Verified Document

Employer Employee Dispute Term Paper

¶ … Against "Opinion-Based" Decision Making: The Wal-Mart Case

One of the most reviled events in the business world -- from the largest corporations to the smallest privately-owned business is the discrimination lawsuit. In whatever form it takes; whether age, sex, religion, disability, or any of the other myriad conditions for which discrimination is illegal, the ramifications for the company can be severe. In the current class action case against Wal-Mart, allegations of gender discrimination impact literally thousands of current and former employees, who stand to gain significant compensation should the court find against the retail giant. Sadly, such a case could have been prevented entirely by paying strict attention to anti-discrimination policies, training and research.

Wal-Mart holds sway as the nation's biggest employer (Wal-Mart.com, 2005). As such, it not only enjoys tremendous success, but is also faced with an immense amount of possible liability should it fail to follow through on issues of equal opportunity and anti-discrimination. In order to avoid this, Wal-Mart, like countless other companies, has established policies in place, backed up by training procedures designed to prevent any lapse between its legal responsibilities and its practices. Unfortunately, according to many, this failed.

As is the standard in corporate America, Wal-Mart asserts that it fully follows all Equal Opportunity laws in the United States, as well as abroad (2005). It also asserts that it...

However, given the current large scale class action suit, it seems that somewhere those policies and procedures failed. In June of 2004, a federal court authorized the expansion of a sexual discrimination lawsuit filed in California to a class action, estimated to encompass more than 1.6 million workers (Curry, 2004). In the case, workers claim that, since 1988, women workers were underpaid in relation to their male counterparts company wide (even across different geographical regions -- indicating an "institutionalization" of the practice), that they are not promoted at the same rate as men, and that the highest posts in the company are disproportionately male (when compared to other large corporations) (2004).
Of course, Wal-Mart disputes this case, arguing (typically) that the measurable inequalities between its male and female employees are simply a reflection of qualification and interest -- and not of a systematic favoritism of one sex over the other. However, the Judge in the federal case seemed to think otherwise, and thus expanded the case to the currently estimate 1.6 person class.

Clearly, the problem was exacerbated by (as it has been in many other similar cases, including the recent Home Depot settlement) the allowance for "personal judgment" in hiring practices (Curry, 2004). Although the utilization of personal judgment has long been held to be a particular "American" virtue, in today's world,…

Sources used in this document:
Although many may mourn the loss of personal judgment in employee decision making, careful training can demonstrate the practicality of the shift away from subjective decision making. Further, education on the nature of "hunch" motivation, especially with regard to culture and the transmission of stereotypes can help alleviate any misgivings. In the end, there simply is no avoiding the fact that using subjective judgment increases liability, as well as unfair labor practices. In order to safeguard both the company's interests, as well as the employees, the shift from personal opinion to statistical justification must be made.

Curry, Myron. (2004). "Wal-Mart Class Action Gender Discrimination Case Holds Warnings for All Employers." Business Training Media. Web site. Retrieved on July 12, 2005, from, http://www.business-marketing.com/store/article-walmart.html

Wal-Mart. Staff. (2005). "Employment Overview." Wa-Mart.com. Home Page. Retrieved on July 12, 2005, from, http://www.walmartfacts.com/doyouknow/default.aspx#a26
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Employee Relations: Industrial Conflicts and Collective Disputes:
Words: 1899 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Employee Relations: Industrial Conflicts and Collective Disputes: Efficient and good industrial relations are usually dependent on the consistent, just and reasonable treatment as well as participation of the staff in issues and decisions that have an impact on them. The ideological framework of industrial relations involves the maintenance and enhancement of human resources procedures and policies. This framework of industrial relations also ensures that there is unbiased and consistent application of joint

Employee Handbook Addressing the Issue of Workplace
Words: 1099 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

employee handbook addressing the issue of workplace equity and nondiscrimination in a health care organization. The essay includes various issues related to the non-discrimination laws and the benefits of implementation of anti-discrimination laws. An employee handbook is a manual for employees and works as a staff handbook which is drafted by the employer. Employee handbook contains policies and procedures for the employees. It has all the terms and conditions of

Employee Representation a Labor Union Refers to
Words: 640 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Employee Representation A labor union refers to an association of employees that have come together in pursuit of common goals, such as better pay. Labor relations are wider in scope; they refer to the interactions between the labor unions (employees' representatives) and employers - and usually deal with the maintenance of collective bargaining agreements. Labor relations date way back to the formation of the very first significant unions: the Knights of Labor,

Union Labor Disputes Canada Wal-Mart
Words: 6077 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

But when it just recently occurred in 2004 at a store in Jonquiere, British Columbia, the reader must appreciate that a real battle had been won. The original efforts of that particular store for example had the local labor Commission reject certification by a margin of 74 to 65. When the union announced that it won the coveted certification at Quebec, it was quite a blow to the retailer.

Human Resource, Conflict Management and Employee Relations
Words: 1898 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Integrate the Relevant Information Found Both In Organizations Today and in Research Human resource management HRM is considered to be an integral part of any organization to make it run effectively and efficiently. Fundamentally, the principal objective of HRM is to upsurge the economic profitability from employees through making them organized in a productive, inventive and powered force (Price 2007, p.31). HR function includes many activities like planning, recruitment and appraisal (Pulignano,

ADR Alternate Dispute Regulation and
Words: 1969 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Id. At 118. Additionally, refraining from attacking another party's reliability, but instead, reducing risks and praising honorable activity will help to engender an incentive for the other party to develop trustworthiness. Id. At 119-21. According to the authors, "people are more likely to behave reliably if they know their reliability is appreciated." Id. At 121. However, the authors stress that one must not place trust in an individual when

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now