Verified Document

Effectiveness Of Standards As A Vehicle For School Reform Term Paper

Standards and School Reform While standardized testing has been in use in U.S. education for decades, until recently, it was most often used for special purposes, such as college entrance: the SATs, and the GREs for graduate school and so on. IQ testing had been part of the educational landscape, also. However, it was only after 1983's government-backed report that found American children at educational risk that standards became the main tool for establishing educational goals and determining whether they had been met. Unfortunately, this thrust produced not better educated children, but rather greater insistence on more standards and more testing until, by the advent of No Child Left Behind, the standards left almost no leeway for teachers to educate children, but rather simply to prepare them to do well on lowest-common-denominator sorts of tests. Conceivably, adding a humanizing element, such as service teaching, can help mitigate some of the ill effects of testing run amok.

In the era of No Child Left Behind, a program even a cursory reading of the popular press will reveal as a misdirected, underfunded, and thoroughly detested effort by the Bush administration to improve education, it is tempting to throw out all standards in educational practice. However, it might be better to attempt to find some standards that are effective and examine why. Alternatively, if none can be found that are effective, again, it would be better to discover the reasons for the failure of standards in school reform.

Foss and LeMahieu (1994) compared treating standards as a freestanding component of school reform to walking in the woods, picking up a fallen branch, and failing to notice that it was connected to all other things in the woods: the trees, the root system, the ground, as well as the sky, the birds flying through the treetops, and so on. Likewise, they point out that it is unreasonable and unworkable to treat standards as sufficient in itself to accomplish school reform. Rather, it should be taken as a component of many initiatives directed at school reform. In context, they point out, standards can play a significant role.

The problem arises when localities' educational administrators promulgate standards and...

Then, Foss and LeMahieu point out, "They behave as though that will be enough, as though standards and assessments alone define systemic reform. Close examination of some of the implicit assumptions of standards -based reform leads one back to the many other trees in these woods. It discourages the thinking that attending to any one or two actions alone can possibly make for a healthy ecosystem" (Foss and LeMahieu, 1994, p. 16). Success in using standards to drive school reform depends on the integration of the standards with other aspects of the educational process.
They offer some suggestions for how standards can best be used in school reform. Primarily, they suggest, the standards must reflect the system's aspirations for students. "To fail to do so is to dictate that the winds of change will blow powerfully through the halls of our schools, but unfortunately not into any of the classrooms" (Foss and LeMahieu, 1994, p. 16). This is precisely what many say is wrong with all standards-based reform, and with No Child Left Behind in particular. The standards have nothing to do with the unique characteristics of each school population and are, in fact, so divorced from interactive learning and teaching that the 'teaching to test' process leaves students uneducated except in the narrow parameters of the test. And even then, the point could be made that exceptional 'test-takers' know only how to mark down correct answers they have memorized but lack understanding of how elements of the subject relate to each other. In short, they have become parrots rather than educated human beings, all in the name of standards.

In order to avoid this, it would seem to be almost imperative to avoid state or national standards that necessarily attempt to be all things to all students, and, instead, create standards locally. Foss and LeMahieu suggest that a school district should first describe the educational experience it desires for the students, and then determine what sort of organization it will require to achieve those intentions (1994). Perhaps the most significant question to be answered, when attempting to define an effective educational structure and create…

Sources used in this document:
References

Berman, S.H. (2000) Service as systemic reform. School Administrator, 57(7): 20. Retrieved June 17, 2005 from www.questia.com.

Eisner, E.W. (1994) Do American schools need standards? School Administrator, 51(5): 8. Retrieved June 17, 2005 from www.questia.com.

Finn, C.E. Jr. (2002, Summer) Making school reform work. Public Interest: 85+. Retrieved June 17, 2005 from www.questia.com.

Foss, H.K. And P.G. LeMahieu. (1994) Standards at the base of school reform. School Administrator, 51(5): 16. Retrieved June 17, 2005 from www.questia.com.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Standards Academic Standards in Education
Words: 676 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Interestingly, this creation of "standards" began as a state effort, with each state creating its own standards for education, according to what was considered important for schools by citizens in each specific state. Challenges regarding consistency were therefore part and parcel of the standards issue to begin with. Later, a movement was established to create more common standards. The historical ideal behind content standards is that they draw on relevant

Impact of School Culture on School Safety
Words: 33592 Length: 122 Document Type: Term Paper

School Culture on School Safety Many studies have been done on safety in schools. Likewise, many studies have been done on the culture of various schools. Unfortunately, there has not been significant research on a link between the two. This is not to say that these kinds of studies have not been done, but rather that there has not been enough of them. Many of the studies that have been

Reduction of the High School
Words: 10887 Length: 40 Document Type: Thesis

Moseley, chair of the Coalition advisory board and president and CEO of the Academy for Educational Development. "It is not a luxury that can be addressed at some point in the future, but rather it provides people with the tools to survive and improve their lives" (Basic Education Coalition 2004). There is no one magical, quick fix solution to Bermuda's dropout problem. The problem is complex and requires a

Bilingual Programs in Elementary School
Words: 2980 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

The Court then obliged schools to take steps to overcome language barriers in order to give all children equal access to the curriculum. This was endorsed by the Equal Educational Opportunity Act of 1974. None of the implemented laws require a specific methodology for instruction in schools, but civil rights laws do require that all children receive equal opportunities. Specifically, this requirement is enforced by the further requirements of theoretically

Relationship of School Facilities Conditions
Words: 5393 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Some of those are as follows: 1) Affect the environment; 2) Either save or expend energy; 3) Economically feasible or expensive to maintain, heat and cool. 4) Affect student learning; 5) Affect the health of students and teachers alike and 6) Affect the retention of teachers. (Olson and Carney, 2004) Criteria involved in the design, operation and maintenance of these 'sustainable' buildings are those as follows: Sustainable site planning and landscaping design that decrease the use

What Is the Value of Music in the Elementary School
Words: 1136 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Elementary Music School Programs Music Programs Music programs in elementary schools are sometimes viewed as discretionary. The scope of curricula seems to grow increasingly broader and deeper with each passing year, and the pressure to meet learning standards is tremendous. Instruction that does not have a direct influence on student and school performance is viewed as optional -- a nice program to have if the school can afford it and if

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now