Verified Document

Do Electronic Voting Machines Improve The Voting Process  Term Paper

¶ … Things Fall Apart" Achebe before referencing Electronic Voting Machines: Technology's failure to rehabilitate American's confidence in the voting process

Theoretically, counting votes should be easy. After all, surely it is simply the accumulation and the verifying of data? However, when America attempted to adopt touch-screen, electronic voting on a wide scale, the result was a fiasco. "There was a wonderful confluence of events. There was a vague product requirement coming from an agency that doesn't really understand technology (the U.S. Congress), foisting a system on other government agencies that may not have asked for it. There was a relatively small time frame for development and a lot of money. Finally, the government did not allow for even the notion of failure. By 2004, darn it, we'd all have touch screen voting" (Cringely, 2003). Congress expected to adopt touch-screen voting on a widespread basis in the next election, after the controversy over the results in the 2000 Florida presidential election demonstrated the need for reform of the punch card voting system. However, this sweeping decision neglected to take one crucial fact into consideration -- the new system was supposed to be based in unerring technology, unlike the inefficient paper systems of old. But only "28% of software projects were complete successes in 2000," meaning that there is a 72% rate of failure of software projects, give or take, on any given year (Cringely, 2003).

It did not matter -- the government was determined that touch-screen voting would be instated. After Florida, the U.S. government allocated $3.5 billion to modernize voting systems in all states. Diebold Systems, the company responsible for creating most of the automated teller systems in America purchased a smaller company that made voting machines to take advantage of the burgeoning market. Two other firms like Diebold who made ATMs, grocery self check-out systems and kiosk ticket systems threw their hats in the ring and accepted bids as well. Since information technology specializes in the storing and accumulating of vast amounts of data, computers seemed...

Apparently, no one in Congress has ever had his or her computer system 'crash.'
The first and most obvious problem with the use of electronic voting is that there is 'paper trail.' In other words, "there doesn't seem to be any way in these systems to verify that the numbers coming out are the numbers that went in. There is no print-out from the machine, no receipt given to the voter, no way of auditing the election at all (Cringely, 2003). For a system that is supposed to alleviate voter's ethical concerns, this is problematic, to say the least, at best. The lack of a paper trail means that the machines cannot be 'audited' by an independent, nonpartisan authority.

The truly audacious aspect of this lack of a paper trail with touch-screen voting is that the other machines created by Diebold and their ilk DO have 'paper trails.' Ask yourself: would you use an ATM that didn't dispense a receipt informing you of your balance, so you could be made aware immediately of a bank computer error? Would you use your credit card at a store that did not give you a receipt, so you could check to see if you had been overcharged? Of course not -- you would shift to another bank or use another store. But this act of faith was exactly what Diebold was expected of American voters. And voters in states like Georgia that only use electronic voting cannot move their votes, like consumers can move their dollars, to a more reliable venue.

To be fair, not all members of Congress were equally confident in Diebold's efficacy and security. For example, Representative Rush Holt of New Jersey, "introduced a bill requiring that digital voting machines leave a paper trail and that their software be available for public inspection, but was told that this was unnecessary, as such systems "lacking these safeguards haven't caused problems" (Krugman, 2003: 1). In disbelief, he asked: "How do you know?" In other words, without a verifiable paper trail, how can…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Cringely, Robert. (4Dec 2003). "No Confidence Vote." PBS. Retrieved 19 Feb 2008 at http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/2003/pulpit_20031204_000794.html

Kantor, Andrew. (4 Jun 2004). "More Problems Arise with 'black box voting.'

USA Today. http://www.usatoday.com/tech/columnist/andrewkantor/2004-06-04-kantor_x.htm

Krugman, Paul. (2 Dec 2003). "Hack the Vote." The New York Times. Retrieved 19 Feb 2008 at http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940CE2DF1E3AF931A35751C1A9659C8B63
The Independent. Retrieved 19 Feb 2008 at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/in-the-news/race-for-whitehouse/the-official-electionwatchers-glossary-777868.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Design the Online Voting Process for One County or One State
Words: 2125 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Online Voting System The current system for registering voters in our country was designed in a time-frame before the computer industry had become such a major power in our day-to-day lives. In a time when citizens can order everything from automobiles to movie tickets online, the technology exists to also streamline this system. State, and county governments have the ability to make it simpler for each voter to participate in

Advantages and Disadvantages of Internet Voting in US Elections
Words: 2576 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Internet Voting in the U.S. At least in the last decade, the use of the internet has become a part of the daily schedule of the 90% majority who go online at least daily, 2/3 at least 10 hours a week and 1/3 at least 20 hours a week (Davis 2000), most of them below 25 years old. There has been dramatic growth in the amount of information available online and

Elderly Voting Trends and the
Words: 3166 Length: 9 Document Type: Thesis

Returning to the Churchill quote, we note that the Democratic Party, the relative left wing of today's political world, does contain the majority of the young vote in America. It is also the case that many members of the labor class and the majority of minority citizens also make up the Democratic Party. Conversely, Republicans tend to be an older, wealthier, and whiter than Democrats. The Republicans swept the 2002 election and left our George W.

Earth Science, Information Age, and
Words: 5138 Length: 14 Document Type: Essay

Continental tropical (cT) air masses are hot, dry, unstable at low levels and generally stable aloft (upper-level ridge); they originate in northern Mexico. Continental polar (cP) or continental arctic (cA) air masses are cold, dry, and stable originating over northern Canada and Alaska as a result of radiational cooling. (Oklahoma Climatological Survey, 2004)" The greenhouse effect has been in the news for the last several decades especially with the resulting

Competitiveness of Sustenance Lithographic Printing Industry With
Words: 8843 Length: 31 Document Type: Case Study

Competitiveness of Sustenance Lithographic Printing Industry with the Digital Printing Industry: A Case Study of the Lithographic Printing Industry in Nigeria Major Constraints Affecting the Lithographic Printing Industry The Effect of the Total Quality Management System on Lithographic Industry and Compliance with a Changing World Comparison of Lithographic Printing and Digital Printing to Develop Avenues to Increase the Sale of Lithography Stakeholder Opinions of the Proficiency of the Lithographic Printing Industry Although facing obsolescence from innovations in

E-Voting and Related Use of the Internet for Elections
Words: 2402 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

E-Voting and Related Use of the Internet for Elections Electronic voting often regarded as Internet voting, online voting or e-voting is an electoral system that utilizes encoding to permit a voter to pass on their secure and confidential ballot over the web. (E-Ping meeting Brussels) The democratic system of formation of government entails authority of the citizens to choose leaders and to represent them in the Legislative Assembly and form the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now