Verified Document

Cultural Biases In Intelligence Testing Essay

Intelligence testing can be a useful means of measuring certain skills. However, intelligence tests are highly contextualized and also have the potential to be culturally biased. Although intelligence tests are “here to stay,” they can be administered, adapted, and used in ways that fairer and more representative of a diverse population (Ford, 2005). One of the ways intelligence testing can be culturally biased is that there are different types of intelligence, and some cultures favor some types more than others. According to Benson (2003), Western cultures—namely those located in North America and Western Europe—tend to favor categorization and rational debate over synthesis, collaboration, and complexity. Likewise, most non-Western cultures including those in Africa and Asia value social skills intelligence and also practical intelligence far more than Western societies (Benson, 2003). Cultural bias may also be evident in the ways children from families with high cultural capital may have access to the cognitive frameworks needed to perform better on intelligence testing. Therefore, the substantive content of the intelligence test may be culturally constrained. Another issue with cultural bias in intelligence testing has to do with context and test administration. Some of the types of intelligence tests administered in American schools are abstract, but “people who are unable to solve complex problems in the abstract can often solve them when they are presented...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Contextualizing questions or administering the test using different tools or environmental cues can be helpful. For example, Young (2013) found that test takers perform “better in the medium to which they were more accustomed,” such as pencil and paper versus oral tests. Cultural bias may also be an issue when it is considered alongside socio-economic class and privilege. Test takers who have been exposed to methods of learning and practice in their home and neighborhood environments may be predisposed to high performance on intelligence tests versus their counterparts from disadvantaged families or communities. Finally, intelligence testing could be culturally biased in terms of how the results are used. Most intelligence tests can be considered “high stakes,” in that performance on a single test early in life may guarantee placement in a gifted program (Ford, 2005). Tracking students using intelligence tests can therefore lead to systematic bias throughout the school system.
Warne, Yoon, & Price (2014) point out that cultural bias manifests in different ways. For example, if there is a score gap between two or more cultural groups, it will be easier to reinforce stereotypes about those groups and thereby perpetuate inequality (p. 571). Rather than point ot the intelligence tests as the problem, some educators have assumed that score gaps indicate relative superiority or inferiority of specific…

Sources used in this document:

References



Benson, E. (2003). Intelligence across cultures. Monitor in Psychology 34(2): 56.

Ford, D.Y. (2005). Intelligence testing and cultural diversity. The National Research Center on the Gifted and Talented, Retrieved online: http://nrcgt.uconn.edu/newsletters/winter052/

Warne, R.T., Yoon, M. & Price, C.J. (2014). Exploring the various interpretations of test bias. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology 20(4): 570-582.

Young, E. (2013). Intelligence testing: Accurate or extremely biased? Retrieved online: http://www.theneuroethicsblog.com/2013/09/intelligence-testing-accurate-or.html



 


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Intelligence Testing
Words: 1312 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Intelligence Testing Few concepts in psychology are more hotly debated than the idea of what constitutes human intelligence. The definition of intelligence has become part of current culture wars as well as an area of intense scientific debate. This paper examines one popular theory of intelligence, Howard Gardner's concept of 'multiple intelligences,' which has been proposed as an alternative to the theory of 'general intelligence,' or intelligence as a concept that

IQ & Cultural Bias IQ
Words: 2634 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

The researchers found that the student's minimum performance rate correlated more closely with their IQ scores than any other single variable. High and low IQ scores were predicted on the basis of the worst performance (minimum recall) and the best performance (maximum recall). When compared, those that were predicted on the basis of the worst performance were more accurate, indicating that "worst performance reveals more about intelligence than best performance"

Intelligence When Most People Think the Concept
Words: 2839 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Intelligence When most people think the concept of "intelligence," they think of how "smart" an individual might be. Typically associated with academic success, many imagine that intelligence has a lot to do with how well one did (or did not do) in school, and later, by how much money one can make in its exercise. However, as many people know, there are many different kinds of intelligence -- from the "book

Culture Bias in Intelligence Assessments
Words: 4715 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Culturally Biased Intelligence Assessment Intelligence assessments have existed since the early twentieth century and have continued to be a topic of debate. We all know full well that intelligence assessment is critical to the type if academic success that we achieve in life. One of the primary tools used to assess intelligence is the IQ test. However, the intelligence quotient test has been under scrutiny for decades because it is believed

Cultural Differences in IQ Scores
Words: 2525 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

IQ Test Scores Cultural Differences in IQ Test Scores Most studies carried out in the United States to measure intelligence (IQ) indicate a significant gap in the IQ test scores of Blacks and Whites. The gap is more pronounced in certain areas of intelligence such as general intelligence and on tests requiring problem solving and more complex mental operations than on tests of rote learning and immediate memory. The gap has narrowed

The Concept of Intelligence and Testing for It
Words: 1485 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Intelligence/Personality Tests The concept of intelligence and the practice (and practicality) of testing for intelligence has been one of the more controversial areas of psychology and psychometrics since the first tests were developed and administered a century ago. Far from there being a consensus in the scientific community on exactly what makes up intelligence, the list of characteristics that comprise intelligence has instead been a matter of extreme and ongoing debate.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now