Etiology of Campus Binge Drinking
Drinking and Alcoholism
A Failed Experiment in Social Control
The consumption of alcohol has always been a focus of government efforts to limits its use, due to the potential for abuse, the financial burden imposed upon social programs, and its association with criminal activity. Between 1920 and 1934 the consumption of alcohol was outlawed in the United States, with the intention of addressing these social problems. During the first year following the enactment of Prohibition, alcohol-related deaths, psychosis, and arrests all declined by 20-40%, but between 1921 and 1927 these measures reveal a sharp increase to near pre-Prohibition levels (Miron and Zwiebel, 1991). By the end of Prohibition, which correlates with the start of the Great Depression, alcohol consumption leveled out at around 60-70% of pre-Prohibition levels despite costing three times as much for a drink. Given the infamous criminal activity that emerged around the illegal manufacture and sale of alcohol, and the modest reduction in alcohol consumption during the Prohibition Era, the overall savings this law was supposed to produce were probably not realized.
The New Prohibition
A similar experiment in alcohol prohibition is currently underway in the United States for a limited segment of the population. Beginning in 1984 the federally-mandated Minimum Legal Drinking Age (MDLA) Act became law, which set the minimum drinking age to 21 for all states that wished to retain 10% of their federal highway funding. This law was designed to reduce the number of highway fatalities and other problems associated with abuse of alcohol among adolescents and young adults (Grucza, Norberg, and Beirut, 2009).
One measure of the prevalence of alcohol abuse is binge drinking (BD), which is defined as 5 or more drinks for an adult male, or 4 or more drinks for an adult female, over a period of 2 hours (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2004). When the trends in binge drinking were examined between 1979 and 2006 for 12 to 20-year-olds, there appears to be some evidence that this law has had a positive effect (Grucza, Norberg, and Beirut, 2009, p. 697). Males in this age group experienced a significant decline in the prevalence of BD during this period (p < 0.001), but there was no change in this behavior among females.
The impact of raising the MLDA to 21 seems to have had a positive effect on traffic fatalities as well. For all drivers between the ages of 16 and 20 fatally injured in 2008, 33% had blood alcohol content above the legal limit (McCartt, Hellinga, and Kirley, 2011, p. 174). In 1982 the prevalence of fatally injured drunk drivers in this age group was 61%, which represents a nearly 50% reduction in this traffic statistic over the subsequent decades. This data seems to show that raising the legal drinking age to 21 significantly reduced traffic fatalities for this age group.
Unexpected Outcomes of the New Prohibition
In June 2008 a group of 120 college professors from liberal arts colleges released a statement expressing the need to reopen the debate about whether the MDLA of 21 is working, because in their experience it isn't (Amethyst Initiative, 2008). This statement caused a stir in the press and was inaccurately restated as an endorsement of lowering the drinking age to 18. The signatories to the Amethyst Initiative cited their concerns about what is a growing culture of clandestine drinking parties, the manufacture of fake identification cards, and other criminal activities on college campuses, not unlike the speakeasies and other criminal activities that emerged during Prohibition. The data seems to support their concerns.
Between the years of 1979 and 2006, male students 18 to 23-year of age experienced a slight, non-significant trend downward in the prevalence of BD (Table 1; Grucza, Norberg, and Beirut, 2009, p. 697). The pattern for female students indicates a move in the opposite direction; between the ages of 18 and 20 the prevalence was unchanged, but for female students between 21 and 23 there was a 2-3 fold increase in BD (p = 0.02). Overall, the prevalence of BD among college students seems to have increased since the MLDA was raised to 21.
The dramatic increase in BD prevalence among female college students is certainly cause for concern, but should there be a similar level of concern about male students? A comparison of BD prevalence among male nonstudents between the ages of 18 and 20 reveals a significant, 2-3 fold decrease for the period 1979 to 2006 (p < 0.001; Grucza, Norberg, and Beirut, 2009, p. 697). Nonstudent males between the ages of 21 and 23 also experienced a significant (p = 0.03), but modest decline in BD. When compared to nonstudents, being a male college student represents a significant risk factor for engaging in BD.
Female nonstudents also experienced an increase in BD prevalence between 1979 and 2006, but this modest increase (< 30%) was limited to the ages of 21-23 (Grucza, Norberg, and Beirut, 2009, p. 697). When compared to the 200-300% increase in BD among female college students in this age group, attending college is also a major BD risk factor for women.
These trends seem to...
Alcoholism and the DSM-IV-TR Alcoholism is a serious problem in our society. Alcoholism is a "disabling addictive disorder" (Wikipedia, 2011). It is a compulsive behavior by the individual, where he/she is unable to control their consumption of alcohol despite the negative effects of drinking. Alcoholism affects the drinker's health, social and work relationships, which in much case can impact their financial standings and judgment. The abuse of alcohol is a common
In fact, some people can recover from alcoholism with no formal treatment whatsoever, and others may "…cycle in and out of dependence" during their entire lifetime, Huebner continues (296). One relatively new idea in terms of treating alcoholics is to use the powerful hallucinogenic drug, LSD, according to an article in Medline Plus (Preidt, 2012). A study using 536 patients who were alcohol dependent showed that "a single dose of
Alcoholism in Adolescence Significance of the health issue of alcoholism Everything is good in moderation, and, indeed, studies show that low-levels of alcohol consumption (such as 1-2 drinks per day (Sellman et al., 2009) may prove beneficial to drinkers. Chronic alcohol abuse (i.e. consistent and persistent consumption of alcohol) has an undoubted negative long-term impact. It is ironic that whilst low drinking can consequent in decreased risks of osteoporosis, cardiovascular condition, stroke,
Alcoholism: Children of Alcoholic Parents Alcoholism is a serious problem that affects millions of American families in unthinkable ways. More importantly is the effect on the children of problem drinkers, who often suffer from emotional and psychological problems as a result of parental alcohol abuse. Research on this topic has often revealed that children of alcoholic parents stand a greater chance of becoming alcoholics themselves. The manner in which a young
When Terri asks Mel is he is drunk, he becomes defensive because he realizes that something about his personality must be changing. In other words, he is getting drunk and behaving drunk but does not want to admit it and continues to drink to cover his emotions. Perhaps the most compelling aspect of the story in relation to drinking is the fact that the characters are drinking as if it
This means that alcohol is made accessible to underage persons and in this way, they start consuming alcohol at a young age. It is for this reason that the legal drinking age should not be lowered, but actually increased to reduce the chances of it being made available to those who are underage. Increasing the minimum legal drinking age to at least 25 years, like India, will go a
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now