Dr. David Livingstone seemed to epitomize this view, "These privations, I beg you to observe, are not sacrifices. I think that word ought never to be mentioned in reference to anything we can do for Him….Can that be a sacrifice which is simply paid back as a small part of a great debt owing to our God, which we can never repay… it is a privilege."
With this attitude of sacrifice for the greater glory, and it was certainly that for many who endured pain, pestilence, disease, hunger and bodily harm, also came a certain attitude about modernizing and bringing the native populations into the modern world through Christ. In places as diverse as Hawaii, the Philippines, central Africa, and even the Muslim world, these well-meaning missionaries invariable also brought with them cultural baggage and xenophobia. While wishing to save the population from the fires of Hell through Christianity, there was an inference that the indigenous culture and traditions were pagan and evil. Thus, approaching the Palestinian problem for Robinson was a difficult juxtaposition between heathen conversion and objective, academic scholarship. In an 1830 sermon, for instance, Smith emphasized how important and exciting missionary work in the New East was. This was because smith found it both important and gratifying that modern ways and modern religion were brought to lands of idolatry, fanaticism, and superstition. Smith criticized Eastern Orthodoxy as well as Islam, being unable to actually move his mind around the concept of divergent paths. In fact, religion was such a powerful tool for Smith, and his zealousness often blended with his assistance to Robinson. Foremost for Smith, was the task to "reform and save the degenerate and perishing people who now dwell there."
Robinson was clearly more of an academic, which is not to say that he was any less serious or devout, but simply that his verbiage and ability to synthesize action may have been more developed than that of Smith. For example, Robinsons traveled with only a few basic surveying supplies: compass, measuring tape, a thermometer, and telescopes. Smith, however, carried various bibles and past accounts of expeditions into a similar area. It was clear that Smith was the more fervent in his belief system, and was of the ilk that Smith would find it as rewarding to convert a soul rather than find an important archaeological discovery. In the same way, Smith viewed most of the linguistic discoveries as part of a dead tradition and no longer relevant to the task at hand.
We must also remember that, during Robinson's trip, there were not guides to middle-eastern scholarship, nor did vast journal articles and a potent bibliography as reference exist. Instead, one had to pick and choose between thousands of documents, most written in one of 7-8 languages, decide what was and what was not important, and then work in the final biblical scholarship.
As we've seen, Robinson was not particularly outgoing which caused many of his students to view him as aloof and unapproachable. Thus, his methodology and theoretical views are never taken up until much later in the 20th century. This was also due to his thoroughness and technique. In fact, Biblical geography and archaeology were fairly stagnant for decades following Robinson. "Rather than continuing in the path that he began, Americans scholarship became oriented towards Assyriology, which the geographic component became subsumed by the world of the National Geographic Society.
The resulting scholarship, for its time, was seminal in character and development. For the modern reader, it is a bit of a dialog between scholarly references and religious observations. Robinson did perform a great service by uncovering a number of scholarly proofs, but most of all, his attention to detail and his willingness to look beyond culture for the historical antecedent to what his beliefs told him was true, and to bring this truth to the world in a verifiable and factual basis are his most enduring legacy.
REFERENCES
Aharoni, Y. (1962). The Land of The Bible. Louisville, KY: John Knox Press; Brisco.
Arnold, B.T. (2002). Readings from the Ancient Near East: Primary Sources for Old Testament
Study. New York: Baker Academic Press.
Brisco, T. (1999). Holman Bible Atlas: A Complete Guide to the Expansive Geography of Biblical History. New York: B & H. Publishing Group.
Hallote, R. (2006). Bible, Map, and Spade: the American Palestine Exploration Society. Gorgias Press, LLC.
Hammond, P. (2005). "What Inspired...
Aftermath As the city council was making its preparations to host the Olympics, various groups militated for the negative effects the endeavor would generate upon the city. They cited the necessity to invest large amounts of money from the national budget, which means that other charitable events and endeavors would be left aside. Another limitation is given by the fact that throughout the 17 days games, the businesses not directly
The Hispanics have also migrated away from their more sparse locales in the city to increase the population in the Hispanic southeast corner of the city, still living with a majority of whites (Hispanic 2000). Using this information we see that residential differentiation, especially between whites and blacks, has become more intense, sharpening the lines between the races in the residential communities of Baltimore City. Perhaps because of this increased
IntroductionHomelessness in urban areas, particularly among children, is a significant issue facing major U.S. cities. As reported in the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development�s annual homeless assessment report (2020), there were approximately 570,000 people experiencing homelessness on a single night in January 2019 in the United States. Furthermore, homelessness has recently increased nationwide, although the temporal changes in homeless rates exhibit considerable sub-national variations. For example, while homelessness
Urban Area Globalization has created a profound impact on society. Through globalization, emerging markets continue to grow and develop. New and innovative products are created that provide solutions to societal problems. As such, wealth is created that is distributed to nations that provide services to humanity. As wealth is distributed, urban areas are created and cultivated. These cities, over time, become populated with the new inhabitants, and continue to thrive. The
The rain, averaging only 2-4 inches annually, comes in seasonal bursts that sometimes result in flash floods. Temperatures throughout the Gobi Desert are equally extreme, with lows records at -40 degree Fahrenheit and highs of 113 degrees Fahrenheit (Sadler 76). All of these climatic and geologic forces have combined to shape the landscape throughout the Gobi Desert. They have created immense megadunes a quarter of a mile tall held
"Between and beyond these two large areas lie two more fields of great importance, the East Texas field and the Panhandle field in northwest Texas. Separate from these fields but also of major importance are those located in southern California. In the mid-1960s, exploitation of deposits of petroleum and natural gas was begun along the north Alaska slope." (Birdstall & Florin, 1992) This is not enough to sustain the American
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now