Verified Document

CSR And Avoiding Exploitation Of Laborers Research Paper

Related Topics:

Ethics and Corporate Responsibility in the Workplace PharmaCARE's motto is "We CARE about YOUR health" -- and this assertion should be born out in the firm's actions and not just in its words. To understand the actual impact of the organization's actions, it is necessary to acknowledge its stakeholders and see how each is affected. By doing so, a better system of corporate social responsibility (CSR) can be implemented that will address the issues that face PharmaCARE in Colberia. By examining how other firms and multinationals have addressed CSR issues and comparing them to the situation that PharmaCARE faces, a detailed proposition based on the appropriate philosophical/ethical perspective can be generated. This paper will provide an overview of the stakeholders in the firm, how they are impacted by the organization's actions, how the firm can better itself ethically and responsibly regarding stakeholders, and how PharmaCARE compares to another company of a similar situation.

A stakeholder is one who is directly or indirectly impacted by the conduct of the company. Thus, a stakeholder can be a manager within the firm or a customer of the firm. It can be a political activist who receives donations from the firm and looks after its interests, or it can be a politician who represents a community where the firm does business. Stakeholders are in some way involved in and/or touched by the activities of the company. The stakeholders in PharamCARE consist of employees (both Western and Colberian), consumers/clients, and directors, as well as the recipients of its sponsored programs, including PAC fund recipients, scholarship recipients, and environmental lobby groups. The issue that the firm faces is that its commitment to health evidenced in its motto and mission is at odds with its actions in both the environmental realm and in the socio-political realm. For example, instead of committing itself to environmental protection, it has lobbied to overturn environmental regulations show that it can avoid being hampered by laws and regulations that are detrimental to its ability to turn a profit. This is an example of a company that puts profits before people, when the core of CSR should be putting people before profits, as it is the former that underlines the ability to produce the latter.

CSR is a way for firms to have a direct effect on the "social, environmental and economic environment in which" the corporation functions (Castka, Bamber, Sharp, 2005, p. vii). By devising good CSR policies, companies can be seen as being willing to commit to the actual health of the planet and the cultures/communities with which the companies interact, in a united effort to create a better place for all (Friedman, Miles, 2002). In order to appropriately structure the CSR policy, a firm should effect an adequate ethical foundation for itself, which serves as a guideline for how the company should address all issues that come up in its line of work (Pearce, Doh, 2005; AnyangoOoko, 2014). For instance, with PharmaCARE the company expresses its intent to help improve the health of people, but if it is opposing legislation that will help to protect the environment, then it is not living up to its motto, because if an environment is negatively impacted so too will be the people in that environment. PharmaCARE's outlook therefore is not currently being guided by an ethical framework that allows it to apply a systematic and ethical formula to every occasion. In order for it to succeed, it needs to do just this.

Another issue that the firm faces is its use of labor in Africa which consists of the exploitation of workers in Colberia, who are employed for slave wages ($1 per day) and are required to do heavy manual lifting and labor. This is not a caring practice and does not show concern for the workers of the company within that country (though Western employees are treated much better, having lavish accommodations, including swimming pool access and places of rest and living quarters that are quite different from those of the average African worker. Thus, there is a system of inequality evident within the firm and its operations.

Apple is one example of a company that has taken its business to other countries in order to profit from labor there. Apple has used Chinese labor, which it pays a similar rate for, and it has also dealt with the controversial issue of worker suicide by erecting nets outside its factories, so that workers cannot kill themselves by jumping out windows or from the rooftops (Copper, 2013). Apple's "sweatshop" factories, as they are...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

In fact, Apple CEO Tim Cook has denied that the company exploits Chinese labor for the sake of boosting profits, asserting that the skill level of the Chinese is just so much better than anywhere else in the world and that that is the reason the company hires Chinese workers instead of other workers in the West, for example (Sharwood, 2015; Langlois, 2015). Despite Cook's attempt to put a clean face on the company's activities in China, Apple faces serious human rights violations allegations and should adopt a CSR policy that is more strategically aligned with the ideals of modern society.
PharmaCARE's human rights issues in Colberia are related to its slave wage payments to African laborers, who are required to walk many miles carrying heavy loads. The company does not look after its African laborers in the same way that it does its corporate Western workers and does not provide a standard of living that is in keeping with its Western culture. Instead, it exploits the low standard of living among the native Colberians and symbolizes essentially a new era of colonialism. This is a human rights issue because PharmaCARE is hypocritically engaging in activity that it pledges to help fight -- and the same is true with its environmental policy: it claims to support environmental cleanup and protection but when it comes to passing legislation to ensure such protection, the company fights against it.

Three changes that PharmaCARE could make to better itself in terms of adopting an adequate CSR policy and ethical standard for itself and for its workers and stakeholders are the following:

First, the firm should increase the wages of its African laborers.

Second, the firm should ease the burden of its laboerers.

Third, it should support legislative efforts to protect the environment.

These three recommendations, when implemented, would show that the company is dedicated to helping everyone and that it is putting people before profits. It would be evidence of it actually having a sense of corporate social responsibility -- in action -- rather than just paying lip service to ideals that it does not actually attempt to bear out in practice.

