Verified Document

Democracy Is Better Than Bureaucracy Term Paper

As an economist who had studied administrative and regulatory law, he saw the waste and inefficiency in socialism, but he points out that Lenin and Hitler, as well as the British champions of socialization and "thus the most eminent advocates of socialism implicitly admit that their tenets and plans cannot stand the criticism of economic science and are doomed under a regime of freedom" (von Mises 119)

In Bureaucracy, von Mises concluded that every man cannot be an economist, that professionals have an advantage over laymen as they devote all their time to that one thing, becoming specialists in their area. Highly regulated fields include environmental protection, healthcare, and professional licensing. Understanding and applying principles of administrative law are critical to a smooth functioning of government. Administrative law is also important in interactions with government in its proprietary capacity, such as eminent domain, real estate development, contracts and construction. As the amateur cannot become a specialist, but needs to have a voice in the overall effect of the bureaucrats' rule, von Mises proposes there be a "middle way," capitalism regulated and regimented by government interference with business. "But this government intervention should not amount to full government control of all economic activities; it should be limited to the elimination of some especially objectionable excrescences of capitalism without suppressing the activities of the entrepreneur altogether" (von Mises 122).

It would be a mistake to leave all regulatory and economic decision-making to professionals, to completely abdicate to professionals in administrative, social, educational or other governmental issues, even though the ordinary citizen does not concern him or herself with such things as agriculture, flow-charts, zoning or road-building. Bureaucrats can ply their expertise in these areas, but the citizen, if he or she wants to be self-determining, must at least gain some kind of judgment in these areas to guide the bureaucrats into decisions that do not encroach on the rights and ability to act independently, of each citizen. Oversight of compliance audits, knowledge of governmental agency functions and assistance in training citizens in the legislative systems must be in place. As von Mises said at the end of his argument,

Democracy means self-determination. How can people...

It is, on the contrary, a treasure that must be daily defended and conquered anew by strenuous effort (von Mises 125).
In conclusion, bureaucracy has its place in the regulations and administration of a government, but when it begins to encroach on the rights of people, it must be limited. Expertise is needed in most areas of government and is invaluable in a democracy. However, experts must be controlled by the tenets of democracy, and must allow the common man (or woman) to determine how many and what kind of decisions may be made about their lives without seriously limiting their rights and freedom.

References

Benson, H., (Jan-Feb 2005). Focusing the AFL-CIO debate: Bureaucracy v. Democracy. Union Democracy Review #154. Jan-Feb 2005.Association for Union Democracy.

Webster, N. (1974). Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language. Nashville: The Southwestern Co.

A von Mises, L. (1944). Bureaucracy. Auburn, Alabama: Mises.

Large corporations are entities that most people work for and are used to, that focus all power on the leaders, as "the deciders," who make decisions, good or bad, for everyone below them. The employees of a large corporation must go along with the decisions that the leaders make because they have no choice. A government run on these principles is not a democracy. It is a bureaucracy.

Today workers in unions fear that, though it is more efficient, the bureaucratization of the labor movement will incorporate independent small unions and combine them into an assemblage of 15 or 20 organizations, which would parcel out all jurisdictional rights of the smaller unions and reduce the labor union to one, huge bureaucratic entity. Workers, if they are dissatisfied with union leaders would be unable to replace them, and be locked into this system. Under a bureaucracy, central labor councils in cities and states would be subject to strict control by the officers of huge internationals, who would appoint all their delegates and officers and deprive them of autonomy. The bureaucracy, they fear, would even view union democracy as a diversion or an impediment to carrying out union plans.

Sources used in this document:
References

Benson, H., (Jan-Feb 2005). Focusing the AFL-CIO debate: Bureaucracy v. Democracy. Union Democracy Review #154. Jan-Feb 2005.Association for Union Democracy.

Webster, N. (1974). Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language. Nashville: The Southwestern Co.

A von Mises, L. (1944). Bureaucracy. Auburn, Alabama: Mises.

Large corporations are entities that most people work for and are used to, that focus all power on the leaders, as "the deciders," who make decisions, good or bad, for everyone below them. The employees of a large corporation must go along with the decisions that the leaders make because they have no choice. A government run on these principles is not a democracy. It is a bureaucracy.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Bureaucracy According to Weber and
Words: 2522 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Such resources will include proper funding for facilities, personnel, technological and communicational resources and other such elements required for an administrative capacity congruent with the needs of the public which it is designed to serve. It is thus that the bulk of Meier's book concerns the actual structure of a government based on the principle of bureaucracy. Here, he explores in detail the relationship between a variant of agencies and

Democracy or Not for Economic Development
Words: 2986 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

South Sudan gained independence from Sudan in 2011, but has been embroiled in civil conflict ever since. This instability has hampered the ability of the country to lay the groundwork for developing its economy. The evidence shows that there is a pathway to economic development, even for the least-developed country, and this paper will elaborate on what those steps might be. South Sudan is a landlocked country of 12.5 million people

Democracy in the United States What Type
Words: 1730 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Democracy in the United States [...] what type of democracy is the U.S. What are the most democratic and least democratic features of American national government? Do you believe that the U.S. presently embodies the core values of a democracy or do you believe that the U.S. has yet to attain the essence of democratic ideals? Democracy is one of the most sought after forms of government, and some

How to Implement Policy
Words: 1173 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Democracy and Bureaucracy There is a natural tendency for bureaucracy to grow larger in a democracy if left unchecked. Much of this arises because of similar growth tendencies that can be found in other organizations. However, in the democratic form of government, there are challenges present in governmental bureaucracy that are unique to this sector. For example, in private companies there are typically chains of authority that are responsible for the

Toulmin's Model for Arguing About Holding Bureaucracy Accountable
Words: 986 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Toulmin's Model On Holding Bureaucracy Accountable "How to use this worksheet": "Toulmin's model is an effective tool to help you question your sources and the essential elements of your own argument." "Use a separate copy of this worksheet to evaluate each of your sources. Once you've identified the specific parts of each argument, compare the claims, the data, the warrants (along with any qualifiers, rebuttals, or backing). Note where arguments are similar or

Role of Democracy in the Middle East
Words: 1732 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Role of Democracy in the Middle East There has recently been a wave of democratic uprisings sweeping across the Middle East. Starting in Tunisia, the call for democratic reforms spread through Egypt, Bahrain, Yemen, Jordan, Syria, Iran and many other nations. Many have likened these uprisings to the social unrest of 1848, which gave rise to the Communist Revolution of 1917, but they do so wrongly. While the popular uprisings

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now