¶ … Difficulties
Empirical research is necessarily designed to provide a workable framework through which a researcher may test a hypothesized explanation for observable phenomena, but the two primary branches of scientific inquiry differ greatly in terms of the analytical scope and style employed throughout an experiment. While quantitative research is capable of recording, sorting and analyzing voluminous amounts of numerical data, from credit card usage rates for various tax brackets to the pace of population acceleration within a given demographic, this methodology is left lacking when researchers seek to explain the trends and configurations they have identified. In order to develop informed explanations of behavioral patterns, emotional capacity, artistic inclination, and any number of similarly intangible phenomena, the use of qualitative research must be employed to ascertain the motivational processes used to determine basic decision making. Although the traditional quantitative method of research is more widely known by laymen, with surveys, questionnaires and tests becoming ubiquitous in today's modern informational age, qualitative methodologies are most often applied to explain shifts in cultural attitude, collective experiences such as childrearing or aging, and other aspects of human or animal behavior which must be firmly comprehended before they can ever be improved upon.
The "Hawthorne Effect"
Although qualitative research is the preferred mode of study within the social sciences (anthropology, political science, psychology, etc.), researchers who employ this methodology often encounter a series of difficulties which must be overcome if valid conclusions are to be drawn from the data gathered. Although a wide variety of methods can be used within a qualitative study to collect and sort data, including ethnography, action research, and narratology, each is limited by the same set of inherent threats to validity. Among the most infamous of these methodological hurdles is known as the "Hawthorne Effect," which describes a curious but confirmed phenomenon whereby the participants of a qualitative research study alter -- on either the conscious or subconscious level -- the very behavior being subjected to scientific scrutiny. A simple qualitative study conducted by the National Research Council in 1924 became the impetus for this theory, after researchers attempted to determine whether improved ambient lighting in the workplace -- in this case Western Electric's Hawthorne Plant in Cicero, IL -- enhances the productivity of workers therein. Although increases in visibility and ambient lighting did result in the expected rise in worker productivity, the research team stumbled upon an apparent aberration when they elected to return the work environment to its previously dim and dingy atmosphere. When the workers under observation continued to produce demonstrable gains in productivity, despite the lack of light previously thought to be the limiting factor of their output, researchers realized the mere act of observing the subjects was enough to perceptibly influence their behavior, and "from these experiments, emerged the concept of the "Hawthorne effect," which is defined & #8230; as an improvement in the performance of workers resulting from a change in their working conditions, and caused either by their response to innovation or by the feeling that they are being accorded some attention" (Levitt & List, 2011).
Impact of the Researcher's Perspective
When expanded to the entirety of qualitative research, the "Hawthorne Effect" can be more widely defined as "the confounding that occurs if experimenters fail to realize how the consequences of subjects' performance affect what subjects do & #8230; (because) performance is impacted -- possibly unconsciously -- by possible positive or negative personal consequences unconsidered by the experimenter" (Parsons, 1974). Also known as the "observer effect," the phenomenon whereby test subjects inevitably alter their behavior based on awareness that they are being observed has limited the acceptance of theories generated from qualitative research studies, simply because the validity of any conclusions is entirely dependent on the independence and authenticity of the data being collected and analyzed. Although the specter of the "Hawthorne Effect" must be recognized and respected by researchers engaged in qualitative study, the problem actually derives from a broader limiting factor affecting the manner in which qualitative research is performed.
Gaining Entry
Whenever a demographic group is identified as possessing traits which warrant further study, the researcher's next priority is gaining entry to this group, and in doing so their ability to mitigate the influence of the "Hawthorne Effect" becomes effectively nullified (Lofland, Snow, Anderson & Lofland, 2006). The concept of gaining entry becomes paramount when conducting fieldwork, because qualitative investigation is reliant on the willing submission of accurate information by the organizations or individuals subjected to study. In a comprehensive review of the entry issues associated with qualitative methodologies titled "Strategies for Gaining Access to Organizations and Informants in Qualitative...
Even when they are presented with more information related to their condition, people who embrace the S1 model can refuse to change their option. In certain circumstances, individuals who apparently employ analytical thinking are actually using intuition. It seems that they are using investigative judgment because they are aware that surface data should not be accepted without comprehensive examination. In this situation, intuition can be practical, since it assists the
Experimental Research Methods in Business Experimental Research Methods The author provides a survey of the literature illustrating applied experimental research methods in cross-sections of business and organization types. The advantages and disadvantages of the experimental research methods are discussed for each of the examples provided which run the gamut from depression-era agricultural economics to research conducted for the National Science Institute. While the article focuses on business research methods, the range of
(Niglas, 2004) Stated to be research questions that should guide the empirical study design are those as follows: (1) How have quantitative and qualitative elements been related? What type of combined designs have been sued? What is the level of integration between qualitative and quantitative aspects of studies? (2) Why have the authors chosen to prefer multimethod or mixed design to monomethod approach? Do they offer a rationale for their choice? What
Experimental, and Survey Research Social researchers have a wide array of qualitative and quantitative research methodologies available to them, including field, experimental and survey research. Each of these research methodologies has some strengths and weaknesses that make them better suited for some applications than others. The purpose of this paper is to provide a review of the relevant literature concerning field, experiment and survey research to identify their respective strengths
Quantitative Research Critique Part I Introduction It is important to note, from the onset, that the health and wellbeing of women is often impacted upon negatively by intimate partner violence (IPV). In the past, various research studies have attempted to not only assess the impact of IPV on the health and wellbeing of women, but also the strategies that ought to be implemented in seeking to care for victims of IPV. In
The case studies compiled and edited by Caro-Brice (2007) provide a somewhat broader perspective than the singular case study conducted by Coles-Ritchie and Lugo (2010). These studies are all geared towards promoting equality in instructional methods and learning rates in diverse classroom settings, however, making them directly useful in this review and plan development. Some of the central common findings of the studies compiled by Caro-Brice (2007) and the lessons that
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now