Verified Document

Defense And Criticism Of Homicide Law Essay

Homicide Law is invoked in cases where cause of wrongful death of a human being is being investigated. The accused or defendant is tried under the appropriate sections of the law according to the merits of the case. The death may have taken place as an outcome of inconsiderate, reckless action of the accused or may have been willful, premeditated, intentional planning by the defendant. These mental afflictions and the perceived intentions resulting in the death attract vastly different penalties under Homicide Laws. Deaths caused in accidents may be viewed leniently by the court, whereas intentional killing attracts punishment of life term or even death where still applicable. Homicide cases are serious legal proceedings where the help of able criminal lawyers should be availed immediately by the accused (Homicide Law). Support for Homicide Law Today

Many states support Homicide Laws, for instance, death caused to fetus was included under Homicide Law by the state Senate New Hampshire, though the fetus age at which such implementation could be applied continued to be contested in the House. Fetus death would attract punishments under first-degree, second-degree-murder or negligent homicide. Exceptions to this rule included medical, assented termination of pregnancies by the woman carrying the child or legal guardian of the lady in question (Ramer, 2012). According to the House, the applicable age of the fetus would be 24 months whereas the senate voted in favor of threshold of 8 weeks into pregnancy. The senate had also discussed the point of conception or viability variables. The governor (John Lynch) himself, who supported the standard of viability, contested the concern of the Senate (Ramer, 2012).

The immediate cause for the enactment was the car crash that took place in which a drunk driver jumped the signal colliding with a car driven by a seven-month pregnant woman. An emergency cesarean section had to be performed that delivered a still born, which, though put on life support died after two weeks (Ramer, 2012). The negligent driver escaped negligent homicide, as at that time, to be considered a person, the baby had to be at least breathing and showing some signs of life at the time of delivery.

The extreme case of homicide is the premeditated, intentional murder and...

In the event of intent to kill a person even if another person is killed (inadvertently), the crime is still considered first-degree murder (Homicide Definition). In cases where prior planning is not affirmed, yet there the intention to kill is substantiated, as in the case of "in a fit of anger," voluntary manslaughter or second-degree charges may be applied and the variation depends on the particular States' laws. Manslaughter is considered a slightly lesser evil murder, and lesser still is involuntary manslaughter.
Involuntary manslaughter is applied to cases where death is caused in accidents wherein the defaulter driver was (Driving Under Influence). DUI is considered an act of criminal negligence (Homicide Definition). Voluntary manslaughter refers to cases of death of a person where premeditation or forethought of murder is not an established fact, and each state treats these situations differently. Different states interpret manslaughter differently, and provisions are made for exceptions to killings otherwise considered manslaughter, and then called "justified homicide." "Justified homicide" is best depicted as an act of killing in self-defense or even in trying to defend another vulnerable victim (Homicide Definition). Killing under substantiated acts such as these are usually allowed to escape manslaughter charges in intended murder, armed robbery or rape types of crimes.

Homicide Law Criticism

The felony murder doctrine has been contested for long. Some of these criticisms were well founded or at least had merit to some questionable provisions under these laws. Surprisingly, some of the drafters of MPC (Model Penal Code) also criticize the felony murder doctrine. The Supreme Court of Michigan however found little validity in the criticisms. For a considerable period, these laws were a part of every state law, although there was no valid reason offered for retaining it (Crump, 2009).

The discussions surrounding felony murder doctrine continues even today and two queries still need attention (Crump, 2009). The First is how to answer the latest criticisms to these laws? That becomes important, as even the previous queries have not been countered effectively. It is difficult to make a statutory…

Sources used in this document:
References

1)HOMICIDE LAW, HG.org <http://HG.org> Legal Resources, <http://www.hg.org/homicide-law.html>

2)HOLLY RAMER, Senate Backs Including Fetus Death in Homicide Law, The Telegraph, (May, 18, 2012), <http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/newsstatenewengland/961303-227/senate-backs-including-fetus-death-in-homicide.html>

3) Crump David, Reconsidering the Felony Murder Rule in Light of Modern Criticisms: Doesn't the Conclusion Depend upon the Particular Rule at Issue?, Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy, (2009), <https://www.questia.com/library/journal/1G1-204614060/reconsidering-the-felony-murder-rule-in-light-of-modern>

4) Draker & Robinson, AN INTRODUCTION TO THE MODEL PENAL CODE,
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Law and Wikileaks
Words: 4615 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

Wiki Leaks The whistle-blowing WikiLeaks is an online organization situated in Sweden; this organization distributed records termed "the diplomatic cables" from U.S. foreign negotiators on November 28, 2010. Upon their distribution, lawmakers from all corners of the U.S. political space censured the organization (Steinmetz). Within a brief time period, WikiLeaks turned into the biggest and most famous whistle-blowing organization on the planet. Due partially to the release of huge amounts of

Death Penalty in the Constitutional Law
Words: 4228 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

public to scholars, the death penalty has come under severe criticism in contemporary epoch. The debate between the supporters and criticizers of capital punishment has been going on for decades. Is death penalty constitutional? What are the factors that may render it unconstitutional? Is racial discrimination one of such factors? The paper uses a set of law review articles and highlights racial discrimination in death penalty in United States, discusses

Corporate Manslaughter Bill Research Organisation
Words: 12324 Length: 45 Document Type: Term Paper

The benefit of creating the term at this point is that lawmakers and prosecutors and defense lawyers will all be aware of the growth of the term as it moves through the judicial birth canal and is delivered in its full meaning, with all its parts in working order and ready to be tested at trial. Draft Corporate Manslaughter Bill Important as the corporate manslaughter bill is to many people, it

Gangs Military Weapons Tactics Unclassified//For
Words: 721 Length: 2 Document Type: Article Review

Call for backup before attempting pursuit into unsecured potential gang situations 5.. Examples of gangs deploying military weapons and tactics against law enforcement: 2005: Contract assassination attempt against corrections officer in Lakewood, Wash. By United Blood Nation gang member in active service from Bremerton Navy Station (10) 2005: Ceres, California: Active-duty, U.S. Marine Iraq combat veteran gang member shoots two police, killing one, using military tactics (11) 2006: Verbal testimony by several gang members

Women and the Death Penalty
Words: 5499 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Women and the Death Penalty Analysis An Analysis of the Historical Effect of Gender and Race on the Application of the Death Penalty in the United States While the debate over capital punishment continues to rage in the United States, questions of why the death penalty is viewed as ethical by some, while others would view it as unethical become increasingly significant. In addition, there are new controversies concerning the ethical nature

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for
Words: 6266 Length: 20 Document Type: Capstone Project

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for topic selection Causes of racial prejudice and discrimination Juvenile in delinquent society theory Culture and values Official and unofficial values The effectiveness of the death penalty The death penalty is irreversible The death penalty is barbaric Changes to the death sentence Implemented changes Sentencing guidelines Bifurcated trials Automatic appellate conviction review Proportionality review The importance of proposed changes Anticipated outcome Life imprisonment; alternative to death sentences The costs Decency standards Overall efficiency Policies in support of incarceration Conclusion References Background Despite the controversy over how effective it is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now