Verified Document

Cross Cultural Service Essay

Related Topics:

According to Illich (1968), hypocrisy is, perhaps, an instinctive trait shared by majority of Americans. They are mentally prepared to accept that the motives of potentially legitimizing the 1963 international volunteer action are not applicable when it comes to performing the very same act five years later. “Mission vacations” involving the poor people of Mexico was the trend among wealthy American students during the initial half of the decade. Emotional concerns for the just-found poverty beyond the nation’s southern border, together with utter thoughtlessness to the far severer state of the domestic poor, warranted this benevolence. Intellectual understanding of the challenges linked to successful volunteer action failed to dull the spirits of the soi-disant volunteers, papal volunteers, and Peace Corps (Illich, 1968).
Illich (1968) believed the presence of institutions such as the Conference on InterAmerican Student Projects was actually insulting to the Mexican nation. He claimed he felt revolted by the whole thing and believed their actions and good intentions were not interrelated. To him, the theological idea of good intentions can help no one. Indeed, according to the Irish, good intentions mark the way to hell, which summarizes this theological understanding. However, he did state that he had profound faith in American volunteers’ good will (Illich, 1968).

This, though, may be explained through a terrible want of innate delicacy. By their very nature, Americans can’t help eventually being vacation salesmen for a bourgeois American lifestyle as they know no other life. Such a group couldn’t be conceived if there was no relevant ‘mood’ created in America in support of the notion that a true American has to share the blessings of the Almighty with underprivileged humans. The notion that all Americans have a few things to give, which they always must, explains the decision of students of that period to spend some months in Mexican villages and aid their farmers to develop (Illich, 1968).

After weapons and money, American idealists are the third greatest export of North America; they can be found in all arenas: teaching, voluntary work, missionary work, economic development, community organization, and vacationing altruism. Ideally, their role may be defined as service. In fact, they often alleviate the destruction wreaked by weapons and money, or attract third-world societies to the advantages of a world of accomplishment and prosperity. At this point, Illich (1968) feels that we had rather emphasize to Americans that their lifestyle is simply not sufficiently alive to share with all (Illich, 1968).

America can only survive if it persuades the remainder of the planet that it is a sort of ‘Heaven on Earth’, in Illich’s (1968) opinion. Its survival is contingent on the universal acknowledgment by the world’s “free” people that its bourgeois society has attained their goals. The American lifestyle, to the speaker, had grown into a religion that had to be adopted by everyone who wished not to perish by weapons like the napalm or sword. America has been striving worldwide to safeguard and develop minorities who consume that which is affordable to the American majority. This was the aim of the Latin America-United States bourgeois Alliance for Progress (AFP). However, this business association increasingly requires protection by weapons that enable the minority capable of “making it” to safeguard their accomplishments and procurements (Illich, 1968).

The AFP has garnered considerable success within the Latin American region in terms of increasing the share of individuals who have become more affluent (that is, the small share of bourgeois elites), besides giving rise to ideal military dictatorship conditions. Initially, the dictators served plantation owners; however, they currently defend the novel industrial complexes. Illich (1968) asserts that the American students aid Mexican underdogs in accepting their destiny....…trust between healthcare facility workers and Hmong community members. Further, facility employees have reconsidered care-related points in which Hmong community healers can be included; currently, they perform around eighty-five rituals and interventions. Such a cross-cultural marriage of biomedical technology and cultural beliefs may forge trust and relationships between communities from one case to the next (Brinkmann, 2018).

Physician-patient relations are grounded in layers of faith. It is taken for granted by patients, in general, that all professionals possess requisite abilities and knowledge for adequately performing their roles. Patients enter into therapeutic relationships with competence being the first trust level. While physicians normally don’t have to earn this facet of trust, it may be lost (e.g., if any significant/fatal error occurs on the part of the physician). The technical competence expectation is backed by ethical codes, professional role-regulating rules, and institutional procedures. As this constitutes the minimal trust level, clearly, forging an effective client-provider relationship which generates wellbeing or restoration of health entails more than mere clinical ability and know-how: it needs to entail something within their interpersonal interaction (Laws & Chilton, 2012).

