Verified Document

Defense Of Globalization Jagdish Bhagwati And The Essay

¶ … Defense of Globalization Jagdish Bhagwati and the Defense of Globalization

It has lately become fashionable to talk about the evil face of globalization as a parasitic force that devours small nations and economies for the benefit of the rich and powerful countries. The anti-globalization movement today has a wide range of supporters, in the West and developing countries, among politicians, scholars, students, environmentalists, human rights activists, and many others. Globalization, these critics contend, further enriches the rich and impoverishes the poor, by using international trade and financial institutions and imposing Western forms of economics on the rest of the world. But in this paper I argue, using insights and arguments from the works of Columbia law and economics professor Jagdish Bhagwati, that the attacks on globalization are contradictory, misguided, and unjustified. Globalization, I argue, has been a force for good in the West and the rest of the world.

One of the oft-repeated charges directed against globalization is that it is a new form of colonialism and imperialism. In the words of Indian anti-globalization activist Arundhati Roy, globalization is "a mutant form of globalization" (Roy, 2002). The main problem with such characterization is the overly simplistic understanding of global forces. Globalization refers to worldwide integration of political, economic, and cultural institutions, but it is the economic form of globalization that comes under heavy criticism most often. The problem with Roy's characterization is that Indians, Saudis, Guatemalans, or any other people from the developing world using financial institutions for their own benefit is also the result of globalization. People in poorer nations having access to the rest of the world by using the Internet, computers, cell phones, tablets, etc., is also thanks to globalization. It would be ludicrous to describe these processes as a "mutant form of colonialism."

There is much more to globalization than just exploitation of weak nations by predatory multi-national corporations. It is true that some multi-national corporations use the loopholes in the international institutions or the corruption in local governments...

There is no denying to that. But it should not distract us from positive sides of globalization. For example, when predatory corporations commit crimes against workers in poor nations or pollute their environment without adequately compensating for that, it is thanks to the forces of globalization these poor nations can hold powerful multi-national corporations to task. These forces include the United Nations, international human rights and environmental organizations, the international media, and the world public without whom it would have been impossible for any poor nations to challenge these corporations. But for some reason, anti-globalizationists do not take this into account. And that is the essential contradiction of anti-globalization position.
As today's one of the foremost economists of the world Jagdish Bhagwati argues, "economic globalization has a human face and it advances, rather than inhibits, the achievements of social agendas as wide-ranging as the promotion of gender equality worldwide and the reduction of poverty and child labor in poorer countries" (Bhagwati, 2004a). Note that when some countries and cultures practice egregious forms of gender inequality or force children into labor, these abuses are exposed to the world more often than ever before today primarily thanks to globalization. Forces of globalization demand that some standards of labor and gender relations are met, inducing abusive governments to abandon their worst excesses.

The contradiction of anti-globalization activism is also visible in Western countries. As Bhagwati notes, during U.S. presidential elections in 2004, "Senator John Kerry has characterized companies that outsource as traitors -- even if, after doing so, Kerry and his wife dined on imported French wine and brie, rather than on Kraft cheese and Milwaukee beer, and watched a BBC Masterpiece Theater drama instead of a U.S. sitcom television" (Bhagwati, 2004a). Likewise, one might add, many right-wing U.S. politicians routinely call for imposing tariffs for Chinese products in order to protect domestic…

Sources used in this document:
References

Roy, A. (2002, Feb. 18) Shall We Leave it to the Experts? The Nation. Retrieved on 30 Oct. 2011, from http://www.commondreams.org/views02/0203-03.htm

Bhagwati, J. (2004a, March 5) What Enriches the Poor and Liberates the Oppressed. The Times. Retrieved on 30 Oct. 2011, from http://www.cfr.org/economics/enriches-poor-liberates-oppressed/p6843

Bhagwati, J. (2004b) In Defense of Globalization. New York: Oxford University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Globalization the Effects of Globalization
Words: 2539 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Bhagwati says, "But today's most dramatic change is in the degree to which governments have intervened to reduce obstacles to the flow of trade and investments worldwide (p. 11)." He emphasizes to make this next point, which is: But this fact forces upon our attention a disturbing observation: governments that can accelerate globalization can also reverse it. Herein lies a vulnerability that cannot be dismissed complacently. The earlier globalization, in

Globalization the Term Globalization Means a Process
Words: 927 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Globalization The term globalization means a process of increased interconnectedness among countries especially in terms of economy, politics as well as culture. The effect of globalization has been felt positively in all corners of the world this is due to the fact that it has been associated with most vital issues. A section of economists analyze globalization as a fast train which a country needs to build a platform so that it

Defense of Globalization This Present
Words: 2822 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Objective observers cannot but agree that the world has never been a better place than this and now. Norberg ascribes and attributes the swift adoption of globalization to the freedom of decision-making, whereby it has enabled individuals and economic freedom as the precedence for political freedom (2003). He writes: In the long run, it is hard for dictatorships, once they have accepted economic freedom, to avoid introducing political liberty as well

Globalization's Effect on the United States National Security
Words: 5279 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

Globalization's Effect on the United States' National Security Objective of this paper is to explore the impact of globalization on the United States national security. The study defines globalization as the increasing global relations of people, corporate organization and government. There is no doubt that the globalization provides numerous benefits to the American economy. Despite the benefits derived from the globalization, the advent of globalization also provides some threats to the United

Globalization, Regionalism, and Nationalism Do
Words: 752 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

In this light, globalization is expressed through regionalism. Regionalism can also be seen as a response to globalization. As different regions around the world start to share similar views and become cooperative with one another, regional loyalties and models become more accepted and promoted. In some ways, globalization seems to drive regionalization. For example, globalization is widely blamed for diminishing the American dollar, which means that imports are no longer as

Globalisation Leading Cultural Damage Exploitation Uderdeveloped...
Words: 3420 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Globalisation leading cultural damage exploitation uderdeveloped nations peoples." It include (a) Definitions "Globalisation" (b) Logic linking globalisation free market processes liberal creed. Negative effect of globalization to under developed countries Globalization has been a widely discussed topic among various authors, economics and business analysts and its' from the studies and research that the essay has been built on. First the essay will explain what globalization is and some of the characteristics of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now