Verified Document

Ethical Debate On Savior Siblings: Ethics And Morality Essay

Savior Siblings: The Ethical Debate At a hospital, one of the most fulfilling tasks carried out daily is that of helping mothers usher in newborns into the world. Proud parents of beautiful healthy babies cannot contain their joy as they take their bundles of joy home ready to embark on a journey full of endless moments of happiness. However, some parents' joys are short lived when their children develop life threatening illnesses and complications that leave them struggling each day to finding the best treatments. Although they make the decision to do all it will take to save the child's life, their options are limited particularly because most of the most common illnesses, such as Diamond Blackfan Anemia or leukemia, often require blood or bone marrow transfers which they are not in a position to give as they are not necessarily the exact tissue matches for the concerned child.

Confronted with dilemmas on how to save such children's life, doctors have adopted the practice of creating babies that provide stem cells or transplants to their siblings. To create savior siblings, sometimes referred to as spare part children, a cell is usually sourced from an embryo then tested to determine if it will match the cells of the older ill sibling. If they are a match, the umbilical stem cells of the new baby can grow into any part of the sick child's body. Therefore, they are implanted into the affected area in the older child's body, which often results in them being cured. The hospital has been presented with an opportunity to help desperate parents using this method after being given a chance to hire a doctor, who will specialize in creating spare part children. As the head of research at the hospital, it is imperative to present a solid argument in light of the conflicting views...

This text takes a look at spare part children in detail and evaluates whether it is advisable to hire the doctor to provide the service of creating "spare parts" children in the future.
Discussion

According to Whitehouse (2010), experts estimate that there are more 250 spare part children in existence in the United States today. In fact, in Chicago alone, about 1000 families had adopted the in vitro fertilization (IVF) method to select a donor child for the benefit of an older sick sibling. Furthermore, the first family to attempt this, the Nash family of Colorado was able to save their six-year-old daughter's life using their son Adam, and the result was two happy healthy children (Whitehouse, 2010). The main implication of this is that if the procedure is done for the right reasons, then parents can help save their child's life. The doctor is an expert at what he does - therefore, it is only correct to hire him because in most cases, only the umbilical cord is harvested and since it is usually discarded under normal circumstances, there is no real harm caused to the spare part child. In agreement with Dr. Brookoff, a member of the ethics panel, the hospital should not withhold treatment that has been offered to other babies before, and resulted in improved health conditions. As such, doctors in the hospital should take all available options to save the sick child's life; even if it means creating a spare part child.

Another motivation for engaging the services of the doctor would be to appreciate the advancement of genetic technology in the field of medicine and to put it to use in this hospital. Today, parents have been provided with a chance to save a sick child by getting another child. If there are parents out there who…

Sources used in this document:
References

Overall, C. (2012). Why Have Children? The Ethical Debate. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Paola, F.A., Walker, R & Nixon, L.L. (2010) Medical Ethics and Humanities. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett Publishers, LLC.

Whitehouse, B. (2010). The Match: Savior Siblings and One Family's Battle to Heal Their Daughter. Boston: Beacon Press
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics Issues in Nursing Related to Savior Siblings
Words: 2457 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing Ethics Related to Savior Siblings This work in writing addresses the ethical issues relating to parents undergo a procedure to conceive a child that will perfectly match blood with a child who is sick for the purpose of saving the sick child's life. This procedure is known as preimplantation genetic diagnosis (POGD) This procedure, while providing hope to parents who are desperate, carries with it ethical implications and concerns. Preimplantation Genetic

Savior Baby Lit Review
Words: 731 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis: State of the Art Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) is used to analyze embryos genetically before their transfer into the uterus and offers couples at risk the chance to have an unaffected child, without facing termination of pregnancy. Embryos are obtained by in vitro fertilization with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), and are biopsied mostly on day 3; blastocyst biopsy is mentioned as a possible alternative; the genetic analysis is

Christian Values and Business Management
Words: 27724 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

Christian Biotechnology: Not a Contradiction in Terms Presented with the idea of "Bioethics" most people in the scientific community today immediately get the impression of repressive, Luddite forces wishing to stifle research and advancement in the name of morality and God. Unfortunately, this stereotype too often holds true. If one looks over the many independent sites on the Internet regarding bioethics, reads popular magazines and publications, or browses library shelves for

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now