Verified Document

Digital Rights Management Ethical Dilemmas Research Paper

Related Topics:

Search Engines and Online LibrariesContent Creators

There are several people who might fall into the class of people who create intellectual property. First, there are creatives, for example writers, visual artists, or even project managers such as directors or the team who write code for software. All of these are actively involved in the creative process. When they are doing as employees or contractors of a company, then typically the rights flow to the company, as the financier of the project. But someone creating on their own should have full right to distribute as they please, whether or not this involves active digital rights management. There are examples of star acts that have sought to exert greater control over their work, using digital distribution models to bypass record companies. This is an example of a content creator exerting their natural control over how they distribute and control their work (Clemons, Gu, & Lang, 2002-2003). Open source software provides a similar example, except where the content creator specifically denies their intellectual property rights.

Producers

The control over production processes often leaves content creators with a fee or set percentage of commission based on sales, with the rights holder actually being the company that financed the venture. These producers – music labels and academic journal publishers being two examples – claim themselves as category a. They are, however, not. Their claim is based on legal precedent, which in turn is based on a capitalist logic that the entity that puts up the capital is taking the most risk, and therefore should...

Other schools of thought, however, such as socialist schools, argue that the control over production should be owned by the people. Even a softer view than what the 19th century communists envisioned would still apply creator rights to actual creators. The royalty would go to the publisher/distributor, paid for their service. It is only disparity of bargaining power between creators and publishers that reverses this arrangement, but there is no ethical or moral reason why differences in bargaining power need to be codified into law. Producers have legal rights because of that codification, but I struggle to find a reasonable ethical argument that they should have such rights, and certainly would struggle to hold that those rights are inalienable and ethical.
End Users

An end user in this case could be someone who enjoys a piece of music and wants to share it on YouTube for others to discover and enjoy. Or it could be an adult, no longer in university, who wishes to continue learning and requires access to the latest scientific research to do so. These individuals would fall into category b, someone who might use devices to bypass restrictions. Such individuals fall into this category when they seek to obtain access to a work that they would otherwise need to pay for. I believe that they fall into the category because there are ethical issues raised when anyone – but especially the poor or otherwise disenfranchised – is denied access to something like knowledge. (I know that example is cherry-picking, but it is also where the greatest ethical dilemma lies).…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Digital Rights
Words: 2611 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Digital Copyright problem of the Digital Age is that while information is easy and economical to publish and disseminate, exploitation of digital copyright and intellectual property rights remains a contentious issue. The question of who owns the right to digital information is one of the most hotly contested issues on the Web today. The subject of intellectual and digital copyright is fast becoming a topic that is expected to have

Ethics and Morality of Intellectual Property Rights
Words: 1678 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Digital Rights a) Sonderholm (2010) describes intellectual property rights as "a socio-economic tool that creates a temporary monopoly", specifically as a means to allow creators to earn profit, which in theory will incentivize more creation. On the issue of digital rights management versus the public's right to fair use, there are several issues to unpack. First is that a person who creates intellectual property has no obligation to do anything with it.

Ethical Changes in the Classroom
Words: 6690 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

The Vietnam War was a turning point in the Army's growing realization that senior military leaders, and not just political leaders, had a responsibility to be able to speak to soldiers, to the American people, and to the press about ethical issues. The Professionalism Study of 1970, examined institutional systems and requirements for success in the Army, attitudes and values of senior officers, and tasks for the 1970s. One of

Management and Decision Sciences From
Words: 25680 Length: 90 Document Type: Thesis

76). As automation increasingly assumes the more mundane and routine aspects of work of all types, Drucker was visionary in his assessment of how decisions would be made in the years to come. "In the future," said Drucker, "it was possible that all employment would be managerial in nature, and we would then have progressed from a society of labor to a society of management" (Witzel, p. 76). The

Management & Corporate Responsibility Patagonia
Words: 4562 Length: 15 Document Type: Corporate

Patagonia Strategic Management & Corporate ResponsibilityIntroductionPatagonia is a subsidiary of Lost Arrow, a privately held firm established in 1973 by climbers and surfers. Patagonia is a purveyor of outdoor clothing and gear and manages its research, design manufacturing, and sale of its products. The firm is driven by developing essential products for outdoor activities rather than profit-motivated production. Patagonia has a competitive advantage due to unique technological innovation in the

Marketing Management This Report Will Be a
Words: 2446 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Marketing Management This report will be a thorough analysis of a chosen marketing management problems. In this report, the approach taken will include thorough analysis of a total of five recent studies. The thematic marketing management problem studied here will be the impact that the ethical standards can have on the entire marketing management structure. The studies chosen will be studies from five different perspectives i.e. The background of the studies

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now