Verified Document

Disability Discrimination The ADA Case Study

Huber v WalMart In the United States, the 1990 American's with Disabilities Act (ADA) was a huge step forward in Civil and Individual Rights that protects against discrimination and requires access to all public organizations. To broaden this, the ADA Amendments Act of 2008 (ADAAA) includes a major list of life activities and enhances the requirements for accessibility. Broadly defined, an individual has a disability if they have something physical or mental that prevents them from engaging in a major activity that most people take for granted. The law already addresses equal employment opportunities, (Title 1 of the ADA), but other parts of the ADA are more focused to what is known as "reasonable accommodation." This means that if an individual is otherwise qualified for a position, their disability, or impairment, must not be a factor in being hired, promoted, or otherwise actualized within the position.

In the case of Huber v. Wal-Mart, Pam Huber worked for Wal-Mart as a dry grocery order filler. She was not disabled when she was put in this position, but permanently injured her right arm as a result of a workplace injury. As a reasonable accommodation, Huber requested to be assigned to a router position, which both parties agreed was a vacant position and equivalent. Although the parties agreed that Huber was qualified, she was not the most qualified for that position. Huber was given a different position at another facility, but her salary was lowered from $13/hour to $6.70/hour. The District Court found in favor of Huber, but the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the decision and sided with Wal-Mart (Huber v Wal-Mart, 2007).

Part 1 -- In the case, both parties stipulated to some basic facts: Huber was injured while working, she was qualified for the vacant position, and she would be given another position to accommodate her disability. The germane issue was the actual qualifications for the router position. While Huber was qualified,...

The Court found that Wal-Mart was required, under the ADA, to compete for the router job, but it did not require Wal-Mart to hire her or turn away a superior applicant. The Court indicated that:
The contrary rule would convert a nondiscrimination statute into a mandatory preference statute, a result which would be both inconsistent with the non-discriminatory aims of the ADA and an unreasonable imposition on the employers and coworkers of disabled employees. A policy of giving the job to the best applicant is legitimate and nondiscriminatory. Decisions on the merits are not discriminatory (Huber v Wal-Mart).

If Wal-Mart had automatically put Huber into the router position based on ADA law, they would have violated EEOC law. In fact, the ADA says that an employer is free to select the most qualified applicant available and to make decisions based on reasons unrelated to a disability. Reasonable Accommodation is defined as "any modification or adjustment to a job or the work environment that will enable a qualified applicant or employee with a disability to participate in the application process or to perform essential job functions. Reasonable accommodation also includes adjustments to assure that a qualified individual with a disability has rights and privileges in employment equal to those of employees without disabilities" (USEEOC, 2012).

Note that this says "reasonable" which would include finding ways to "help" work a position, not simply being moved into a position because of a disability. It would be impossible for the legal system to force a lesser qualified candidate into a job in which there was a more qualified candidate. That said, the injury did occur during work hours, and Wal-Mart should be somewhat more sensitive to this issue. Asking Huber to take a job…

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

Huber v. Wal-Mart. (2007, May). United States Court of Appeals, 8th Circuit. No. 06-2238. Retrieved from: http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-8th-circuit/1289819.html

Wal-Mart Worker Cancels High Court Clash. (2008, January). Bloomberg TV. Retrieved from: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=a5gjEo3pYRDU&refer=home

Lavin, H. And DiMichele, E. (2011). Split Circuits: To Reassign or Not to Reassign. Employee Relations Law Journal. 36 (4): Retrieved from: http://www.stroock.com/SiteFiles/Pub1042.PDF

U.S. Department of Justice. (2013). Americans With Disabilities Act. Retrieved from: http://www.ada.gov/
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2010). Q & A on the ADA. Retrieved from: http://www.ada.gov/qandaeng.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Discrimination and Affirmative Action
Words: 1026 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Discrimination and Affirmative Action Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) enforced by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) prohibits private and state and local government employers with 15 or more employees from discriminating against individuals on the basis of disability. Title I of the ADA also generally requires covered employers to make reasonable accommodations -- changes in the workplace or in the way things are usually done

ADA When a Reasonable Accommodation
Words: 413 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

The union, however, must be part of the process of determining a reasonable accommodation where the reasonable accommodation would cause a material, substantial or significant change in working conditions" to the unionized employees (Johnson, 2007). However, negotiating reasonable accommodations, "may conflict with the NLRA prohibitions on direct dealing and unilateral changes to terms and conditions of employment," which must be established during the collective bargaining process (Johnson, 2007). Thus the

Discrimination in the Workplace: A
Words: 3155 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Discrimination against the elderly, against pregnant women, against women with children, against people of color are all prohibited under the law. The EEOC or Equal Employment Opportunity Commission was created to administer Title VII of the Civil Rights act and specifically to "progress race, national origin, religious, and sex discrimination claims pursuant to the statue" (Gregory, 2003). Is the EEC doing its job? During the first year alone after

ADA & Racial Discrimination Summary
Words: 3400 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

Sheriff Jones caused an internal investigation to b conducted. The investigation found that Smith has not violated any law or policies of the department and further did not violate any rule regarding the use of fire arms. After all these findings disciplinary charges were made against Smith and were awarded with 30 days suspension. After a due process hearing the board which went into the issue concluded that Smith was

Disability Act in the Workplace
Words: 2141 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Proposal

Slotting summer jobs or paid internships specifically for high school, college and post-grad students with disabilities; (2) Affirmative action and mentoring for people with disabilities. (Whether and how to implement affirmative action depends on organizational culture and applicable law.); (3) Training and professional development for people with disabilities; (4) Accomplishments of goals, services available, etc. In your organization's newsletter, bulletin board and reports, to the extent that other groups

Disability Politics and the Disability Movement in Britain
Words: 8090 Length: 25 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Census Bureau in the United States, there are about 54 million Americans that have some sort of disability. Out of these persons, 26 million persons have a severe disability. While employment rates are concerned, it should be seen that 82% of the people in America without a disability have a job or some sort of business. Keeping this in mind, it should be seen that the employment rate of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now