Verified Document

Criminal Justice Law Term Paper

¶ … Fourth Amendment of the Constitution is designed to protect the right of the people to live in privacy. As such, it concerns itself with security against illegal or unjustified searches and seizures, as well as the inappropriate levying of warrants. However, the potential conflict that this amendment commonly incites against law enforcement practices causes much debate over specific application of its provision. In the case of Dopey v. The People of the State of California, the defendant has invoked the amendment, contesting that his conviction on charges of drug trafficking was invalid to the fashion in which officers obtained the evidence. Upon careful examination of the case, and based on the nature of precedent, Dopey's assertion is correct. Both the cash found in his house and the cocaine found in his car were collected by law enforcement in violation of the Constitution.

According to the "exclusionary rule," first invoked by Mapp v. Ohio (1961), any evidence gained by measures not accorded by the fourth amendment will be considered inadmissible to the court and can therefore not be used in building a case against the defendant. This condition applies directly to the Dopey's situation.

Of particular note is that Dopey was arrested inside his home by officers who used neither an arrest warrant or a search warrant in doing so. Entering his home by force, they made the arrest and proceeded to search the home, thus finding the case considered in evidence.

According to Payton v. New York (1980), reasons that could be considered valid for making an arrest in a public place can not be employed likewise in a home. In the home, probable cause is not enough for forcible entry and arrest. An officer...

Because the police failed to acquire said warrant, all evidence found inside the house must be considered inadmissible. Also, this fact calls into question the very legitimacy of the arrest.
If the arrest is to be considered valid, than the evidence still would be considered inadmissible under Chimel v California (1969). The $11,000 was found in a room in which the arrest did not occur, which, according to the above cited case, makes it inadmissible. Because it was not in the direct vicinity of the arrest, the evidence could not be considered yielded from a search incidental to a valid arrest.

Because the legitimacy of the arrest itself is severely questionable, it hearkens New York v Belton (1981) in which it was established that a car may be searched only if the arrest of the suspect is a valid and legal apprehension. This, of course, could be negated by a circumstance of 'in plain view' which would than demand a search of the vehicle.

In the case of Dopey, the arrest is not entirely valid, and no circumstances of the incident or evidence acquired within the house were sufficient enough to imply exigency. And though there was a substance that was believed to be heroin on the defendant's car seat and floor, in plain view, the substance was found to be a legal substance. As such, there was no imperative to impound the vehicle or conduct a more intensive search therein. That being the case, the cocaine found in the spare tire compartment of the…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminal Justice Law Enforcement Some Things Are
Words: 1827 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice Law enforcement Some things are fundamental to the history and progressive development of human society. The evolution of technology brings with it new challenges in the management of the security of the state. For this motive that law enforcement systems is set in the society to maintain and promote law and order (Law enforcement, 2002). Law enforcement systems act in organized manner, in the process of promoting adherence to the

Criminal Justice Management and Administration
Words: 2074 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Criminal Justice Management and Administration The objective of this work in writing is to describe the historical and theoretical development of organizational management and to list and summarize the most common positions, functions and positions in various Criminal Justice Organizations. The work of Stojkovic, Kalinich, and Klofas (2008) reports that criminal justice administration Management "has come a long way since the President's Commission in 1967 called for a closer look at the

Criminal Justice Procedure A Case Study
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

Criminal Justice ProcedureCriminal justice involves varying procedures that commence with an investigation process and ends when a prisoner is released from prison facilities after serving their sentence. Rules and decision-making guide the criminal justice process. In this situation, a case study is analyzed revolving around Chris, a police officer from the Centerville Police Department, who obtains a search warrant for a house. The case contains a series of criminal justice

Criminal Justice Law
Words: 1178 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Moose Horn Police officers admissible at trial, since no Miranda warnings were given to the defendant at any time? In the case of Sleazy vs. The state of decency the statements made by the defendant were not admissible in court because the officers did not inform Sleazy of his Miranda rights. These rights should have been stated to the defendant when it was obvious to the police officers that section

Criminal Justice Trends the Trends of the
Words: 1924 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice Trends The trends of the past, present and future that outline the borders connecting the criminal justice system components and their links adjoining the society is, beyond doubt, an authentic relationship that the law and society have established. Criminal justice has been affected by various trends in the times gone by. This is because trends keep changing with the passage of time. Therefore, it is exceedingly important for the

Criminal Justice System Normally Refers to the
Words: 1488 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Criminal justice system normally refers to the compilation of the prevailing federal; state accompanied by the local public agencies those pacts with the crime problem. These corresponding agencies procedure suspects, defendants accompanied by the convicted offenders and are normally mutually dependent insofar as the prevailing decisions of the single agency influence other supplementary agencies (Cole & Smith, 2009). The fundamental framework of the underlying system is normally granted through the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now