Verified Document

Dillon V Champion Jogbra: Case Analysis Essay

DILLION V. CHAMPION JOGBRA The objective of this study is to examine the case Dillion v. Champion Jogbra and to answer the following questions: (1) What are the legal issues in this case? (2) What is the implied contract in this case? (3) How did the employer breach the implied contract in this case? (4) Why did the disclaimer in the employee manual fail to have the effect desired by the employer?

What are the legal issues in this case?

The legal issues in this case revolve around the employment at will of employees of the company Champion Jogbra and the wrongful termination of the employee Dillion. Additionally at issue in this case is Champion Jogbra's 'Corrective Action Procedures' which are included in Champion Jogbra's employee handbook. The Corrective Action Procedures require that the company take specified steps prior to terminating an employee which includes that management use "training and employee counseling, to achieve the desired actions of employees." (p. 528) The Corrective Action Policy is reported to establish "three categories of violations of company policy and corresponding actions to be taken generally in each case." (p. 528) The Corrective Action Policy further is reported to delineate "progressive steps to be taken for certain types of cases including unsatisfactory quality of work and time periods governing things such as how long a reprimand is considered active." (p. 528) The result is that employees are sent messages that are mixed and the Corrective Action Policy in effect is inconsistent with the employment at will disclaimer contained in the employee manual.

Dillion states that when she was hired she was promised specified...

In addition, Dillion states that Champion Jogbra, and specifically her immediate supervisor informed her that she would not be comfortable in doing her job for a period of six (6) months and that she was not to worry about that. However, after Dillion had been employed by Champion Jogbra for a period of approximately two (2) months, she was called into her supervisor's office and informed that her work was not satisfactory and that she was to be placed in a temporary position. Dillion was informed that she could apply for other positions within the company and should she not be assigned to another position by the end of December that she would be terminated. Although Dillion did apply for one other position, she was not chosen to fill that position and at the end of December her employment with Champion Jogbra was terminated.
II. What is the implied contract in this case?

The implied contact in this case is that Dillion will be on the receiving end of specified and sufficient training by her predecessor and that if her work is found to be unsatisfactory, after a period of six (6) months that Champion Jogbra will follow the specified actions set out in the Corrective Action Policy prior to terminating her employment.

III. How did the employer breach the implied contract in this case?

The employer did not provide what was sufficient training as specified in the oral agreement between Champion Jogbra and Dillion when Dillion was give the job. In addition, the employer, Champion Jogbra informed Dillion that she would not be…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Dillion v. Champion Jogbra 819 A. 2d 703 (Vt. 2002).

Klingshirn, N. (2009) Writing Effective Employee Handbooks. Klingshirn Ohio. Retrieved from: http://www.fklaborlaw.com/articles/Writing-Effective-Employee-Handbooks.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Career Counseling
Words: 616 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Career Counseling -- Systems Theory The Case of Alex: Applying Systems Theory The work and personal life challenges that Alex is facing can be explained through various lenses; however, in this particular case, systems theory as applied in the multicultural environment context will be most useful to develop possible interventions that will help Alex re-establish his career in a new social environment (North Carolina). Systems theory, as defined in Arthur and McMahon's (2005)

Career Counseling in a Diverse
Words: 743 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

No matter how intelligent a person is and how successful he can be, there are many reasons for him to choose a career not really worthy of his talents. This can be due to the conception that some races do not succeed in a certain field. Similarly some women might want to become a space technician but not really take it up believing that women are not welcomed there

Career Counseling This Analysis of
Words: 2030 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

From the list of personal dimensions of development produced by the Association for Multicultural Counseling and Development (Arredondo et al., 1996), gender is the dimension most neglected or ignored, in spite of the fact that gender intersects with all other dimensions across cultures (see Hansen, Gama, & Harkins, 2002). Whether internal or external, one major weakness is the need to motivate more counselor educators to value career counseling and to

Career Development Career Counseling Is
Words: 1782 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Sixth, I look at Alex's vocational personality. I do this by looking at her stories through with Holland's RIASEC hexagon. Using this tool I see that she most resembles the Enterprising type (Holland's Theory of Career Choice and You, 2009). She likes to be a leader, act with enthusiasm and enjoys being the center of attention. In Alex's case it appears that her choice of becoming an attorney and possibly getting

Career Counseling Mc Is a
Words: 579 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

RT, in his mid-30s, has worked for the services sector in the past 7 years as a Business Development manager. He is currently out of work because the agency he used to work for 'folded up' when it was badly hit by the economic recession in 2008. He has tried setting up a small business right after his resignation, but he has not managed to improve his company's financial status

Career Counseling and Multicultural Students in School to Work Transition...
Words: 4299 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

Career Counseling and Multicultural Students in School-to-Work Transition Good career counseling always takes place within a cultural context, which is true regardless of ethnicity. Current theoretical models may not be adequate to explain the career behavior of racial and ethnic minorities. Vocational assessment has to be culturally sensitive, and only culturally appropriate tools should be used in vocational assessment. The goal of career counseling is to help clients make career choices that

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now