Verified Document

Downsizing The Ethics Of Downsizing: Term Paper

What these authors are essentially saying is that if a pre-determined set of ethical rules or practices is used to make downsizing decisions within organizations, and/or if projected (and necessarily uncertain) information about outcomes was used to inform and help make these decisions, the organization would easily if not automatically absolve itself of true moral responsibility (Clegg et al., 2007). This is because there would be an external system truly "making the decision," rather than the organization itself (or rather, the powers-that-be within the organization) engaging in critical examination of the specific scenario and options at hand, much like the "marionette" manager tries to remove any sense of ethical duty on his part by insisting that he or she is only acting as required by his or her bosses (Clegg et al., 2007; Lamsa & Tokala, 2000). Seen in this light, empathy in the decision making process could be considered a necessary quality of ethicality, as suggested in some empirical research (Lamsa & Tokala, 2000). If it is really on the specific and un-generalizable details of the singular scenario and set of heterogeneous options that a company finds itself faced with that a decision regarding downsizing must be made, than a consideration of the human elements -- of the psychological, social, and economic costs to individuals within the organization -- must also be included (Clegg et al., 2007; Applebaum & Labib, 1993). This is the only way to approach a comprehensive assessment of the situation.

It is also important in making a downsizing decision, however, to examine the effects of not downsizing on both the organization and the individuals within it. Though this issue is not explicitly addressed by any of the researchers cited, it is...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

(2007). If the psychological, social, and economic implications and effects on individuals of the decision to downsize matter, and if the specific circumstances of an isolated decision scenario must be the basis for the making of that decision, then the psychological, social, and economic effects of a specific decision to retain a full workforce must also be included in the consideration. Companies do not downsize maliciously, but because there is a perceived need to reduce costs and/or increase efficiency. Whether or not these perceptions are rooted in empirical truth or are arrived out from a larger desire to achieve what is best for the organization and the individuals involved is precisely the issue when examining the ethics of making such a decision, but if such a need is rightfully perceived then there will be clear disadvantages in these areas if the decision to downsize is not made.
Conclusion

Ultimately, Clegg et al. (2007) provide the most certain and the most general assessment of ethicality in the downsizing decision-making process. No rules or formulations can be considered permanent or generalizable, as this negates true moral responsibility. Making specific decisions and carrying them out well is ethical, period.

References

Applebaum, a. & Labib, N. (1993). Strategic Downsizing: A Human Resources Perspective. Human Resource Planning 16(4).

Clegg, S., Kornberger, M. & Rhodes, C. (2007). Organizational ethics, decision making, undecidability. The Sociological Review 55(2): 393-409.

Lamsa, a. & Tokala, T. (2000). Downsizing and Ethics of Personnel Dismissals -- the Case of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Applebaum, a. & Labib, N. (1993). Strategic Downsizing: A Human Resources Perspective. Human Resource Planning 16(4).

Clegg, S., Kornberger, M. & Rhodes, C. (2007). Organizational ethics, decision making, undecidability. The Sociological Review 55(2): 393-409.

Lamsa, a. & Tokala, T. (2000). Downsizing and Ethics of Personnel Dismissals -- the Case of Finnish Managers. Journal of Business Ethics 23: 389-99.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Business Plan: Bridal Salon Business Products and
Words: 3400 Length: 10 Document Type: Business Plan

Business Plan: Bridal Salon Business Products and services Keys to Success Company description Vision Statement Mission Statement Company background Products and Industry Product Description Industry Description The Market Market and Target Customer Market Segmentation Target Market Strategy Competition and Competitive Advantage Curbing Local Competition Curbing Regional Competition Marketing Strategy Overall Strategy Sales Plan Competitive Plan Research and Development (Growth Plan) The Organization Legal and Organization Structure Key Personnel Related Service Providers Location The Financials Critical Risks Income Statement Cash Flow Projection Balance Sheet Assumptions References Executive Summary Introduction Pace-setter is a bridal salon that rides on the theme of 'experience'. It creates an environment in which

Business Description Definition of the Market Description
Words: 1271 Length: 4 Document Type: Business Plan

Business Description Definition of the Market Description of the Products Organization and Management Descriptions Marketing Strategies Financial Management This paper presents business plan for a new leather garment manufacturing and retailing business. The business is being set up with an initial capital outlay of $53 million. The paper starts with a brief description of the business; its target market and product offerings, and then proceeds by proposing organizational and management strategies, marketing strategies, and financial management

Business Plan Gbsgreen Building Solutions Company Description
Words: 1926 Length: 6 Document Type: Business Plan

Business Plan GBSGreen Building Solutions Company Description Product & Service Description Marketing Strategy & Plan Environmental Analysis (SWOT/PEST) Competitive Analysis Products and Services Pricing Promotion People Financial Analysis & Projections Profit and Loss Risks and Assumptions GBSGreen Building Solutions Business Plan According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) the impact of commercial buildings on the physical and social environment are such that there is "not questioning the vast impact…" (Environmental Protection Agency, 2006) Commercial Buildings are reported by the U.S. Department of Energy's Energy Information Administration

Business Plan Idc Interiors Aims
Words: 3240 Length: 12 Document Type: Business Plan

[2: www.med.govt.nz/business/business.../structure-and-dynamics-2011.... ] The primary research of the Auckland market presents the following sectors for consideration for the new venture: The demographics in the target market include: college going and married women with children who either are working mothers or stay-at-home mothers; this makes the age group anywhere between 25 to 55; the overall annual income of the household is more than AUS $100,000; the property owned by the target individual

Business Plan of Searchyyy.com a Meta Search
Words: 2289 Length: 7 Document Type: Business Plan

Business Plan of Searchyyy.com a Meta search engine Market Opportunity & Solutions Business Model and Strategy Search engine according to countries and languages Advertisement Revolution Social Networking and Blogging Sites Revenue Opportunities Sales and marketing plan Technology overview Technology implementation Intellectual property Competition Financials Current ratio ROE Debt to equity ratio (D/E) Management Organization and Ownership Organizational Structure Risks and mitigation Searchyyy.com, Inc. is Meta search engine which intends to provide a multi-category search engine to its users at a faster pace. The growing technology has evolved our lives. Users

Business Plan Product Description Market
Words: 4066 Length: 15 Document Type: Business Plan

As part of the research triangle, Raleigh has a significant portion of its population that fits the target market. For the Farmery to succeed, it only needs to capture a small portion of the market share. This is especially true because the store has a small footprint, and has the flexibility to set up on vacant lots without the costs of either renting or developing fixed real estate. The

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now