilemmas throughout the treatment process and specifically the client's use of illegal substances and the distribution of these drugs to others creating a cause for concern in regards to the welfare of client's child. Client reports that she is not using drugs in the child's presence however, the ability of the client to care for her

Ethical Dilemma the First Question That We
Words: 1488 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Dilemma The first question that we are to consider asks us to address many of the actual issues that come up in the course of medical decisions, and not simply in terms of cancer treatment. It is often the case that parents and children will not agree over a proposed treatment for the child; the ethical conflicts that can follow such a disagreement can be extremely traumatic. This is especially

Ethical Dilemma Facts: My Client, Justin King,
Words: 895 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Dilemma Facts: My client, Justin King, has informed me that he was intoxicated on the date of an accident he had on his Harley. However, because he was unconscious after the accident, no tests were conducted to determine whether he was under the influence. Furthermore, his toxicology reports from Paxton Medical Center were apparently erroneously destroyed by the hospital as part of its standard document retention policy. Justin has told

Ethical Dilemma With Lavonda Lavonda's
Words: 712 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

However, this option is ethically deplorable. Lavonda would have Soo-Chin's eventual misery on her conscience in addition to everything else. On the other hand, Lavonda can take her chances with pressing formal charges against Allen. This option comes with the possibility that Lavonda will walk away with less than nothing. If the case against Allen goes the way Karline seems to think it will, not only will Lavonda lose her

Ethical Dilemma Ethics Officer Response: Ethics Police
Words: 665 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethical Dilemma Ethics Officer response: Ethics Police officers are given additional powers to enforce the law that ordinary citizens do not possess, such as the right to stop and frisk suspects and if necessary to use proportional force against a suspect. However, with additional powers comes additional responsibility. On a human level, it is easy to understand why it might be tempting to act violently against someone committing child molestation. But an officer

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now