Verified Document

Electronic Medical/Health Records Utilizing Electronic Thesis

Costa, attorney and associate at Greenberg Traurig, LLP, in Boston, Mass. However, he adds, most of these organizations maintain warehouses where they store paper records that have been transcribed to electronic form. "There is resistance from some about going to a completely electronic format because there are still some questions about privacy," Costa says. "There is definitely still a place for paper-based medical records, but the focus from now on will be on making sure that information can be adequately secured" (Fiske). Frederick Geilfuss, partner in the health law department of Foley & Lardner, in Milwaukee, Wis. says that while many larger providers have already begun the shift, he has not encountered any institutions that have made a complete transition -- an event that he believes is still in the distant future. "There are quite a few doctors out there who are not technologically minded and who prefer paper records," he explains. Changing from paper to electronic records requires organization, as well as technology, because a switch made on a going-forward basis would result in two sets of medical records -- paper and electronic -- with an increased potential for confusion (Fiske).

Health Information Management (HIM) professionals using paper-based systems are confronted by many of the same challenges regarding HIPAA compliance as their colleagues who have switched to electronic records. Although the legislation was originally intended to ensure security and privacy of electronically stored and transmitted information, it has evolved to include all types of communications. "HIPAA extends to any manifestation of patient confidentiality, including what people do in medical offices and what they say about confidential information," explains Henry E. Schwartz, partner in the business and corporate department in the Baltimore, Md., office of Blank, Rome, Comisky, and McCauley, LLP (Fiske).

The HIPAA security requirements for paper-based records are the same as those that apply to oral communications and electronic information, Costa explains. It will be necessary to ensure that the minimal amount of information is disclosed at any time, and providers will need to adhere to restrictions about uses of patient information for medical research and quality assurance purposes. Monetary penalties for noncompliance can range from $10,000 to $250,000, depending upon whether disclosure of information is accidental or for commercial profit, he says. There are also criminal penalties ranging from five to ten years in prison for willful release of patient information without patient consent (Fiske).

While securing paper medical records in either an office or at an off-site facility is often lock-and-key simple, it is always important to monitor and limit employee access to vital and confidential information. "There is really nothing new under the sun, as far as security measures, for paper medical records," says Schwartz. "Medical information has always been confidential, and, in the larger sense, HIPAA didn't change that." Although HIPAA does not specify the means by which requirements must be met, most security measures are simply based on common sense, beginning with an assessment of office practices in order to determine the current state of security for written and oral information, he says (Fiske).

Among the measures that Schwartz recommends are locking medical records files and restricting physical access to them; implementing a policy to ensure that no one enters medical files without authorization and reason to do so; developing a fax policy to ensure that faxed medical information is received by the person for whom it was intended; and, perhaps most simply, not leaving medical files on desks or tables around the office. "It's great that medical records are protected when they are in a storage cabinet," Schwartz comments, "but what happens when someone takes them out to look at them? Does the person leave them lying around while he or she leaves to get a cup of coffee" (Fiske).

As bulky paper records accrue, many healthcare organizations opt to store them in off-site warehouses or storage facilities. Historically, this has not presented any problems of which Schwartz is aware, but he cautions administrators to include security policies in contracts with off-site storage providers. He adds that, when disposed of, paper medical records should always be shredded. "If anyone gets a hold of them," he advises, "they should be unreadable and unrecognizable" (Fiske)

Discussion -- Perhaps EHR's aren't Safe Enough for a National Roll-out?

Will EHR's eventually make patient records safer? The answer, as we will see, is, most likely, yes. However, how do we get there? If we want and need a safer system, we also need a usable, economic system for all types and sizes of medical facilities....

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

And this country will need solid, well-designed health information technology (HIT) networks to store, distribute, and keep safe all of that private medical information.
As mentioned previously, when President-elect Obama outlined his economic stimulus package earlier this month, he emphasized the need to invest in the healthcare system's infrastructure by pushing for electronic health records (EHR), nationwide: "We will make sure that every doctor's office and hospital in this country is using cutting edge technology and electronic medical records so that we can cut red tape, prevent medical mistakes, and help save billions of dollars each year" (Mahar).