PharmaCARE's environmental initiatives when judged in the light of its anti-environmental lobbying efforts shows that the company is not really committed to environmental safety and protection. Were it actually concerned about the environment, it would not engage in efforts to lobby politicians to vote against legislation designed to protect the environment. This gives the firm a false face and a bad public image, and it also undermines the company's intentions in so far as it aims to help preserve the environment.

In terms of Utilitarian principles, the actions of the company could be assessed as being in conformity with this set of philosophical guidelines, as the essence of this philosophy is that the greatest common good should be achieved: and from the company's perspective it may argue that the greatest good is achieved through the hiring of low wage employees in Colberia and through the defeating of environmental laws for reasons related to profit and the company's ability to grow. Without growth, there can be no product, so the company could argue. The problem with this system of ethics is that it is very subjective and open to interpretation -- so what is viewed as good by the company may not be viewed as good by other stakeholders and thus there could be a difference of opinion as to whether the firm is acting ethically or not. What is needed is a more objective and clearly defined approach to ethical practices.

This could be achieved through a deontology system of ethics, which obliges one to perform one's duty according to a set parameter of rules. In the case of PharmaCARE, the rules would be outlined in its mission statement and would relate to treating employees fairly and justly and to helping the environment and to improve people's lives. Following these rules and guides, the company would be obliged to support legislation protecting the environment (even if it cuts into the company's profits) and it would be obliged to boost the standard of living of its workers in Colberia (and not just its corporate workers).

With a system of virtue ethics, the corporation could be even more firmly placed within a framework that would ensure that it provides for both employees and the…

Sources used in this document:
References

AnyangoOoko, G. (2014). The environmental factors that influence implementation of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in an organization. Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 19(12): 95-102.

Castka, P., Bamber, C., Sharp, J. (2005). Implementing Effective Corporate Social

Responsibility and Corporate Governance: A Framework. UK: British Standards Institution.

Cooper, R. (2013). Inside Apple's Chinese 'sweatshop' factory where workers are paid just 1.12 per hour to produce iPhones and iPads for the West. Daily Mail. Retrieved from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2103798/Revealed-Inside-Apples-Chinese-sweatshop-factory-workers-paid-just-1-12-hour.html
Langlois, S. (2015). Tim Cook says this is the real reason Apple products are made in China. MarketWatch. Retrieved from http://www.marketwatch.com/story/tim-cook-apple-doesnt-make-its-products-in-china-because-its-cheaper-2015-12-20
The Register. Retrieved from http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/12/21/apple_60_minutes_interview/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Sweatshops in Third World Countries
Words: 2320 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Sweatshops in Third World Countries Not so long ago when the word sweatshop was mentioned, images of Charles Dickens would surface, for the notion of sweatshops seemed to be a thing of the past. However, in recent years, sweatshops have been at the forefront of media attention. They are back, actually they never truly went away at all, and they are back in full swing around the world, mostly in third

Sweatshops: Since All Children and
Words: 390 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Thus it can improve the fates of the sweatshop workers' children, by infusing income into the poorer nation. The argument in favor of the employment of illegal workers in the United States is that the workers chose their lot by illegally immigrating and often work under better conditions than they would on their home soil. Also, the children of the illegal workers will improve if the children are allowed

Sweatshops Are Sweatshops a Necessarily Evil Within
Words: 623 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Sweatshops Are Sweatshops a Necessarily Evil? Within the last few years, Americans have become aware that sometimes when American corporations send manufacturing tasks to foreign countries, those tasks end up being performed by people we would view as not yet adults -- young teenagers, and sometimes even workers younger than that. The companies argue that they do not always have either control or knowledge that such practices are going on, thus excusing

Sweatshops Simply the Word "Sweatshop"
Words: 440 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

A utilitarian would argue that to ensure the greatest happiness, for the greatest number, perhaps some suffering in the interim must be endured by the current generation of factory laborers in the developing world, so that industrialization can develop and so capitalism can take hold there. Moreover, the ethical quandaries we experience are not merely relegated to clothing -- what of how we profit off of the labor illegal

Sweatshop Girl: Sadie Frowne in "The Story
Words: 627 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Sweatshop Girl: Sadie Frowne In "The Story of a Sweatshop Girl," Sadie Frowne describes her life journey from peasant farmer's daughter to factory worker. Her description includes details of her daily life, and the difficulties she faces as a sweatshop girl in the early 20th century. Her narrative also illustrates prevalent social values of the time, as well as her individual values. Her focus on the specific details of her

Unfair Labor Laws and Sweatshops
Words: 1532 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The organization explains that consumers can take the initiative to speak out against companies that use sweatshops. (Ten Ways to end Sweatshops) They can also join campaigns such as OXFAM which attempt to ensure that special events such as the Olympics are not utilizing products created in sweatshops. Ten Ways to end Sweatshops) Conclusion The purpose of this paper was to discuss sweatshops, the impact that they have on the world and what

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now