Verified Document

Editorial Letter On Prenatal Testing Peer-Reviewed Journal

¶ … Editor, In his letter printed June 8, 2014, Alistair Pullen discusses the fact that the advent of prenatal testing has helped transform pregnancy from a time of joy to a time of fear. He discusses his wife's pregnancy with his first daughter, in which prenatal testing revealed the existence of a disorder that was incompatible with life. As a result of the testing, Mr. Pullen and his wife chose to induce labor, resulting in their daughter being stillborn at 20 weeks of age. In their three subsequent pregnancies, prenatal testing helped reassure them that their children were healthy. While Mr. Pullen believes that prenatal testing helped transform the early periods of the pregnancies into high stress events, but that the high stress helps parents avoid something that is even more stressful; the birth of a child with a disorder that is incompatible with life.

I find myself both agreeing and disagreeing with Mr. Pullen's proposition that prenatal testing increases stress during pregnancy, but contributes to an overall reduction in pregnancy stress. Mr. Pullen and his wife chose to terminate a pregnancy after determining that the developing fetus had a condition that was ultimately incompatible with life. As a result, his conclusion that prenatal testing has the capacity of reducing stress...

At this point in time, this is a position held by roughly half of Americans, though evidence about termination rates when fetuses are actually diagnosed with serious disorders through prenatal testing suggests that these numbers may be much higher.
My concerns about prenatal testing are directly linked to these termination rates, because of the fact that parents are choosing to terminate children with disorders that are neither incompatible with life nor linked to low-quality of life, like Down syndrome. Advocates for people with Down syndrome suggest that society is losing something by terminating children with Down syndrome. At the same time, these same advocates suggest that society needs to make adjustments and changes to be more accommodating to those with Down syndrome. It brings to mind Greg Narbey's question, "How much accommodation or acceptance must majorities extend to minority groups, and when is accommodation or acceptance unreasonable?" (Narbey, 2009). The complex issue that arises from this scenario is: does the answer to this question change when the minority is a group that may be eliminated…

Sources used in this document:
References

Narbey, G. (2009). Can we all just get along? In C. Cockerton and M. Chaparian (Eds.), The

Human Project, 5th Edition (pp. ). Canada: Pearson Education.

Pullen, A. (8 June, 2014). To the editor. Retrieved June 15, 2014 from The New York Times

website: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/14/opinion/prenatal-testing-along-with-the-worries.html?_r=0
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Thomas Becket Movie Peter Glenville's
Words: 1132 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The king proves his irresponsibility by forgiving Becket and thus brings England once again in danger of being controlled by the clergy. The final scenes show how Becket dies while protecting his beliefs while the king is ravaged by his own actions and illogically punishes Becket's killers for the murder Henry II indirectly ordered. Question 3: It is difficult to determine if Becket actually got God's honor exactly as he expected

Eyeglasses for the Poor When
Words: 734 Length: 2 Document Type: Data Analysis Chapter

Next, the board members. The organization would be wise to directly approach a business leader in the community, someone with a charitable reputation who has the time and inclination to participate. Also, a business owner in the eyeglasses field would be perfect for a second board member. Group members can also be considered. Once the new three-member board has its first meeting, the articles of incorporation and bylaws can be

Europe, Middle Ages 800-Year Prelude
Words: 623 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

"I grant you the sacred charge of propagating our order under any and all conditions, because it is sure to have a lasting effect on posterity. As I've told you many times, the Priory de Zion has been the guiding force behind the Knights Templars, the French faction which has been our military might and the possessor of the holy grail which Mary Magdalene took into this country after the

Stained Glass Panel 1 Of
Words: 4052 Length: 12 Document Type: Thesis

As the light changes during the course of a day, the colors change as well; reds and yellows get more brilliant at noon, blues become brilliant as the light fades in the afternoon. All the while, the pictures tell important stories or symbolize truths. Light radiating through glass adds life, beauty, is transcendent, and spiritual connections become apparent. The above rather elaborate description is cited at length in order to

Politics on Facebook and Twitter
Words: 1131 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Social Media & Politics Social media has not been around a terribly long time in terms of years and time spent. However, the days of when MySpace fully came onto the scene was not that long ago. Since then, Facebook has asserted a massive presence. That presence has been used by Facebook itself and others to change the face of different realms of society. Just one of those realms would happen

Current Events and Applying Sociology
Words: 1832 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

R.I.P. RELIGIOUS RIGHT and other Super Tuesday Take-Aways . . . Whereas the "religious right" had seemed to be a dominant force in American politics, particularly powerful in the Republican Party, the influence of this loud but still minority group seems to have waned. This article goes so far as to suggest that candidate Donald Trump's raging popularity in the Bible Belt signals a nail in the coffin for the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now