Verified Document

Electoral College The Current Function Of The Article Critique

Related Topics:

Electoral College The current function of the Electoral College is that each state has a set number of votes for the President, based on the population of that state. The candidate with the most votes in that state would receive all of that state's Electoral College votes. The system has come under fire from critics would point out the flaws in this system. For example, it does not differentiate between a landslide victory and a squeaker, and the Electoral College encourages politicians to only compete in battleground states, ignoring the needs of other states entirely. These concerns are justified, in that a President can be elected despite the other candidate having more votes. This does not sound like a perfectly-functioning democratic system. Critics of the Electoral College have proposed instead that the national popular vote be the method used to determine the Presidency.

As an alternative to the Electoral College,...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

From a functional perspective, the patchwork of different state electoral systems is not built for a national popular vote, as Gregg (2011) points out. Countries that have national election bodies might be equipped for such a vote, but the United States is not. Another issue with the national popular vote is that it might create a higher level of polarization among the electorate than already exists and candidates build their platforms around catering to specific groups that vote in large blocks. The baby boomers are entering their senior years, for example, and this will characterize their voting needs -- such a large block needs to be attended to. Likewise, the Hispanic and African-American votes can be block-like, and candidates would need to tailor to cultural and demographic needs rather than the needs of those in specific states. The NPV plan, therefore, does not eliminate…

Sources used in this document:
Referenced:

Gregg, Gary L. "Unpopular vote: enemies of the Electoral College aim to scrap the Founders' design." The American Conservative 10.12 (2011)

Underhill, Wendy. "Changing up the electoral college?" State Legislatures 38.1 (2012)
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Electoral College: Should the U.S. Push for
Words: 2729 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Electoral College: Should the U.S. Push for Reform or Elimination? When citizens of the United States vote in a presidential election, many believe that they are taking part in a direct election of the president (Sutin 2003). However, because of the existence of the electoral college, established in the U.S. Constitution, this is not really true. The electoral college is a set group of "electors" who are nominated by political activists and

Electoral College Is Truly Representative
Words: 2547 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

This is just as important as having a president who is equally representative of the interests of each state. The Founding Fathers succeeded admirably in the area of state-based election of the president, but did they succeed in also ensuring we have a democratically elected president? Are public presidential elections really shams, leaving us with a president who is essentially appointed by political party favorites, or does he represent

Electoral College and Constitution
Words: 650 Length: 2 Document Type:

American Democracy The Electoral College as it currently functions is a way of getting around the "popular vote" -- as Underhill (2012) notes in "Changing Up the Electoral College?" However, Gregg (2011) puts an entirely different spin on the Electoral College by viewing it as "a compromise" between the Federalist and Anti-Federalist agendas that went into forming the Constitution (p. 34). Gregg asserts that the Electoral College allows special representatives to

Function of the American Government the American
Words: 3137 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Function of the American Government The American government has had a long-standing checks-and-balances efficiency within its three-branch system. Because of the separate governable powers within the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of the United States, American law has been approved after many constant revisions and discussions. It is extremely commendable that the legislative branch takes into account the representation of both "state" and "people." This is not to say, of

Electoral Politics As Detailed Quite Eloquently in
Words: 1039 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Electoral Politics As detailed quite eloquently in Chapter 15 of Haywood's text, having political power is not simply getting one's way in a crude and overt manner, like passing or pushing a bill through congress. Rather, power also involves the task of agenda-setting itself, putting an idea upon the national platform of discourse. The author additionally cites Bacharatz and Baratz as critical in defining not simply making yes or no the

British Electoral System Reform Over
Words: 7210 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

The Constitution is based on several key principals the most notable would include: separation of powers as well as checks and balances. Separation of powers is when there are clearly defined powers that are given to the various branches of: the government, the federal government and the states. Checks and balances is when one branch of the government will have the power to the check the authority of another

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now