Verified Document

Employers And What They Can Do To Employees For Complaining On Social Media Case Study

Discharged for Facebook Comments The National Labor Relation Board (NLRB) has protected the right of free speech of employees posting messages on social media so long as that speech is limited to discussions about "wages and working conditions ... in an effort to improve them" (Kasle). In so far as Nelson's comments on Facebook regarding her supervisor were not constructive in the sense of advocating an improved workplace environment, they are not protected by NLRB's law. Thus, Nelson's employer did have the right to terminate her employment.

When does an employer have a legal right to discipline or discharge an employee for comments the employee makes about the company? It is a controversial question. Free speech advocates might suggest that all speech is protected. However, business advocates suggest that corporations and companies have a right to protect themselves. In this context, NLRB has stipulated that all criticism of employers must be done constructively on social media, and not simply come across as venting. Such stipulation should not appease free speech advocates because it is clearly an arbitrary and politically correct way of determining that employees may not say what they think about employers on the Internet. Nonetheless, the law is clear: employers do have a legal right to discipline and/or discharge employees who violate the NLRB's statute. As Jessica Sussman points out: "Employees have the right to discuss wages, hours, working conditions on Facebook or other social networking sites with coworkers and this activity is protected ... [so long as the discussion is part of a] concerted activity for the purpose of collective bargaining or mutual aid or protection."

Were I representing the company for which Nelson worked and the NLRB regional director asked if I would be willing to settle the union's charge voluntarily, I would state that I was willing to settle the charge voluntarily...

The reason would be this: companies all too often can come across as monolithic and inhuman. In today's day and age, companies need to cultivate good employee-manager relations. When Nelson's supervisor refused to allow her time to contact her union rep, he aggravated the issue and sparked a need in Nelson to vent to her social networking peers. That is perfectly understandable. So while my company does have the legal right to terminate Nelson for criticizing her supervisors, it does not present the company as being employee-friendly. Rather than insist on legalities, I would prefer to settle the union's charge voluntarily and come to an understanding with Nelson to see if she would at least accept some form of disciplinary measure while for our part we could at least admit that her supervisor had taken a misstep by blocking her desire for contact with a union rep.
This is not to say that the company committed an unfair labor practice by (1) discharging Nelson for her Facebook postings or (2) denying Nelson an opportunity to meet with her local union representative during an investigatory meeting with her supervisor, or (3) enforcing an overly broad blogging and Internet use policy. The company does not want to admit any wrongdoing and neither does Nelson. That is all perfectly understandable. But let us look into the matter as objectively as possible.

Nelson was asserting her Weingarten Rights when she asked to meet with her union representative during the investigation (Discipline and Workplace Rights). The purpose of doing so, for Nelson's part, was to ensure that a union rep could be present to witness the investigatory process and to ask pertinent questions when necessary. This is part of employee protection against unjust persecution on the part of the employer. It is, after all, "the right of employees to have union…

Sources used in this document:
References

"Discipline and Workplace Rights." AFSCME. 13 Nov 2009. Web.

Kasle, Whitney. "When Can You Legally Terminate an Employee Because of a Misstep

on Social Media?" New Brand. 28 Jan 2014. Web.

Sussman, Jessica. "Are there any circumstances under which it is unlawful to discipline an employee for posting negative comments on Facebook or another social networking site?" XPertHR. 2015. Web.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Media - A New Kind of
Words: 2405 Length: 6 Document Type: Dissertation

Social Media - a New Kind of Security Problem in Business The Newest Threat to any Business: Social Media Social media is one of the most significant changes that has come about in communication today. However, it can also have serious implications for business and for the privacy and protection of businesses and employees. Overall, social media is not something that can be ignored by businesses today, because it can offer worries

Social Media Policies
Words: 822 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Social Media Recently, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) made its first social media-related ruling. The board adjudicated a case against Costco, and in this case the NLRB struck down Costco's social media policy as standing in violation of the workers' right to free speech (Little, 2012). The Board found that Costco's policy on social media usage was overly broad. The policy held that employees were prohibited from posting statements that

Social Media and Healthcare
Words: 3856 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Legal Ethics of E-Mail and Social Media and Its Applicability to the Healthcare Industry Consequences of Social Media p.3 Perils of Building an Online Network p.6 Caution with Employee Email Accounts p.8 Issues when Endorsing other Companies p.10 Benefits of Social Media p.13 p.15 Legal Ethics of E-mail and Social Media and its Applicability to the Healthcare Industry Social media has without a doubt changed the way we live, the way we view the world and the way we interact with one another.

Social Networking Sites Began in
Words: 493 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

The primary target market for Facebook is between the ages of 22-34. The secondary target market is between 35-54. The strengths are that it is addictive, has a clean layout is open platform and is a real-world network (unlike Myspace). It has relatively few weaknesses, other than low revenue per user. Threats are other social networking sites, instant messenger services and photo sharing sites. There are opportunities in new markets

Employee Turnover and Bus
Words: 11018 Length: 2 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

drivers endure a multitude of work-related health issues due to the nature of their work. They drive consistently long hours. They must be weary of potential accidents, and do not receive high pay. This can lead to a higher than normal employee turnover rates, which lends to a lower quality of service for customers. Researchers have aimed at identifying what specific work-related health problems plague bus drivers. Research shows bus

Employee Turnover and Bus
Words: 9290 Length: 30 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

drivers endure a multitude of work-related health issues due to the nature of their work. They drive consistently long hours. They must be weary of potential accidents, and do not receive high pay. This can lead to a higher than normal employee turnover rates, which lends to a lower quality of service for customers. Researchers have aimed at aimed at identifying what specific work-related health problems plague bus drivers. Research

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now