The problem is that the physicians and hospitals who the government expected to invest in electronic health records are least likely to benefit financially. For example, if electronic medical records reduce the number of redundant tests, the insurer and/or the patient enjoy the financial benefit: the physician does not. In fact, if the physician does the tests in his own office, he loses money every time he doesn't need to repeat a test. Over time, health care providers might realize savings from EHRs, but experience suggests that it would take at least ten years (Mahar).

Since insurers would be the first to enjoy savings from more efficient care, it would make sense for them to provide the initial funding for Health Information Technology (it). But so far, relatively few for-profit insurers have stepped up to the plate.

In most developed countries, the government (i.e. taxpayers) has played a major role in developing and funding EHRs. The U.S. decided to wait for market competition to do the job. So far, that hasn't worked out very well, and the new administration seems ready to take a more proactive role. But before making an enormous investment, someone should ask about the state of the art: are EHRs ready for a national roll-out (Mahar)?

The answer, says Dr. Scot Silverstein, the director of Drexel University's Institute for Healthcare Informatics, is No! Over at Dr. Roy Poses' Health Care Renewal, Silverstein has posted an open letter to President Obama, applauding him for the it initiative, but warning that at this point in time "Health Information Technology (HIT) is an experiment" -- at least in the U.S. It is, yet, unproven on a large scale. There have been many warning signs that it is an experiment that could go awry" (Mahar)

Silverstein notes that "after years of effort and billions of dollars spent," the use of HIT in this country remains limited. And where electronic health records are used, "Clinicians (physicians, nurses and others) are struggling to use awkwardly designed HIT, designed as if for quiet, solitary business offices yet costing millions of dollars per hospital."

Silverstein blames information technology experts who do not recognize the difference between healthcare and other industries. They design systems that might work well in a bank but will not cut it in a hectic ER. Silverstein stresses that clinicians must be involved in the design of healthcare it (Mahar).

A 2005 article in the Journal of Biomedical Informatics expands on this point: "Designers of healthcare information technology (HIT) must be exquisitely sensitive to the non-linear, context dependent, fast communication-dependent, interruption-filled, uncertain, and collaborative nature of hospital clinical practice," writes the University of Pennsylvania's Dr. Ross Koppel. The piece concludes: "That some HIT development has occurred without this disciplinary input and wisdom is deeply regrettable (Mahar).

Three years later, little has improved, says Silverstein. Rather than becoming more sensitive to the needs of a hospital, "the healthcare industry and the HIT sector have been reliably tone deaf on these issues, which results in the very low diffusion of HIT. Platitudes, excuses, and blame placed solely on end users (i.e., the clinicians) are the norm" (Mahar).

Yes, a large investment in health it would create jobs but, as Silverstein points out, given the state of vendor-designed EHRs, and the trouble healthcare workers and hospitals are having with them, "While HIT problems may be good for the it and management consulting businesses, they are not good for the healthcare business, already struggling under great financial duress."

If phrases like "HIT hell" and "irrational exuberance" don't give you pause, consider another open letter to the Obama Healthcare Team on TheHealthCareBlog.com (THCB). This missive was penned by David C. Kibbe MD MBA, a Family Physician and Senior Advisor to the American Academy of Family Physicians who consults on healthcare professional and consumer technologies, and Brian Klepper PhD, a health care market analyst and a Founding Principal of Health…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Ball, Marion, Carla Smith and Richard Bakalar. "Personal Health Records: Empowering Consumers." Journal of Healthcare Information Management (2007): 76-83.

Brenner, Bill. "Secure Electronic Medical Records: Fact or Fiction?" 3 March 2009. The Standard. 10 April 2009 <http://www.thestandard.com/news/2009/03/03/secure-electronic-medical-records-fact-or-fiction>.

Bright, Beckey. "Benefits of Electronic Health Records." 29 November 2007. The Wall Street Journal. 10 April 2009 http://hfs.illinois.gov/assets/ilhie_112907.pdf

