Verified Document

Criminal Justice For Possible Outcome 2, Two Essay

¶ … Criminal Justice For Possible Outcome 2, two groups in a population have been subjected to different treatments. One group served as the control group and was not given the opportunity to engage in an educational program that featured the study of human rights violations. However, the group was given course credit for watching a series of films on nature. The second group watched films that dealt with the Holocaust, Darfur, Rwanda, and the famines in eastern Africa. The groups randomly selected from the prison population, but were not randomly selected for the groups. Both groups had been in the prison facility an average of five years. Both groups were surveyed before watching any films, following each film and at the completion of the courses to measure the effect of the film on the subjects' empathy scores using standardized instruments. Mean scores of empathy ratings were charted below, with the blue line showing the mean scores of the treatment group and the green line showing the mean scores of the control group. The control group showed very little to moderate change in their empathy scores as a result of exposure to the nature films. The treatment group showed increases in their empathy scores with each subsequent film, and their overall empathy score increased to a greater degree than did that of the control group.

For Possible Outcome 5, two groups in a population were subjected to the same treatment. Both groups watched films that featured human rights issues, particularly with a focus on women and children. The control group consisted of prisoners who had convictions of domestic violence, child abuse, sexual abuse of minors, and sexual predation. The treatment group consisted of prisoners who were convicted of non-violent crimes that did not have any features of sexual predation or sexual deviancy. Subjects in both groups completed surveys before watching any films, following each film, and at the completion of the series of films. Mean scores of empathy ratings were charted below, with the blue line showing the mean scores of the treatment group and the green line showing the mean scores of the control group. The control group reported having moderate levels of empathy throughout the series of films, but overall change of empathy was not observed. The treatment...

They use words like "effect" and "duration," indicating that they understand the variables that influence program implementation success. Further, the authors also point out the importance of interdependency in policy analysis and implementation research. They argue that several factors must be considered in order to make recommendations about the profitability or payback periods of crime prevention policy decision. That their approach to policy analysis is based on sound empirical practices is evident in their statement that, "Crime prevention policies are not delivered in a vacuum." Nor should policy implementation research.
In the Appendix, the authors explain the scientific rigor of the process they adopted for their analysis. Programs and practices were selected on the basis of demonstrating that they were conceptually coherent and could be made subject to evaluation. This clarity enabled them to be confident that the definitions of the independent variables were constructed in clear language with would contribute to reliability and validity. For a program to be considered evidence-based, the authors looked for demonstrations of effectiveness. If evidence of effectiveness could not be identified, the authors considered the availability and level of resources that were expended on a category of programs and practices. Categorically, the two groups (evidence-based and resource-based) were treated differently.

Articles of Interest

"The Academy of Experimental Criminology: Advancing Randomized Trials in Crime and Justice," by David Weisburd (Hebrew University and University of Maryland, Lorraine Mazerolle (Griffith University) & Anthony Petrosino (Learning Innovations at WestEd). This article was of interest to me because I was curious about how scientists might "sell" the idea of randomized trials to both the public and to funders. When…

Sources used in this document:
The study population. All homicides in the murder analysis files of the Chicago Police Department from 1965 through 1995

The observation unit. Individuals.

The sampling method. All homicides were included, but In cases where the offender data were completely missing in the victim-level data, no offender records were generated in the offender-level file. The offender-level data do not contain information about the victims in these cases.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminal Justice System in Two Countries
Words: 4897 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Criminal Justice System Ever since gaining independence status, both Mozambique and Zimbabwe have come under the scanner for violation of human rights incidences and extrajudicial excesses. The under trials, often arrested without formal sanctions have been continually processed through undemocratic norms and subjected to undue treatment when in confinement and under the control of policing authorities in spite of the fact that statutory provisions in the constitution provide assured guarantee

Criminal Justice Field Define What
Words: 4874 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

In the experimental community, the researchers instituted a media campaign to increase seat-belt usage, followed by increased police enforcement of the seat-belt law. It was found that the percentage of drivers using seat belts increased in the experimental community but remained stable or declined slightly in the comparison community (Piquero and Piquero, 2002). An example of the before-and-after design would be the analysis of the impact of the Massachusetts Bartley-Fox

Criminal Justice & Criminology Has the Miranda
Words: 3614 Length: 14 Document Type: Research Proposal

Criminal Justice & Criminology Has the Miranda vs. Arizona ruling decreased the percentage of arresting official violations of defendant Fifth Amendment rights? (Rian) CJ327W Research Methods in Criminal Justice The Miranda vs. Arizona ruling has attracted notable attention to the treatment of the accused in the hands of the law. Specifically, the ruling affirmed the rights to the accused under the law and to the legal rights of the accused. The research was

Criminal Justice Process a Felony
Words: 2551 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

A plea-bargain is frequently attained at this time in order to circumvent a trial. In the event that a plea-bargain is reached, the case does not move forward to a trial but failure to offer enough evidence to establish a plea bargain will mean that the case goes on to trial (Criminal Justice System Handbook, 2009). The trail Trials consist of a sequence of proceedings where the prosecutor presents evidence which

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for
Words: 6266 Length: 20 Document Type: Capstone Project

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for topic selection Causes of racial prejudice and discrimination Juvenile in delinquent society theory Culture and values Official and unofficial values The effectiveness of the death penalty The death penalty is irreversible The death penalty is barbaric Changes to the death sentence Implemented changes Sentencing guidelines Bifurcated trials Automatic appellate conviction review Proportionality review The importance of proposed changes Anticipated outcome Life imprisonment; alternative to death sentences The costs Decency standards Overall efficiency Policies in support of incarceration Conclusion References Background Despite the controversy over how effective it is

Criminal Justice Discuss the Ethical
Words: 1414 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

A researcher must limit the number of external and internal variables outside of the study variable that could affect the outcome of the study. What are the disadvantages to the classic experiment? The primary disadvantage of an experiment is that the controls imposed by a researcher to control for rival causation may create artificial conditions that alter the ability for the results of the study to be generalized to other populations.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now