Aldo Leopold would agree. His "land ethic" calls for a new philosophy that includes a moral respect for the land. Like Cronon, Leopold advocates an "ecological conscience," that includes a "conviction of individual responsibility," (435). Cronon realizes that humility and respect as well as "critical self-consciousness" should be the guiding forces of the environmentalist movement (p. 387).
However, Leopold too upholds a dualistic worldview that appears to be ingrained in American cultural consciousness. For Leopold, there are two different groups of people pulling in opposite directions: those who view land as soil and therefore commodity production, and those that view land as biota. Leopold makes a snickering comment about organic farming as well: "the discontent that labels itself 'organic farming' while bearing some of the earmarks of a cult, is nevertheless biotic in its direction," (p. 435). Cronon would note that the criticism of organic farming is itself a product of the insipid and ironic dualism that pervades the environmentalist movement. There is no reason why all farming cannot be organic in a true "ecological ethic."
Wilderness is a product of shifting social, economic, political, and cultural realities in the United States at the end of the nineteenth century, according to Cronon. The social and economic revolutions taking place were in no small part due to industrialism. Were it not for the industrial development and urbanization, the current concept of wilderness as safe haven would probably have never been born. Wilderness was created out of nostalgia for an "older, simpler, truer world," (p. 384). People who lived in cities needed to create their opposite as an alternative for the harsh conditions of city life, including pollution. Alice Hamilton worked with immigrant victims of harsh factory working conditions and observed the effects of industrialism on
Calling the labor practices a form of exploitation, Hamilton's commentary shows how strong and how necessary the impetus for wilderness creation was. Teddy Roosevelt's conviction that wilderness must be saved was ultimately a positive force in American history. After all, as Cronon points out, wilderness has the potential to remind people what to appreciate in our own back yards. The problem is that few people do take the time to appreciate the frog in their back yard because somehow it seems more mundane and trivial than the bald eagle on the top of the mountain.
Cronon's main motive in writing "The Trouble with Wilderness" is not to criticize the environmental or conservation movements but to "abandon the dualism that sees the tree in the garden as artificial," (387). All nature is sacred and sublime, including the grasses on the prairies and the marshlands in Florida. Labeling some parts of the natural world as "wilderness" makes those parts valuable in the public consciousness and consequentially, the public may ignore the beauty outside their bedroom window. The trees in Central Park are as valuable as the trees in Yosemite; labeling only creates artificial segregation. Ironically, the "wilderness" areas are now places of booming tourism and are hardly untouched by human hands.
Cronon also shows that Hetch Hetchy was one Eden among many in the world. The upside of the "wilderness" movement is that it did cause a widespread revival in respect for the land, which has spawned a cultural revolution in ethical thought such as Leopold describes. However, referring to some parts of the world as "wilderness" and others as simply "a park" is a problematic perspective borne of cultural biases. Wilderness was in fact created by forcibly removing Indians and thus, wilderness implies "the reassure of the history from which it sprang," (p. 385). Cronon asks that all environmentalists pay attention to the cultural…
Sandia Mountains Environmental History of Sandia Mountains The view from the top of Sandia Peak is breathtaking. Showing off some of Nature's finest work, the Tramway glides along the cable climbing the rugged Sandia Mountains presenting spectacular views of the Rio Grande Valley and nearby Sandia Crest. Even though you're just a few miles from Albuquerque, the 15 minute tram ride has taken you far away from the everyday world. As your
. . political and law enforcement cronyism and corruption. . . And last, an surprising astonishing level of incompetence which symbolizes much of the authorized intelligence- meeting and investigative developments (Block, 1985, p.310). This lack of enforcement taking part in helping with the waste especially after a natural disaster such as a tornado will possibly allow such practices as illegal dumping to last unchecked. "The ideal answer to hazardous waste problems
Getting the Facts Straight After a meeting the public need to know that they have been 'listened to'. A good idea is to schedule enough meetings to a. Present the case you are making (such as Puget Sound is in dire trouble), b. Distribute this knowledge to the public, c. Ask for input from the public. It is important to have people whose sole job at the meeting is to jot
It offers a good theory as it emphasizes on the production and export of those items for which a country possesses a comparative advantage. Furthermore, through its focus on the reduction of taxes and tariffs in international trade and the adherent practices, the theory of comparative costs has set the basis for the contemporaneous processes of market liberalization and globalization. But the theory has not been spared from criticism. Oumar
Nightingale met a friend Richard Monckton Miles in 1842. Then in 1844, Nightingale asked Dr. Howe if she could do a charitable job in a hospital like the catholic nuns, and refused her marriage to her cousin, Henry Nicholson. By 1845, Nightingale started training herself in the nearby Salisbury Hospital, but her parents were not happy about it, seeing nursing as an inappropriate job for a well to do
history from 1865 to the present day. To focus the research, select six subtopics (specific events or developments related to the topic, separated in time); three from before 1930 and three from after. Immigrants There are more than 50 million immigrants (legal and illegal) and their U.S.-born children (under 18) in the United States as of August 2012. As of the last decade, most immigrants come from the following countries: Honduras
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now