Conclusion

It may prove highly rewarding to healthcare providers to work with those belonging to a different cultural background. Fadiman explains how the Hmong community’s culture deepened her personal insights into family, empathy and assistance. Such valuable views may be missed if the emphasis is solely on delivery of biomedical solutions. Contemporary medicine provides tangible resolutions to ailments and, according to Kleinman, can treat “both disease and illness.” Practitioners’ attempts at providing such solutions to a culturally-diverse patient pool will succeed better if they learn to accept others’ views and cultivate within themselves the requisite skills for incorporating them into everyday clinical decision-making. Their personal lives will also be enriched through being open to perspectives which differ from their own (Brinkmann, 2018).

References…

Sources used in this document:

References

Brinkmann, J. T. (2018, May). The Spirit Catches You: Cultural Collisions and Cooperation in Medical Encounters. Retrieved March 1, 2019, from https://opedge.com/Articles/ViewArticle/2018-05-01/the-spirit-catches-you-cultural-collisions-and-cooperation-in-medical-encounters

Fadiman, A. (2012). The spirit catches you and you fall down: A Hmong child, her American doctors, and the collision of two cultures. Macmillan.

Illich, I. (1968, April). To hell with good intentions. In Conference on Inter-American Student Projects. Cuernavaca, Mexico. Retrieved from http://www.swaraj.org/illich_hell.html

Laws, T., & Chilton, J. A. (2012). Ethics, Cultural Competence, and the Changing Face of America. Pastoral psychology, 62(2), 175-188.


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Cross Cultural Communication Interpretation Across
Words: 4205 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Email was found to be a key culprit in the development of cultural misunderstandings among a diverse group of online users (Rainey, 2000). Stereotypes were found to interfere with online communication, and enhance the potential for cultural misunderstandings (Leidner, 1999). Navigation design, visual design, and information design had an effect on trust that varied among different cultures viewing a website (Cyr, 2008). This research suggests a need for culturally relevant

Cross-Cultural Communication With Increased Competition Being Witnessed...
Words: 5474 Length: 19 Document Type: Essay

Cross-Cultural Communication With increased competition being witnessed in many industries, Multinational companies are setting shop to new foreign markets as a way of increasing their profitability and remaining competitive. Many countries have liberalized their markets, and present advancement in technologies has made it easy for companies to open new branches in foreign markets. However, this also comes with it challenges, particularly relating to cross-cultural communication. Effective cross-cultural communication is very important

Cross-Cultural Differences Risks of Outsourcing
Words: 4111 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Therefore, the standpoint of social embeddedness is a tool that offers to provide a clear picture if one wants to comprehend the contribution of the relational factors in the success of outsourced IS projects (Rai, Maruping and Venkatesh, 2009). If one is to increase his/her comprehension and develop an insight about how to monitor and control outsourced IS projects, Johns' (2006 as cited in Rai, Maruping and Venkatesh, 2009) suggestions

Cross Cultural Negotiation Management the
Words: 1318 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The employee could not however wait until the launch and directly entered in conflict with the manager, accusing him of conspiring to steal the employees' hard earned wages. 3. Framing of the Conflict Framing the conflict can be achieved from numerous standpoints, but given the characteristics of this particular conflict, the most relevant frame would be that of identity. This basically means that the two parties have different identities and the

Cross-Cultural Communication in Business Cultural
Words: 1074 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Proposal

In that regard, fundamentally different interactions between the genders is one element of cultural practices that differs most substantially from national culture to culture and even among individuals of different ethnic or religious backgrounds within the dominant national culture. Typically, individuals of Muslim and Jewish religious traditions (and others) avoid any incidental or polite physical contact between members of the opposite gender, even though such gestures (like handshaking) might be

Cross-Cultural Issue Cross Cultural Perspective Globalization. Globalization...
Words: 1361 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Cross-Cultural Issue CROSS Cultural Perspective GLOBALIZATION. Globalization and Starbucks Few aspects of individual's lives are more personal than that of the coffee they consume. The Starbucks Corporation has been forced to adjust its offerings and approach to marketing to address the needs and expectations of consumers abroad. There have also been ethical considerations about encroaching upon local businesses, as the Starbucks empire gains worldwide traction. Starbucks has tried to answer these concerns by

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now