The third and most contentious explanation charges unequal distribution of pollutants and hazardous toxins to environmental racism.
In this explanation race is a major factor. Research findings suggest, "...racism may be playing a role in the decision-making process" (p. 88). Industrial decision-makers frequently choose minority areas for disposal and industrial facilities. Concentrations of pollution are simply reflections of inherent injustice in the system. In other words, poor environmental quality in minority areas is a symptom of institutional discrimination. Thus a variety of groups, organizations, and such are implicated -- probably, they don't intend any harm, but their policies result in negative outcomes for poor areas and the people living in them. In Kitchener, Ontario, for instance, a housing development was built where formerly a waste landfill was located. Officials who approved the development knew it had been a waste landfill, but the project was going to be profitable. Buyers did not know when they bought the property what was going to be underneath them. In another place, Ralgreen, Ontario, a housing development was built on top of a former waste landfill; methane gas accumulated and caused explosions, and eventually everybody had to move out. The city knew about the presence of methane but kept it secret to "prevent panic." By "coincidence" the people living there were low-income people.
Regardless of whether one accepts any of these explanations for how the unequal distribution of toxins happens, it can't be denied that socio-economic class is always a factor where toxic risks are present. Race issues are always part of it, although measures to assess prejudice are never part of the research data, so it can't be proven with empirical research that environmental racism exists -- at least, so far. Nevertheless, minorities are suffering more from the effects of poor environmental quality. On the bright side, an article titled "Talking Race" (2003) , avoiding pollution and other risks, when they make their decisions. Moreover, environmental problems can't really be separated from problems of poverty, racism, sexism and unemployment. At the risk of sounding anti-capitalist, economic growth should not be allowed to take precedence over environmental health. Decisions should be made on the basis of meeting human and ecological needs and enhancing the quality of life. Democracy demands that minorities and poor people be allowed to speak and have equal voices. Finally, environmental threats should be eliminated before they happen instead of trying clean up a big mess afterwards.
References
Friedman, D. (1998). The "environmental racism" hoax. The American Enterprise, 9 (6), 75-78.
Talking race (2003). Alternatives Journal, 29 (1), 3-4.
Warriner, G.K., McSpurren, K. And Nabalamba, a. (2001). Social justice and environmental equity: Distributing environmental…
Poor peoples and poor nations in the world accept the false and harmful notion that the lack of development meant risky, low-paying jobs and pollution. The economically vulnerable and poor communities, poor states, poor nations and poor regions have succumbed to the notion. The movement demanded that no community, nation, whether rich or poor, whatever the color should be made dumping grounds for these deadly wastes. The movement also
Environmental Justice in the United States: Policies, Beliefs & People/Places Involved During the course of my college career, my interests and passions have changed, gradually evolving to an intensified mix of all that my Interdisciplinary Studies major encompasses. I began my college career seeking a Mass Communication degree; a course of study that focused primarily on community organization and mobilization. After feeling the harsh reality of advertising and public relations evils, I
For example, unequal protection may result from land-use decisions that determine the location of residential amenities and disamenities. Unincorporated, poor, and communities of color often suffer a "triple" vulnerability of noxious facility siting." (Bullard, 1998) Finally, 'Social Equity' is that which "assesses the role of sociological factors (race, ethnicity, class, culture, life styles, political power, etc.) on environmental decision making. Poor people and people of color often work in the
This has often made it very difficult for black individuals to become high educational and social achievers. Racists then twist the reasons behind this lack of achievement and use it as evidence that members of the group are inferior (Gimlin, 2005). Racism and discrimination are both common threads in prejudiced activity toward black women, and this works to perpetuate the problems that they have faced in the past and
Social justice is a multifaceted and complex concept that has evolved over time to embody ideals of fairness, equality, and human rights within societies. It encompasses a wide range of issues such as economic equality, access to education, health care, the rights of marginalized communities, and more (Rawls, 1971). The pursuit of social justice aims to ensure that individuals and groups have equitable opportunities and are not subjected to discrimination
The Emerging Crisis of Climate Refugees: Crafting a Comprehensive ResponseThe consequences of climate change are progressively more conspicuous, resulting in a distinctive crisis characterized by climate refugees. These climate refugees are individuals who are compelled to abandon their homes in response to environmental disasters and the impacts of climate change, thereby presenting a multifaceted challenge. This complex issue has ignited extensive debate and deliberation among experts and scholars, focusing on
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now