Verified Document

Education And Gender Inequality Essay

Gender Issues in Education Today The objective of this study is to examine gender issues in education today and to discuss its impacts or potential impacts on individuals and society. This study will examine how this issue has been addressed by philanthropy, charitable organizations, and governments.

Initial examination of the gender gap in education appears to show that women are on the receiving end of less education to prepare them for life however; there are new reports stating that male students are falling behind their female counterparts in school and that females are outperforming males in the educational setting. For example, the work of Whitmire (2010) states that the debate surrounding "gender and schooling have taken a surprising turn in the past decade. After years of concern that girls were being shortchanged in male-dominated schools, especially in math and science, there has grown a rising chorus of voices worrying about whether boys are the ones in peril." (p.1) Whitmire states that boy are "faring poorly compared to girls" when one considers the rates of dropout and graduation along with grades and scores on tests. Whitmire states the belief that this is happening because "K-12 schools are shortchanging boys. Far too many boys drop out before earning a high school diploma. Worse, too many boys who do make it through high school are either unprepared for or unmotivated to do college-level work." (2010, p.1) A large part of the problem is that the manufacturing jobs that boys could begin out of school without any college and make good wages have been "disappearing for years." (Whitmire, 2010, p.1) Whitmire goes on to state that conventional wisdom held that "women need a college degree more than men" and at one time this was certainly the case "but is no longer" states Whitmire. (2010, p.1)

I. Reports on Gender Gap in Education and Male Students

The work of Chapman (2015) entitled "Gender Bias in Education" relates the statement of Mulrine (2001) as follows:

"Across the country, boys have never been in more trouble: They earn 70% of the D's and F's that teachers dole out. They make up two thirds of students labeled "learning disabled." They are the culprits in a whopping 9 of 10 alcohol and drug violations and the suspected perpetrators in 4 out of 5 crimes that end up in juvenile court. They account for 80% of high school dropouts and attention deficit disorder diagnoses." (cited in Chapman, p.1)

Chapman states that the discrepancy in performance "is notable throughout Canada. In Ontario, Education Minister Janet Ecker said that the results of the standardized grade 3 and grade 6 testing in math and reading showed '...persistent and glaring discrepancies in achievements and attitudes between boys and girls'." (2015, p. 1) In addition, it is reported that in British Columbia "standardized testing indicates that girls outperform boys at all levels of reading and writing and in Alberta testing shows that girls '...significantly outperform boys on reading and writing tests, while almost matching them in math and science'." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) Yet the American Association of University Women reported in 1992 stating that "females receive less attention from teachers and the attention that female students do receive is often more negative than attention received by boys." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) When socialization of gender is examined "within schools and evidence of a gender biased hidden curriculum demonstrates that girls are shortchanged in the classroom. Furthermore there is significant research indicating steps that can be taken to minimize or eliminate the gender bias currently present in our education system." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1)

Chapman reports that socialization of gender in today's schools is such that "assure that girls are made aware that they are unequal to boys." (2015, p.1) Specifically, "Girls are praised for being neat, quiet and calm, where boys are encouraged to think independently, be active and speak up." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) Junior high school girls reported that being popular and to have everyone like them is more important that being viewed as "competent or independent." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) Socialization of femininity...

One study of a third grade classroom examined four self-sorted groups of girls within the classroom: the nice girls, the girlies, the spice girls and the tomboys. Through interviews researcher Diane Reay found that 'nice girls' was considered a derogatory term indicating, "...an absence of toughness and attitude. Furthermore, the girlies were a group of girls who focused their time on flirting with and writing love letters to boys, the tomboys were girls who played sports with the boys, and the spice girls espoused girl-power and played 'rate-the-boy' on the playground. Reay's research shows that each of the groups of girls defined their own femininities in relation to boys. (2001 cited in Chapman,2015, p.1)
The work of Myra and David Sackler notes four types of responses provided by teachers to students: (1) praising students; (2) giving positive feedback; (3) remediation and encouragement to correct their answer or expand upon it; (4) criticism upon an incorrect answer. (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) the Sacklers found in their study that boys were far more likely to receive praise or remediation from a teacher than were girls. The girls were most likely to receive an acknowledgment response from their teacher" (Sadker, 1994 cited in Chapman, 2015, p.1) Chapman notes that these findings agreement with a 1990 study conducted by Good and Brophy that stated finding that "teachers give boys greater opportunity to expand ideas and be animated than they do girls and that they reinforce boys more for general responses than they do for girls." (Marshall, 1997 cited in Chapman, 2015, p.1)

