Verified Document

Crime Scene Evidence Essay

Crime Scene Evidence Laying the Foundation for Crime Scene Evidence

In recent decades, significant advances in forensic technology and communications have revolutionized the art of collecting, sharing and using evidence to prosecute and convict accused criminals. These advances definitely make it easier for law enforcement (police and prosecutors) to put criminals away, but this not at the expense of the accused's constitutional rights to a fair trial. Therefore, courts have established different measures for ensuring that the forensic evidence that is used against a defendant is authentic and reliable. This paper will discuss the various safeguards in place and how law enforcement navigates through the process to maximize the benefit of the available forensic technology.

Generally speaking, on order for forensic evidence to be used against a defendant in court, the state must lay a proper foundation for that evidence. Specifically, this means the state must demonstrate that the evidence is authentic, reliable and relevant. The court (judge) in each individually case will determine whether the proper foundation has been laid, based on certain accepted standards established by statute or previous cases. Without the right foundation, the evidence cannot be used by the prosecution and the state will have a more difficult, or impossible, task of proving the defendant's guilt.

Authenticity

Authentic forensic evidence are items which are proven to be the same items collected from the crime scene, ranging from objects to bodily samples to photographs. Authentic items of forensic evidence typically do not photocopies of objects or replicas of items. Also it is the responsibility of the state to prove that the evidence is authentic. The Federal Rules of Evidence set forth the requirement for authentication in Rule 901 of the evidence code[footnoteRef:1]. Most of the time, the state only need introduce evidence through oral testimony of the chain...

[1: Federal Rule of Evidence 901 Requirement of Authentication or Identification-(a) General provision. -- The requirement of authentication or identification as a condition precedent to admissibility is satisfied by evidence sufficient to support a finding that the matter in question is what its proponent claims.]
Reliability

Reliability is also a key determinate in measuring the admissibility of evidence for which a proper foundation must also be established. Reliability of evidence equates to the likelihood that conclusions of certainty, free of doubt and speculation, can be drawn from the evidence. It is easiest to prove the reliability of a physical object. For instance, a weapon found at a crime scene will likely be admitted into evidence upon the testimony that the victim's wounds were consistent with the type of wounds made by that weapon and that the weapon was found at the crime scene.

Other types of evidence require more scientifically precise measurements to be accepted by the court, especially a scientific analysis of the type that is required for most forensic evidence (DNA, fingerprints etc.…). The Supreme Court has held that in order for scientific evidence to be reliable and therefore admissible, four criteria must be met:

1) The evidence must be based on a testable theory or technique;

2) The theory or technique must have been peer reviewed;

3) The particular testing technique used must have a known error rate and standards controlling the techniques operation; and

4) The underlying science must be generally accepted in the scientific community[footnoteRef:2]. [2: Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509…

Sources used in this document:
cited in the preceding footnotes, relates to the legal relevance of the expert witnesses who will present the forensic evidence and the corresponding incriminating conclusions. Thus, the relevancy question plays a crucial, if indirect role in forensic evidence.] [5: Federal Rule of Evidence 403- Exclusion of Relevant Evidence on Grounds of Prejudice, Confusion, or Waste of Time]

Laying the Foundation to Specific Forensic Evidence

As discussed briefly above, different types of crime scene evidence require very different evidentiary foundations. Common objects/samples contained at a crime scene that are examined forensically include fingerprints, blood alcohol level, blood typing, DNA testing and identification of firearms. For fingerprints, the state will have to show that the fingerprints taken at the crime scene are the ones that were tested for identification (authenticity); that the prints 'lifted' by the crime scene technician were clear enough to make the positive identification (reliability) and that the prints match those of the defendant and this fact helps prove the defendant committed the crime (relevance).

For blood alcohol, blood typing and DNA analysis, the state must show the chain of custody of the sample taken from the crime scene until the time of testing and trial (authenticity); the scientific reliability of the testing done to reach the conclusions; and that the results implicate the defendant (relevance). Finally to admit a firearm into evidence, the state must show that the firearm is the precise weapon removed from the crime scene via a chain of custody and other methods, such as through serial numbers (authenticity); that science proves the weapon matches the type of weapon used in the crime (reliability); and that the weapon helps to prove the defendant's guilt (relevance).

Conclusion
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Crime Scene Management
Words: 1101 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The Importance of Effective Crime Scene Management The purpose of this paper is to provide a review of the relevant literature to explain the importance of securing crime scenes in order to protect evidence from contamination and preserve it for use by the courts. In addition, a discussion concerning different methods that might be necessary to document evidence at a crime scene and different collection methods that might be used at

Crime Scene Investigations: Many Crime Scene Investigations
Words: 2150 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Crime Scene Investigations: Many crime scene investigations revolved around safeguarding the crime scenes, protecting physical evidence, and gathering and transferring the evidence for scientific evaluation. This process is based on the role that physical evidence plays in the overall investigation and determination of a suspected criminal activity. Notably, the ability for physical evidence to play its role in the overall investigation process is dependent on actions that are taken early enough

Crime Scene Preservation: Analysis of
Words: 763 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

4-8). While these standard procedure are relevant in the preservation of any crime scene, certain specifications exist when dealing with the unique challenges associated with the different types of crime scenes including homicides, rapes, arson, and nighttime crime scenes. For instance, in the case of homicide, as well as the aforementioned steps, the area must be preserved for trace evidence such as fingerprints. In the case of rapes or sexual

Crime Scene Investigation: A Homicide Crime Has
Words: 954 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Crime Scene Investigation: A homicide crime has just occurred at a convenience gas station that included the presence of an employee, a mother, and her 15-year-old son who were witnesses of the crime. Upon arrival at the crime scene as a crime scene investigator at 3a.m, I found the deceased victim with an obvious gunshot wound in the chest as the first officer informed me of the present witnesses. As a

Crime Scene Analysis Introduction- There
Words: 2629 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

T. Apparantely in good health, need to investigate insurance and other issues, get medical report. Married, one-4-year-old son Appears happily married with young child, no indication of turmoil in marriage; check. Colleagues say victim was "very organized," and kept to himself, did not make friends nor enemies Mr. T. appears to be inoffensive, not prone to situations that would engender violence. Profession: Attorney; normal office hours 8am-5pm; known to work late on cases as necessary Q:

Crime Scene Investigation Is a Field With
Words: 905 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Crime scene investigation is a field with rapidly changing tools that seem to evolve almost every day as a result of the changes made in technology. However, even the simplest elements of a crime scene can still inform investigators an epic amount. For instance, in this case, the position of the body and the weapon used represent the main forms of evidence and can help investigators uncover the elements which motivated

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now