Verified Document

Deontological Ethics And Law Essay

Ethics and morality feature strongly in Twain's Huckleberry Finn. Set against a backdrop of antebellum social stratification, the novel shows how individuals like the title character make their moral choices. Moreover, Huckleberry Finn is a coming-of-age story showing how the title character discovers his own moral voice. His deepening friendship with Jim, and the conflicts that friendship cause him due to race relations in the antebellum south, help Huckleberry Finn distinguish between the artificial morality ensconced in unjust laws and the genuine moral truths of friendship and universal human rights. Huckleberry Finn's decision-making process reflects both virtue ethics and Kantian deontological ethics. The Fugitive Slave Law is morally unjust from the perspective of Kantian deontological ethics. Requiring that all witnesses of runaway slaves report the transgression to the authorities, the Fugitive Slave Law upholds a morally turbid social and economic system. Yet as a white boy, Huckleberry Finn has never been taught to question the morality of slavery. He has been raised to believe that blacks are inferior to whites, which is why he continually reflects on the subversiveness of his friendship with Jim. Even the strictest interpretation of Kantian ethics would struggle to resolve Huckleberry Finn's moral conflict. On the one hand, Huckleberry Finn associates moral righteousness with obedience to the law and the social codes that govern the only society he knows. On the other hand, the boy associates moral righteousness with human dignity and the mores of friendship. Ultimately Huckleberry Finn realizes that there is a difference between moral righteousness and the law, particularly when the law itself is unjust. Being indoctrinated into the social system of the antebellum South makes it challenging to reach the conclusion, which is why Huckleberry Finn's conscience haunts him.

Virtue ethics highlight the character's morally upright nature. Huckleberry Finn reacts to the calling of his conscience with virtue, recognizing that his conscience...

As a child still, Huckleberry Finn is an ethically innocent creature, allowing Twain to embed virtue ethics into the story without becoming pedantic. Huckleberry Finn is still shaping his own moral character, his own moral virtue. Society threatens to impart its own set of moral standards on him, based on his race and gender, yet innately Huckleberry Finn knows that slavery is dehumanizing and that race does not determine a person's relative value, worth, or dignity in the society. Choosing friendship and justice over the law proves the Huckleberry Finn is morally virtuous. He does not have to learn moral virtue; in fact, he reaches his conclusions about Jim totally independently.
Throughout the novel, Huck is confronted with situations that require him to choose between a rigid moral framework such as one suggested by Kant, and a virtue ethical framework. Each time, Huck opts for a course of action that showcases his virtue. Moreover, Huckleberry Finn even veers toward utilitarianism. He does not mind breaking the law as long as by breaking the law he is promoting the common good. In this case, the common good is represented by a new moral order in which the dignity and rights of all people are valued above the institution of slavery. Although Huckleberry Finn as a novel falls short of presenting a full condemnation of slavery, the title character does exhibit a virtuous moral character that indicates that slavery is an immoral institution. As a child, and as a child who did not have a strict upbringing due to his delinquent dad, Huck is liberated from the society that upholds immoral institutions and ensconces those institutions in the law. Alternatively, institutions like slavery are entrenched in religious institutions.

Jim is Huck's only real friend throughout much of the novel, and it seems shocking that Huck would even consider turning in his friend. However, Huck's conscience also reflects his virtuous character in that Huck does not want to disappoint "Poor Miss Watson." He cares much more for pleasing her and acting kindly toward Miss Watson than he cares about obeying the law or conforming to Christian behavioral standards. After all, the Christian values that Huck learns are as falsely framed as the Fugitive Slave Law. The motif of the "conscience" represents the great sway that social norms and expectations have on a person's character and ability to make ethical decisions. A weaker moral character might have buckled under the pressure, listened to the conscience -- which is a false moral voice. The conscience is no moral voice; it is simply the vestiges of indoctrination into a dysfunctional social and ethical system. Deontological ethics fail Huck Finn because deontological ethics are too simplistic, narrow, and rigid to be realistic in a complex world. Religion often provides the voice of "conscience," too. Huck's main concern is remaining faithful to those who care for him; not remaining faithful to an abstract deity. Thus, Huck realizes that…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Twain, Mark. Huckleberry Finn.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Deontological Ethics in Vocational Dilemmas
Words: 558 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

This exposes another weakness of the deontological approach: it provides no guidance for determining which of two contradictory rules must be respected. If the supervisor respects the company rule prohibiting disclosing the information to the employee, he must violate the general moral rule prohibiting lying. Conversely, if the supervisor respects the general moral rule about lying, he must violate the company policy about non-disclosure. In this particular scenario, the supervisor

Deontological Ethics
Words: 760 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

I have two thoughts regarding your narrative about duty. The first is that I see your point with respect to people having different ideas about what their duty might be towards others. Holly and yourself are described as having different ideas about what her duty towards Chelsea should be. That's a valid point – if we are to use a deontological framework then that assumes that we all have roughly

Kant Deontological Ethics Suggests That There Are
Words: 581 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

KANT Deontological ethics suggests that there are certain moral principles which are so important that one should follow them as if setting a moral law for all time. Kant formulated his categorical imperative to suggest that there are some transcendent moral laws that are applicable to all situations, and cannot be waived no matter how dire the consequences (Kant and business ethics, 2013, RS). Anticipated positive consequences, according to deontological ethicists,

Difference Between Teleological and Deontological Ethics
Words: 732 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

ethics, teleology refers to consequentialist ethics, in which the morality of an action is based on its consequences rather than on the nature of the act itself. Utilitarianism is a type of teleological ethics, because utilitarianism is based on creating the maximum amount of happiness (or some other predetermined desirable outcome such as prosperity or health) for the most people possible. Ethical egoism, the view that benefitting the self

Kant Deontological Ethics -- Also
Words: 1025 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Ross thought that all people should be benevolent and so if lying affects one's benevolence, one needs to decide if lying is better for the sake of benevolence. Ross' non-absolutist take to ethics is preferred because is considers what is morally right in certain situations. In the instance of a Poker game, it is a game that relies upon lying or "bluffing" so it actually does pass Kant's universal law

Ethics Statement I Base My Personal Ethics
Words: 985 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Ethics Statement I base my personal ethics on the rights and responsibilities lens from the Four Ethical Lenses. This lens focuses on the key questions such as: What rules and duties must we follow? And What rights are relevant? This standard of ethics is rooted in deontological ethics, where our actions are guided by our sense of right and wrong, and that sense is in turn guided by society's standards. Consider the aspect

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now