Verified Document

Criminal Justice Random Prevention Patrol Term Paper

In addition, they could be effective in super high-crime hot spots, such as the bar the authors describe in Minneapolis, which recorded an astounding number of assaults throughout the year; roughly 1 in 4 patrons would suffer an assault during the study (Sherman et al. 44). Thus, random patrols in a hot-spot area like this could help deter crime and apprehend offenders. However, chances are that the very nature of the random patrol would be so random that it would not encounter criminal activity, and so, it would be less effective than other forms of patrol. Interestingly, most patrol officers disagree with the findings of these studies. Author Kelling and his colleagues write, "Three-fourths of those surveyed in the South Patrol Division [in Kansas City] more than moderately agreed that routine patrol was the most important function of the department" (Kelling, et al. 38). This is not only because they see their job function as vital to the department, but also because in their experience, they give the public a greater feeling of security, which is another primary aspect of their police work. However, the study showed this was actually not the case, despites the officers' beliefs, and that police forces need to take a new, fresh look at their patrolling options to develop new techniques for managing crime and apprehending offenders.

This also brings up the question of the number of officers in patrol cars, and what is the most effective number of officers. Most of the public (and police officers, as well), would think two-officer cars were the most effective in responding to crime and criminal activities, but a 1977 study in San Diego debunked that thought as well. Author David Kessler writes, "Among the more salient of these experimental findings were that one-officer cars were safer, had fewer citizen complaints, and were more efficient than two-officer cars" (Kessler 49). In addition, the study discovered that two one-officer police cars had faster response times to a crime scene than one, two-officer car had. The study concluded this was true because of the inordinate nature of competition...

This also seems contradictory to public and officer perceptions, but the studies were highly professional and geared to long-term, statistical results, and these results do not lie. Random patrols and two-officer cars do not make sense in modern policing, preventative patrols with one-officer cars are the best way to help deter crime and still give a sense of security to a community's citizens.
In conclusion, these studies indicate that random and routine police patrols are not effective in continually managing crime. The Kansas City study indicates that routine preventative patrols are not effective, but that targeted preventative patrols are much more effective in certain areas of crime. Studies also indicate that a one-person car is more effective at responding to crime. These studies, and many others, indicate that the traditional roles of the police officer are changing, and will continue to change. Will police patrols disappear in the future? Probably not. Even random patrols can prove effective in some situations, and targeted patrols have proven to be quite effective. The scope of police work is ever changing, and departments must be open to change and new ideas. Perhaps that is the real method for police management and control. Rather than relying on tried and true techniques, the most successful departments will hold themselves up as models of change, modernity, and openness to new, forward thinking policing methods.

References

Kelling, George L., Pate, Tony, Dieckman, Duane, and Brown, Charles E. The Kansas City

Preventive Patrol Experiment: A Summary Report. Washington DC: Police Foundation, 1974.

Kessler, David a. "One or Two Officer Cars? A Perspective From Kansas City." Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol. 13, 1985. pp. 49-64.

Sherman, Lawrence W., Gartin, Patrick R, and Buerger, Michael E. "Hot Spots of Predatory Crime: Routine Activities and the Criminology of Place." Criminology, Vol.…

Sources used in this document:
References

Kelling, George L., Pate, Tony, Dieckman, Duane, and Brown, Charles E. The Kansas City

Preventive Patrol Experiment: A Summary Report. Washington DC: Police Foundation, 1974.

Kessler, David a. "One or Two Officer Cars? A Perspective From Kansas City." Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol. 13, 1985. pp. 49-64.

Sherman, Lawrence W., Gartin, Patrick R, and Buerger, Michael E. "Hot Spots of Predatory Crime: Routine Activities and the Criminology of Place." Criminology, Vol. 27, No. 1, 1989. 27-55.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminal Justice Policing 210
Words: 921 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Police Roles and Functions: Similar to the teaching and medicine field, policing is a field that has close or intimate connections with social life, change, and progress. Police agencies are part of the complex network of law enforcement in the United States. While these agencies are distributed across the local, state, and federal governmental levels, they have varying degrees of specialty. Despite of these differing degrees of specialty across the police

Preventive Patrol Efficacy Random Preventive
Words: 1498 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

While the idea that the mere presence of police in a community cannot deter crime from occurring may be a bit saddening or hard to believe for many, the truth is simply that the Kansas City Preventive Patrol Experiment showed that it couldn't. While patrol may be considered the "backbone" of police work, as it has long been, the theory had not been scientifically tested until 1972 in Kansas. One of

Traditional Police Patrol There Are
Words: 3060 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Just a strict surveillance or acting upon people's calls and reporting of crimes might help people feel more secure and they might trust the police to help keep them safer. This way crime may be able to be controlled without even installing more policemen. The punishments for catching the criminal activities should also be strict enough for people to think twice before committing an act. According to the classical

Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994: Analysis of...
Words: 2303 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

Evolution of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994 Most Americans regard the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994 as the most comprehensive and far-reaching anti-crime bill in the country's history. The Act, which took up more than 1000 pages and an approximate $30 billion in costs, covered an overwhelming array of areas ranging from funding for late-night youth basketball programs to a ban on

Community Policing
Words: 4655 Length: 17 Document Type: Research Paper

Community Policing Efficacy The Violent Crime Control & Law Enforcement Act of 1994 heralded the beginning of a massive effort to reform policing strategies in the United States, in part through implementation of community-policing programs at the local level. Congress has allocated billions of federal dollars over the years since to support such efforts and by the end of the 20th century, close to 90% of all police departments serving communities

Community Oriented Policing
Words: 6694 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Community Oriented Policing new and comprehensive strategy against crime: Community Policing: For the purpose of reducing neighborhood crimes, creating a sense of security and reduce fear of crimes among the citizens and improving the quality of life in the community, the community policing strategy will be proved to be the most effective one. The accomplishment of all these objectives to develop a healthy and clean society can be done by combining the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now