Additionally reported is that "special services in education appear to be applied more liberally to boys than to girls. Research shows that boys are referred for testing for gifted programs twice as often as girls, which may be because, "...giftedness is seen as aberrant, and girls strive to conform." (Orenstein, 1994 cited in Chapman, 2015, p. 1) In fact, boys are representative of in excess of "two-thirds of all students in special education programs and there is a higher the proportion of male students receiving diagnoses that are considered to be subjective. While medical reports indicate that learning disabilities occur in nearly equal numbers of in boys and girls, it may be the case that, "Rather than identifying learning problems, school personnel may be mislabeling behavioral problems. Girls who sit quietly are ignored; boys who act out are placed in special programs that may not meet their needs." (Bailey, 1992 cited in Chapman, 2015, p.1)

Gender bias is reinforced through the resources that are chosen for use in the classroom such as "Using texts that omit contributions of women, that tokenize the experiences of women, or that stereotype gender roles, further compounds gender bias in schools' curriculum. While research shows that the use of gender-equitable materials allows students to have more gender-balanced knowledge, to develop more flexible attitudes towards gender roles, and to imitate role behaviors contained in the materials." (Chapman, 2015, p.1) However, there is an ongoing use of gender-based texts in today's classrooms.

A 1990 conference of researchers found that even when texts are specifically designed to align with the present guidelines in California on equity of gender and race in regards to adoption of textbooks there is still an existence of "subtle language bias, neglect of scholarship on women, omission of women as developers of history and initiators of events, and absence of women from accounts of technological developments.." (Chapman, 2015, p. 1) Chapman reports that a study conducted by Jones, Evans, Byrd and Campbell (2000) utilized analysis of lessons that were videotaped in order to demonstrate to teacher's their behavior that is gender biased. One teacher stated: "As a teacher, I was struck by the Sadkers' research on classroom exchanges and was forced to acknowledge the disproportionate amount of time and energy, as well as the different sorts of attention, I give to male students." (Chapman, 2015, p.1)

II. Charity and Philanthropy

According to the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy at Indiana University -- Purdue University Indianapolis" Despite the growing body of research on charitable giving and women in philanthropy, few articles have been published in the past several years that address gender issues in planned giving Most of the articles that do exist are not based on a significantly large sample size or empirical methods. Only one quantitative analysis of gender differences in planned giving was identified after reviewing the prior literature." (2015, p.1) It is reported that a senior associate at Washburn & McGoldrick, Cindy Sterling, who is also formerly Vassar College, s director of gift planning, conducted an examination of "capital campaigns held between 1988 and 1998 at eight small liberal arts colleges" and stated findings that "women's bequests accounted for 22% of the campaign totals at women's colleges on average, more than three times the average percentage for male bequests."…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Keates, M. (2009) Philanthropy and Gender: Not Your Mother's Bake Sale. Marts & Lundy Counsel -- February 2009. Retrieved from: http://martsandlundy.com/philanthropy-and-gender-not-your-mothers-bake-sale

Critical Contributions: Philanthropic Investment in Teachers and Teaching. (nd) University of Georgi, Kronley & Associates. Retrieved from: http://kronley.com/documents/CriticalContributions.pdf

Gender Differences in giving Motivations for Bequest Donors and Non-Donors (2015) Lilly School of Philanthropy. Indian University -- Purdue University Indianapolis. Retrieved from: http://www.philanthropy.iupui.edu/research-by-category/gender-differences-in-giving-motivations-for-bequest-donors-and-non-donors

