Verified Document

Dealing With Affirmative Action In The New Public Service Essay

Affirmative Action Challenged Currently, there is an increasing move away from government-centered to multi-sectored public service entities. This has created a challenge for the maintenance of equality-based programs like AA in an environment that seems to have made this move increasingly outdated. Some have even mentioned that it is addressing a problem that no longer exists (Selden). As such, Affirmative Action (AA) has been and remains a widely divisive and contested issue since its implementation in the workplace.

The initial purpose of AA was to address issues of inequality in workplaces and learning institutions after the success of the equal right movements that started during the 1960s. Particularly, non-white races and women gained greater benefits from being included in these institutions. Since the 1960s, AA has been used more or less consistently to ensure an equally representative workforce across the country. When investigating what AA has in fact accomplished, however, results vary widely. Non-white races at colleges, for example, still fare somewhat worse than their white counterparts (Selden), while minority races and women still suffer discrimination in terms of wages and discrimination in the workplace.

Currently, support for AA varies across cultures and time, according to the specific ideologies and perceptions associated with these variables. In the past, for example, there was more support for AA than has been found in later years. Indeed, there appears to be steady decline in such support. Furthermore, another finding of Selden's is that AA has more support among non-white races than among white people. One underlying reason for this could be perception, where non-white races believe the model helps to promote a sense of equality they do not yet have, while those in historically privileged positions believe that all races have the same opportunities in terms of access to work. There is therefore an underlying discrepancy in how the races and genders view AA in addition to the actual working of the program in terms of success and promoting equality.

In general, support for AA has diminished across the country, and authors like Selden have suggested that a new model is required to replace the one that has been known up to now. The issues to be investigated include:

The effectiveness of AA across the country in terms of promoting equality in various sectors.

The perception of AA among different populations.

The perception of AA among managers and leaders.

The way in which courts have enforced or modified AA policies in the workplace and colleges.

The...

For many colleges and sectors, for example, there have been predetermined quotas to ensure an acceptable level of representation in terms of the demography of the country. The underlying concern, however, remains whether these quotas have effectively promoted actual equality in terms of job performance, wages, and the benefits to companies. Many have argued that the requirements engendered in AA have prevented more qualified persons from entering a position as a result of their skin color. This has led to the perception of "reverse discrimination," in which qualification is not the primary requirement for obtaining a position. This is at the heart of many racial tensions throughout the country. In that regard then, it could be said that, while AA has created a more level playing field for minority races and groups, it has also created greater division on the social platform.
Several courses of action are open in addressing the above-mentioned challenges. The easiest is probably to simply let AA programs carry on and develop according to court decisions and social policies. Another option is to investigate the precise effects of AA within organizations and colleges to determine the true efficacy of programs operating under this umbrella. On the strength of the results, the extent of still existing problems can be determined and addressed. Communication is a further important strategy. From the above, it is clear that different people have different perceptions of the need for and efficacy of AA. Many opponents consider it to be an outdated system addressing specific problems that no longer exist. Based upon this communication, strategies can then be devised to create a system that is more in keeping with the majority of ideologies and perceived needs.

If a problem is identified, the words way to handle it is probably by doing nothing, since this means the problem will simply perpetuate itself and not submit to the active control of decision makers. The one advantage of this option is, however, that it will not require any investment in terms of finance or time. As for the second option, which is to investigate the effects of AA, this has been done by several research entities, with results that appear to indicate that problems still exist. When this option is chosen, it is recommended that it be based upon previous work rather than "reinventing the wheel," as it were. The advantage of this method…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Affirmative Action in Hiring and Firing in the Ad Industry and or...
Words: 3436 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Affirmative Action in Hiring and Firing in the Ad Industry and/or Ad Firms Advertising in the United States means a lot of money and as much as $2.1 million is spent on each advertisement during the Super Bowl advertisements lasting for 30 seconds. There is now a question as to whether the composition of workers within the industry, both in the creative sections and in the non-creative sections will affect the

Affirmative Action in Higher Education
Words: 2904 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Alamo of affirmative action, the University of Michigan. The contradictory stances of Bush and Powell on this issue are dealt with. So is the position of Gerald Ford who believes like the proponents of affirmative action that affirmative action procedures lead to diversity at the educational institutions and opportunities for the minorities that are seen as a must to be offered. Affirmative Action in Michigan Diversity and Achievement Is affirmative action the

American Disability Act and Affirmative Action Act
Words: 760 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

American Disability Act and Affirmative Action Act Critique of Modern Civil Rights Acts The quest to ensure that every American's civil rights are guaranteed is still being waged today. New populations of disadvantaged are continuing to be guaranteed by modern legislation the same every day benefits the majority of the population often takes for granted. Acts like the American Disability Act and the Affirmative Action Act are continuing to provide for the

New Haven Firefighters the Supreme Court Case
Words: 1494 Length: 4 Document Type: Article Review

New Haven Firefighters The Supreme Court case of Ricci v. DeStefano was heard in April of 2009, and the Court's decision was issued in favor of the plaintiffs on 29 June, 2009. The plaintiffs here, Ricci et al., were nineteen firefighters from New Haven, Connecticut who had sued the administration of New Haven mayor John DeStefano over the decision to disregard results from a written examination given for promotion within the

Public Accounting Lessons from Ethical Violations
Words: 4593 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Lessons from Ethical Violations in Public AccountingPublic accounting is a field faced with ethical issues similar to any area of practice. Unethical practices in accounting are often motivated by management greed, incentives, bonus, management pressure, and more. These practices only lead to short-term gains (Finn, Chonko & Hunt, 1988). The long-term impacts are usually negative consequences. Ethical behavior and practices are critical aspects of good accounting. Accounting regulations and rules

Dealing With Human Resources Issues
Words: 2014 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Comcast HR Summary of the Organization Comcast Corporation, a leading cable, telecommunications, and entertainment public company, was incorporated in 1969 (Funding Universe, 2014). The fourth largest cable company in the United States, it enjoys the patronage of 4.4 million subscribers in 21 states with its cable, cellular and wireless telephone products, which bring in enormous revenues. It also accounts for 26% of the entire manpower in the industry (Comcast, 2013). It boasts

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now