Verified Document

DNA Fingerprinting In UK The Research Proposal

Several schools have implemented locks and record keeping mechanisms that depend upon a child's fingerprints (traditional, not DNA) (Edinformatics). These fingerprint mechanisms are used to track money for school meals, to replace library cards, and to alow access to school buildings and rooms in an attempt to cut down on the rate of skipping school -- and the British government is allowed to collect and maintain fingerprint records without parental consent (Edinformatics). There are serious concerns that the relatively new technology of DNA fingerprinting might also be implemented along the same lines, without the right of citizens to deny consent, leading to a DNA database that includes every child who attends school in the United Kingdom. There are also many positive impacts that the technology has had on UK society. Not only has DNA fingerprinting allowed many cases to be solved that would otherwise go un-prosecuted and unclosed, and many more to be solved faster and more conclusively than they otherwise would be, but Dr. Jeffreys believes that the near future will allow for near-instantaneous DNA fingerprinting results using portable units at the scene of a crime (Jeffreys 2005, pp. 1038-9). Jeffreys also sees the same developments that cause privacy concerns for others as future positive applications of DNA fingerprinting, including tracking credit card accounts and providing travel security with a passport-like function (Jeffreys 2005, pp. 1039). Likewise, the National DNA Database established in 1995 is the largest database of its kind in the world with 2.7 million separate records, which serves as both a specific deterrent to criminals and a testament to the overall strength of the United Kingdom's law enforcement (Home Office 2006, pp. 4). In addition, though there is no direct economic benefit from the use of DNA fingerprinting in the filed of criminal justice, the medical industry and private labs have benefited enormously from the technological advances made, improving the economy overall (Henderson 2009).

IV. Moral and Ethical Issues of DNA Fingerprinting

Several lawsuits have already...

There are fears that this could lead to unnecessary arrests and even wrongful convictions, as anyone in the database even for a simple detention could possibly be brought into an investigation simply on the basis of an eyelash or drop of saliva being found at the scene.
These fears were increased in 2003 when the government of the United Kingdom determined that DNA records could be retained indefinitely, increasing the likelihood that an individual in the National DNA Database for something as insignificant as disorderly conduct as a teenager could be brought into an investigation for a much more serious crime later in life (Linacre 2003). The line between protecting society and protecting civil rights has always been a contentious one, and DNA fingerprinting is yet one more technological advancement that demands a clear delineation between the two. This demand, unfortunately, is not being adequately met according to many. Civil rights seem to be losing out in favor of law enforcement's direct priorities, with both Welsh and English laws allowing for the retrieval, profiling, and permanent retention of DNA samples from absolutely every person arrested, without requiring consent or even a charge to be filed against the arrested individual (Wallace 2006).

V. Conclusion

The technological advancements made in DNA fingerprinting since its first discovery and use in the mid-1980s have made the concerns regarding privacy and civil rights issues far more pressing than first imagined. At the same time, the many uses of DNA profiling both within the field of criminal justice and in the private sector has made the technology invaluable and highly lucrative. One thing is certain -- the technology is not going away, but a more careful use of DNA fingerprinting technology and legislation restricting its application might be advantageous to ensure the protection of privacy and civil rights within the UK…

Sources used in this document:
References

DirectGov. (2009). Accessed 6 August 2009. http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/index.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Future of DNA Testing the
Words: 2054 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Proposal

The scientists ran the DNA computer only in a test tube. They foresaw the need for an injectable version for intracellular activities, which could take decades to devise.7 In response to the fear of nonscale robots going around inside the body, the scientists said they placed safeguards into their systems.7 When more reliable DNA computers are invented with fewer mistakes, people could become more comfortable with injectable robots and accept

How to Use DNA Analysis in Court
Words: 2199 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

DNA Analysis Abstract This paper discusses the history of DNA analysis, how it came about, how it was first used in a criminal case, and some of the limitations of DNA analysis as shown by later criminal cases. It looks at how DNA analysis is currently used today, including a recent criminal investigation in Europe in which DNA analysis played a crucial role, and provides a description of the various directions that

Criminal Identification Procedures
Words: 1768 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Criminal Identification Procedures The dawn of the twenty-first century has become the era of George Orwell's "1984." Technology that was found only in science fiction a few decades ago, is part of today's standards and procedures. The world today is filled with cameras that can film an individual wherever he goes, his cell phone signal can pinpoint his location, and even one glance can reveal his true identity (Shenk 2003). Iris-recognition technology,

Jeffery Dahmer
Words: 2674 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Dahmer Forensic Analysis Jeffrey Lionel Dahmer Crime Scene and Discovery Never before has egregious police incompetence hindered the apprehension of a serial killer as in the case of Jeffrey Dahmer. When police were called to investigate an alleged domestic disturbance between Konerak Sinthasomophone and Jeffrey Dahmer on May 27, 1991. Although two women came to the aide of Sinthasomophone and urged police to look further into the alleged dispute, the police ignored their

Christopher Vaughn Case
Words: 1739 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Forensics On June 14, 2007, a man covered in blood waved down a passing motorist on Interstate 55 in Illinois. He had gunshot wounds in the arm and leg. It was 5:40 in the morning in Channahon Township, Illinois. Nearby, the man's 2004 Ford Expedition carried the dead bodies of the man's wife and three children, ages 12, 11, and 8. They had all been shot to death. After pulling over,

Nature Verses Nurture One of
Words: 1792 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

(We've never had it so good - and it's all thanks to science) Thus the question of genes is an effect on certain humans and their behavior; in short their physical and behavioral traits. That does not change the view of society on what a well nurtured human is. Conclusion: Thus we still expect "other people" in society to be upright, polite, incorruptible, generous, are honest, hard working, well-informed, broadminded, who

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now