Verified Document

Education In Law Litigation And Article Critique

Additionally, many may see the chance of a lawsuit as a way to get rich quick, and therefore blow up the situation bigger than necessary for the potential of a large payment. Since this happens too often within modern practice, it is understandable how both teachers and educators alike would take a disliking of such cases. Yet, despite these complaints, most educators and educational administrators have been seen in this research to believe that protection of children is worth the annoyance of litigation. Although many educators see lawsuits as taking a personal toll, the research overwhelmingly showed that many thought it was still necessary to have the option to sue to protect those children who have been wronged. The research presented here states that "The teachers and administrators we spoke with for this pilot study were quick to suggest that children sometimes make false charges of abuse, but they were equally quick to acknowledge that genuine abuse -- both physical and sexual -- could take place in schools," (Johnson & Duffett 2003:19). Therefore, no matter the negative results of some of the cases that go to litigation and the headache they cause, it is necessary to protect the children.

Overall, both teachers and administrators would rather see modifications to the current system, rather than a full forced revolution of the system. Although it may be frustrating, it does work when needed to protect the lives and interests of the children within America's schools. Yet, in the case of special education, the system seems to be failing (Katsiyannia & Herbst 2004). Educators within special education are crying for relief, based on the sensitive nature of the various programs involved. Special Education requires more sensitive treatment than the current system allocates.

The study provides insightful information, yet does show some weaknesses in its basic design. It was a very small study, thus limiting its ability to make overall assumptions...

The research states, "Instead, we are reporting on a small number of national survey findings combined with a small number of focus groups," (Johnson & Duffett 2003:2). These small numbers were needed to successfully conduct the study, yet does hinder its universal appeal. Additionally, the study does not offer any recommendations or working strategies. It states that "The purpose of this small-scale study is to raise questions, stimulate discussion and provide hypothesis for further research -- not to suggest definite conclusions," (Johnson & Duffett 2003:2). Therefore, it is not really contributing new and practical strategy into an already large body of work.
Litigation does play a powerful role in the field of education. It has the potential to bring progressive change, yet it also has the potential to frustrate the system and those who work within it. Major changes were brought forth through litigation. However, as this research shows, not all lawsuits bring beneficial change.

Resources

Aldridge, Delores P. Litigation and education of blacks: A look at the U.S. Supreme Court. Journal of Negro Education. 47(1):96-112.

Johnson, Jean & Duffett, Ann. (2003). I'm calling my lawyer: How litigation, due process and other regulatory requirements are affecting public education. Public Agenda.

Katsiyannia, Antonis & Herbst, Maria. (2004). Minimize litigation in special education. Intervention in School & Clinic. 40(2):106-117.

State Legislatures. (2004). Litigation in education: For 50 years, courts have been deciding whether states are meeting their constitutional obligations to provide a free and adequate education. Goliath. Retrieved March 21, 2010 from http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-2369255/Litigation-in-education-for-50.html

Sources used in this document:
Resources

Aldridge, Delores P. Litigation and education of blacks: A look at the U.S. Supreme Court. Journal of Negro Education. 47(1):96-112.

Johnson, Jean & Duffett, Ann. (2003). I'm calling my lawyer: How litigation, due process and other regulatory requirements are affecting public education. Public Agenda.

Katsiyannia, Antonis & Herbst, Maria. (2004). Minimize litigation in special education. Intervention in School & Clinic. 40(2):106-117.

State Legislatures. (2004). Litigation in education: For 50 years, courts have been deciding whether states are meeting their constitutional obligations to provide a free and adequate education. Goliath. Retrieved March 21, 2010 from http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-2369255/Litigation-in-education-for-50.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Special Education: Attitude, Litigation, and
Words: 804 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

PARC won their case, with the court ruling that all children, including those with identified special needs, were entitled to a "free, appropriate public education" (Eric 1998). This case, and several others that challenged similar laws and/or de facto education practices, led in 1975 to Public Law 94-142, now better known as the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (ERIC 1998). This piece of federal legislation mandated that all

Special Education Law Special Educators
Words: 514 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

This was supported by the Ninth District court in 2002, in the case Eason v. Clark County School District (NV), when it reversed a lower court and ruled that school personnel do not have immunity. This allowed parents to hold teachers and administrators financially liable when their child's right to FAPE is violated. While other rulings required schools to pay for private education or expensive programs such as Applied Behavioral

Education-Administration Education Discrimination to Teachers Teacher...
Words: 1385 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Education-Administration Education Discrimination to Teachers Teacher Discrimination Cases Educational instructors, especially the teachers provide the necessitated skills and knowledge to students, thereby equipping them with essential life skills. The teachers are in most cases employed by union organizations, but in some state and cities, they are directly employed from the school boards. In the latter situation, teacher-related issues are handled by the respective school's board committees. Despite the employer's position or rank, individual

Law Enforcement and Corrections
Words: 1720 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Law enforcement and corrections can be influenced by several external threats. These consist of external communication gaps and many environmental influences. One of the key external threats that impacts both corrections and law enforcement is politics. In delineation, politics is the art of wielding one's authority and power over the government or public affairs. In particular, political action can give rise to the imposition of one's interests within the government,

Law Enforcement and Age Discrimination
Words: 2503 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Many of these have been challenged throughout the years. In fact, here have been a number of cases challenging age discrimination within this more complicated situation. In the case, EEOC v. City of Janesville an individual fought the fifty-five-year cut off age for police officers in that county (Vance 1986). Opponents of the age cut off argued that age discrimination was acceptable only in "particular business," meaning for police officers

NYC Law
Words: 1695 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

NYC Education Law Bullying is a common occurrence among district schools in New York City with the major targets often students regarded as different such as the disabled. In this regard, this article highlights a fictitious scenario regarding bullying of disabled students in attempt to answer legal questions regarding education law about bullying students with learning disabilities. Using New York state statutes and related cases, this paper outlines legal actions individuals

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now