deMarrais, Kathleen and Claire Suggs (2011) Contributions: Philanthropic Investment in Teachers and Teaching. Atlanta, GA: Kronley & Associates. Retrieved from:http://www.ihep.org/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/pubs/corporate_investments.pdf
Grantmakers for Education. Benchmarking: Trends in Education Philanthropy (nd) Portland, OR: Grantmakers for Education, annual. Subject File Number: 210. Retrieved from: http://www.edfunders.org/sites/default/files/benchmarking_2012.pdf
Emerging Gender Issues in Education (2014) Intercultural Development Research Association. Retrieved from: http://www.idra.org/IDRA_Newsletter/May_2002_Self_Renewing_Schools_Technology/Emerging_Gender_Issues_in_Education/
Whitmire, R. And Bailey. SG (2010) Gender Gap. Education Next. Retrieved from: http://educationnext.org/gender-gap/
Chapman, A. (2015) Gender Bias in Education. Critical Multicultural Pavilion. Retrieved from: http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html
Mesch, DJ (nd) Women and Philanthropy: A Literature Review. Working Paper: 4/09. Retrieved from: http://www.philanthropy.iupui.edu/files/file/women_and_philanthropy_literature_review.pdf
from: http://www.edfunders.org/sites/default/files/innovation_2.0_detroit_2011.pdfrom:
Lawrence, Steven. Race to the Top: What Grantmakers Can Learn From the First Round. (2010) New York, NY: Foundation Center, 2010. Retrived from: http://foundationcenter.org/gainknowledge/research/pdf/rtt.pdf
Grantmakers for Education. Benchmarking: Trends in Education Philanthropy. Portland, OR: Grantmakers for Education, annual. Retrueved from: http://www.edfunders.org/sites/default m/files/benchmarking_2012.pdf
Torregrosa, LL (2011) They Call It the Reverse Gender Gap. The New York Times. 13 Dec. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/14/us/14iht-letter14.html?_r=0
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Gender Inequality in Hong Kong Wage Discrimination
Words: 2242 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Gender Inequality in Hong Kong Wage discrimination is the discrepancy of wages between two groups due to a bias towards or against a specific trait with all other characteristics of both groups being equivalent. In the case of gender inequality, wage discrimination exists between the male and female gender. Historically, gender inequality has favored men over similarly qualified women (Kwong, 1999). In Hong Kong, Article 19 of the Bill of Rights

Gender Inequality One of the
Words: 2806 Length: 8 Document Type: Thesis

Body One important aspect that has to be handled while studying gender inequalities is the intermingling of the words sex and gender. The two words, sex and gender are usually intermingled in numerous formats of studies especially in many health studies. The main distinction between the realities of the two words within the social concept of gender is that sex mainly revolves around the physical and biological aspects of the individual

Gender Inequality in Education Every Human Being,
Words: 1782 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

Gender Inequality in Education Every human being, in an ideal society, is born with certain rights that are considered to be the birth right and obligatory for the state and society to deliver. These rights include the right to Healthcare, Clean Water, Food, Justice, Nationality, etc. But again this is something that can only be talked about in the most ideal of worlds. The reality of the world is that not

Gender Inequality in the Workplace
Words: 2531 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Gender Inequality in the Workplace Families, societies, workplaces, moreover the whole world at large is bubbling with inequality. Color, religion, ethnicity, age, financial status and mostly gender are the basis of this biasness. Families do not mingle with people outside their own community, they do not consider cross marriages. Societies look down upon lower statuses and the elite have their noses held high in the air where no conscience can reach.

Gender Inequality in Sports Has Led to Obesity Among Adolescent Girls...
Words: 3829 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Proposal

Gender Inequity in Sports Has Led to Obesity Among Adolescent Girls in Saudi Arabia Gender Inequality in sports has led to Obesity among Adolescent Girls in Saudi Arabia Obesity is one of the most rapidly escalating phenomena in the entire world. It is influencing the lifestyle and lifestyle choices of both adults and teenagers specifically young females across all ethnicities and races as well as social statures (World Health Organization [WHO], 2006).

Gender Inequality Greater at Lower or Higher
Words: 978 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

gender inequality greater at lower or higher educational levels? The authors of this paper are Evertsson, England, Mooi-Reci, Hermsen, de Bruijn, and Cotter. The paper was published by the Oxford University Press. It was found on Google Scholar. My motivation for selecting this paper was that the subject matter is of personal interest to me. I feel that pay inequality between the genders is not only an issue that should

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now