Verified Document

Criminal Cases And Civil Cases: The Criminal Justice System Essay

Criminal Justice System: Criminal Cases and Civil Cases Civil and Criminal Liability

Civil cases are private disputes arising between individuals following violations of legal responsibilities owed to each other. Criminal cases, on the other hand, involve wrongs committed against the state, and which are regarded as harmful to society as a whole, as opposed to a single individual. This text compares civil and criminal cases with the aim of identifying differences and similarities, as well as the role played by either in the administration of justice.

Parties Involved: a civil case begins when an aggrieved party (plaintiff) brings suit against another party (defendant) for failing to honor a legal responsibility owed to him/her. In this scenario, the case is filed at the state or federal court by the wronged party, and both the defendant and the plaintiff are referred to as 'litigants' or 'parties to the suit' (Find Law, 2014). Failing to live up to a contract is one of the most common contributors to civil cases. We can take, for instance, the example of a lumberyard and a carpenter, who enter into a contract where the former is to supply a specific quantity of wood to the latter for a specified period of time -- if the lumberyard fails to deliver the same as agreed upon and the carpenter is consequently forced to buy the wood from another vendor, perhaps at a higher price, the carpenter could sue the lumberyard for damages, where he could petition the court to order the defendant to pay the extra costs incurred (Find Law, 2014a). The government and corporations can also file civil cases; for instance, the government could bring a civil suit against a medical facility for overbilling Medicaid or Medicare (Find Law, 2014).

In criminal cases, however, it is not the aggrieved party's duty to bring suit against the defendant. This duty is taken over by the government through either the federal or the state prosecutor's office. Unlike in a civil case, therefore,...

In a rape incident for instance, the prosecutor, acting for the state, would bring suit against the rapist, and the victim herself would not be party to the criminal action (Find Law, 2014).
Burden and Standard of Proof: the burden of proof can be defined as "the duty placed upon a party to prove or disprove a disputed fact" (The Legal Dictionary, 2014, n.pag). In criminal cases, this burden is charged on the prosecution -- the state or federal prosecutor must demonstrate that the defendant is guilty beyond reasonable doubt (The Legal Dictionary, 2014). In civil proceedings, on the other hand, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff, who has to prove that he/she suffered damages as a direct result of the defendant's action (s) (The Legal Dictionary 2014). The standard of proof is, however, usually lower in civil cases particularly because the punishments are often less severe and the offences less blameworthy (Find Law, 2014b). In most cases, plaintiffs are required to only prove the defendant's guilt on the balance of probabilities.

Punishment: criminal cases usually attract more stringent penalties than civil action. Probation, incarceration, jail terms, and monetary fines are potential punishments in criminal cases. Civil cases, on the other hand, will often only result in orders to either do or not do something, or in some circumstances, monetary damages (Find Law, 2014b). Penalties for criminal action will often result in the loss of personal freedom on the side of the defendant, which is why they are considered more severe.

Constitutional Protections: the stakes are much higher in criminal proceedings compared to civil ones, and for this reason, the legal system places safeguards geared at protecting the rights of defendants in criminal cases. These include the right to a jury trial, entitlement to an attorney; Fourth Amendment protections against illegal and unwarranted searches…

Sources used in this document:
References

Arizona Judicial Branch. (2014). How a Case Moves through the Court System. Arizona State Government. Retrieved 14 December 2014 from http://www.azcourts.gov/guidetoazcourts/HowaCaseMovesThroughtheCourtSystem.aspx

Find Law. (2014a). Civil Cases vs. Criminal Cases: Key Differences. Find Law. Retrieved 15 December 2014 from http://litigation.findlaw.com/filing-a-lawsuit/civil-cases-vs.-criminal-cases-key-differences.html

Find Law. (2014b). The Differences between a Criminal Case and a Civil Case. Find Law. Retrieved 15 December 2014 from http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-law-basics/the-differences-between-a-criminal-case-and-a-civil-case.html

The Legal Dictionary. (2014). Burden of Proof. The Legal Dictionary. Retrieved 15 December 2014 from http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/burden+of+proof
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminal Justice System: Ethics in Criminal Procedure
Words: 958 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice System: Ethics in Criminal Procedure Ethics refers to the principles of morality that govern an individual's behavior. Ethics, therefore, provides the basis through which an individual defines, and distinguishes between the good and the bad. This implies that it is ethics that provides the framework for the duties and responsibilities an individual owes to himself, and to the community. Today, ethics define how corporations, professionals, and individuals relate with

Criminal Justice System
Words: 661 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice System Discuss the means by which police gain access to a suspect's records of cell phone numbers called and received. How do police deal with text messages and emails? Obviously, criminals are using cell phones, text messages, and emails to plan and commit crimes. How does the Fourth Amendment apply to these types of technologies? In what do suspects have a reasonable expectation of privacy? The way that police are

Criminal Justice System of Britain
Words: 1568 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

In this way, the prison system in Britain is attempting to incorporate cultural diversity into the criminal justice system, in an effort to ensure success. In addition, many other agencies now offer translation services, support services for culturally varied populations, and are working with other agencies to provide consistent improvement in the representation of the varied populations of Britain. In attempting such an open-armed policy, the criminal justice system is

Criminal Justice System in Two Countries
Words: 4897 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Criminal Justice System Ever since gaining independence status, both Mozambique and Zimbabwe have come under the scanner for violation of human rights incidences and extrajudicial excesses. The under trials, often arrested without formal sanctions have been continually processed through undemocratic norms and subjected to undue treatment when in confinement and under the control of policing authorities in spite of the fact that statutory provisions in the constitution provide assured guarantee

Criminal Justice System of Haiti
Words: 1675 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

As per the constitution of Haiti – promulgated in 1987 – the government of Haiti has an obligation to not only offer basic protections to the citizens of Haiti, but also maintain law and order. The country’s judiciary, which happens to be one of the three arms of government, is made up of the magistrate’s courts, civil courts, courts of appeal, and court of cassation. This text concerns itself with

Criminal Justice System Essay
Words: 3528 Length: Document Type: Essays

This essay discusses how the criminal justice system is an important part of the government, allowing for the prosecution, imprisonment, and rehabilitation of criminals. Apart from the court system and police, the criminal justice system has other components like criminal justice agencies that provide additional information for researchers to form studies and articles to help improve the criminal justice system as a whole. This Criminal Justice Essay will help students

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now