Byers, Jay. "Medical Records Scanning: Convert your paper-based patient records into electronic records." December 2008. EMR Services of Canada. 9 April 2009 <http://emrcanada.wordpress.com/2008/12/30/paper-medical-records-utterly-irrational-gingrich/>.
Denmark, Donald. "Electronic Health Records: The Evidence-Based Advantage." 1 March 2008. Allbusines.com. 10 April 2009 <http://www.allbusiness.com/health-care/medical-practice-nuclear-medicine/10591686-1.html>.
Fiske, Hannah. "PULP PROTECTION: SECURING PAPER-BASED MEDICAL RECORDS." 17 June 2002. For the Record. 10 April 2009 <http://www.fortherecordmag.com/archives/ftr_061702.shtml>.
Garets, Dave and Mike Davis. "Electronic Medical Records vs. Electronic Health Records: Yes, There is a Difference." 26 January 2006. HIMMS Analytics. 9 April 2009 <http://www.himssanalytics.org/docs/WP_EMR_EHR.pdf>.
U.S. News and World Report. 10 April 2009 .
and Human Services. 9 April 2009 <http://www.hhs.gov/healthit/ahic/materials/meeting03/ehr/HFMA_OvercomingBarriers.pdf
Hoholik, Suzanne. "Are Your Medical Records Secure?" 7 December 2008. The Columbus Dispatch. 10 April 2009 <http://www.columbusdispatch.com/live/content/local_news/stories/2008/12/07/EMR.ART_ART_12-07-08_B1_LOC5H3M.html?sid=101>.
Mahar, Maggie. "Irrational Exuberance Over Electronic Medical Records." 17 December 2008. Healthbeat. 10 April 2009 <http://www.healthbeatblog.org/2008/12/irrational-exuberance-over-electronic-medical-records-.html>.
Szwarc, Sandy. "The hospital was unaware any records had been stolen..." 23 December 2008. Junkfood Science. 9 April 2009 <http://junkfoodscience.blogspot.com/2008/12/hospital-was-unaware-any-medical.html>.
Tang, Paul C., et al. "Personal Health Records: Definition, Benefits, and Strategies for Overcoming Barriers to Adoption." 29 November 2005. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association. 9 April 2009 <http://www.jamia.org/cgi/content/abstract/M2025v1>.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Medical Assistant and Intravenous Therapy
Words: 644 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Intravenous Therapy or IV Fluids are introduced intravenously into the body in order to replace supply and electrolytes (Pearson 2010). These are large amounts of fluid, electrolytes or nutrients administered to a patient who needs them and cannot take them orally. Medication is also administered intravenously by a physician or by a nurse. The physician informs the nurse on the type, amount, and the rate of the solution to be injected.

The Role of Medical Assistants in Claiming Reimbursement
Words: 2555 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

All Medical Assistants The importance of customer service in a tertiary healthcare setting As you all know, the healthcare industry has been transformed in substantive ways as a result of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and the growing need for timely recordation of services rendered in order to attain appropriate reimbursement of physician services and overall expense reimbursement for the medical facility. This memorandum explains how and why customer service

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe
Words: 1347 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe Medicine? Does Jerry's medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or why not? Generally, LPNs and medical assistants are qualified to dispense medication prescribed by a physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). A medical assistant is a trained medical professional who works under the supervision of a board-certified physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). Typically, a medical assistant's work is administrative, but it may also include clinical

Medical Treatment and Hospitals
Words: 655 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

EMTALA stands for Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act and was passed in 1986 to guarantee the public has access to emergency services irrespective of the ability to pay. The main reason for its implementation is section 1867 of the Social Security Act. This part imposes concise requirements on any Medicare-participating hospitals that provide MSE/emergency services. Before EMTALA, people were turned down for medical treatment if they could not pay,

Medical Ethics Interview Medical Ethics Interview Healthcare
Words: 1637 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Medical Ethics Ethics Interview Medical Ethics Interview Healthcare providers include nurses, doctors, social workers and a number of other professions that seem to exist on the periphery of the helping field. One of those on the outside, that many do not consider when looking at the healthcare profession, are professional counselors. Since the term "counselor" has been diluted by everyone from friends to lawyers, it is unclear what one is talking about when

Medical Marijuana and Social Control: Escaping Criminalization
Words: 1145 Length: 4 Document Type: Article Review

Medical Marijuana and Social Control: Escaping Criminalization and Embracing Medicalization Marijuana, also known as cannabis is derived from the cannabis plant (cannabis sativa). The ingredients of the plant, trahydro-cannabinol, widely known as HTC are part of the plant that gives the 'high' effect. The use of marijuana as a drug has been illegal in many states of America and the nations of the world. In the article 'medical marijuana and social

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now