Verified Document

Culture Dismantling Identity Politics: The Term Paper

However, Kymlicka's (2003) close examination of the national and international has illustrated that they are largely shared by most modern, Western nations. Any presumed Canadian uniqueness is largely mythical (p. 368). Of course, mythology can be exceedingly unifying, and there is certainly an interest in Canada of perpetuating the dominant national myths of identity: Canadians as good global citizens, as part of the Western tradition, as a young modern nations, and as distinctly non-American. These national characteristics are generally championed as core parts of a unified Canadian identity, despite their largely exaggerated characteristics and despite the fact that these values do not necessarily unify the myriad subcultural groups within the nation. Aboriginal groups will probably always persist as distinct social and political units within Canada. Every attempt to nationalize the Quebecois have only managed to strengthen their sub-state nationalism (Kymlicka, 2003: p. 373). After centuries of attempting to force a singular vision of national identity on all subcultural groups within Canada that is uniquely Canadian, increasingly we find there is an acceptance of persistent difference and division within the nation.

Despite this, Canada as a nation has not crumpled or torn itself apart via internal strife and division. The nation's political and social institutions have been as successful as ever even as identity...

383-385). The obvious conclusion that can be drawn from this social and political reality is that identity politics is no longer the defining factor in determining the success of a nation. For instance, despite consistently failing to identify themselves as Canadian instead of Quebecois, that particular subgroup still utilizes and participates in Canadian social and political institutions. They still rely on public services like the police, still express their political identity through existing Canadian institutions, and still respect the rule of law that is in effect for the entire nation. Since the success of social and political institutions is dependent on the willing and active participation of citizens, and since cultural distinct groups seem quite willing to participate with one another, it stands that modern participation in the state is based on the legitimacy of its institutions (Kymlicka, 2003, p. 380). Identity politics no longer determines whether or not the modern, Western nation will succeed or fail. It is more important to have a citizenry that, while cultural distinct, nonetheless is willing to work together within the existing system of social and political institutions in the interests of the nation as a whole.
References

Kymlicka, W. (2003). Being Canadian. Government and…

Sources used in this document:
References

Kymlicka, W. (2003). Being Canadian. Government and Opposition, 38(3), pp. 357-385.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Identity Culture
Words: 1209 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

cultures and identities in today's world. The author explores the different dimensions that influence individuals and identities and how it impacts the way society operates in the world. There were five sources used to complete this paper. As the world continues to evolve, societal changes are taking place. Globalization contributes to the melting pot called earth and as societal barriers come down, people have a chance to learn about other

Cultural Identity As It Pertains
Words: 963 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Kymlicka is onto a good point in mentioning how Canada's social welfare system is a fairly unique benefit, springing from a uniquely Canadian attitude towards its citizens and the role of the state in the lives of its citizens. Kymlicka helps his constructive definition of Canadians by pointing out that they are almost unique in the OECD by not dismantling their social welfare benefits in the 1990's. Whether one agrees

Theoretical Perspectives on the War
Words: 6124 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Paper

Anarchy is but one aspect of the Realist paradigm. Anarchy is the impetus for all other components of the Realist theory to come into play. Elements such as power, security dilemma's, balance of power, polarity and alliances and ultimately war are all outcrops of the existence of any real centralized power and an absence of true legitimacy in the form of a well established, respected, influential central government. Each

Apartheid the Effective Boycott of
Words: 1857 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

'" (ANC, 1) The statement goes further to make a crucial point with respect to our discussion. Namely, it confirms the philosophical relevance of using the sporting world as a way to gain international attention and reinforces the rationale that this approach to change would help to illuminate the broader racial struggles in South Africa. Quite indeed, the United Nations would take up the logic that any endorsement of the validity

Salinas Pri Carlos Salinas De
Words: 6480 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

This, of course, would represent one aspect of the resentment served to Salinas. The other aspect would be the significant impact of the economic crisis and the continued devaluation of the Peso. These things reflected on the ineptitude of a party seldom challenged as it should have been. To most, the failures effecting the whole of the nation had marked the need for a hastening of democratic reform, which would

Post-Conflict, Peace/Nation Building in Iraq
Words: 7605 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

This includes putting in place international legal systems, dispute resolution mechanisms as well as cooperative arrangements.14 The call this approach social peace-building or structural peace-building. Such peace-building involves "creating structures -- systems of behavior, institutions, concerted actions -- that support the embodiment or implementation of a peace culture."15 This is what the author's call multi-track diplomacy. It involves individuals who are not normally involved in the peace process, particularly business

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now