Verified Document

Courts What Is The Dual-Court Term Paper

However, it is unlikely that one system will ever be sacrificed entirely. Also, there are cases when jurisdiction between federal and state overlap, such as "any lawsuit where citizens of different states are involved in disputes concerning at least $50,000, the person being sued can insist on federal court," and "some criminal acts that involve single events or multiple events that violate both federal and state laws simultaneously ("Michigan Court System, the Civics Institute, 2004). This also means that combining the two systems would not be feasible, especially given how the system of laws in America currently exists. Question

Outline the various sentencing goals. Which of these goals do you find most acceptable as the primary goal of sentencing? How might your choice of goal vary with the type of offense? Can you envision any circumstances which might make your choice less acceptable?

Sentencing goals may include providing punishment levels that reflect the seriousness of the offense, affording adequate deterrence to criminal conduct, protecting the public from further crimes of the defendant, and avoiding unwarranted sentence disparities among defendants with similar crimes (Maxfield, 2003, pp.3-4). Ultimately, the most serious result of ignoring one of these guidelines would be a sentence that did not protect the public from further crimes of the defendant. The most obvious scenario might be that of a guilty, violent murderer or rapist who was likely to commit another crime, without long-term incarceration.

For example, regarding the seriousness of the offense, an example of consumer fraud might warrant a harsh penalty, if it was done with a flagrant lack of concern for the public's health and well-being, even if the defendant could not commit the crime again, because he or she no longer had his or her executive job. Deterrence might be the goal in harshly punishing a white-collar, so-called victimless crime like insider trading. And even the final goal, although presumably criminals draw little sympathy when they cry 'unfair' might have merit regarding a petty drug user or a speeding ticket -- it might be considered unjust to 'throw the book' at a criminal for a small crime that usually garners a light sentence. Finally, in some cases different considerations might hold sway, such as in the juvenile courts where rehabilitation rather than retribution might be the primary goal of sentencing and thus warrant different guidelines.
Works Cited

Chapter 10: The American Legal System and the Courts." Chapter Summary from Keeping the Republic. Washington DC: CQ Press. 2007.

The Michigan Court System. The Civics Institute. 2004. 28 Feb 2007. http://www.civicsinstitute.org/curricula/high/The_Michigan_Court_System.html

Maxfield, Linda Drazga. "Final Report: Sentencing." Office of Policy Analysis.

Report of U.S. Sentencing Commission. Mar 2003. 28 Feb 2007. http://www.ussc.gov/judsurv/execsum.pdf

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Chapter 10: The American Legal System and the Courts." Chapter Summary from Keeping the Republic. Washington DC: CQ Press. 2007.

The Michigan Court System. The Civics Institute. 2004. 28 Feb 2007. http://www.civicsinstitute.org/curricula/high/The_Michigan_Court_System.html

Maxfield, Linda Drazga. "Final Report: Sentencing." Office of Policy Analysis.

Report of U.S. Sentencing Commission. Mar 2003. 28 Feb 2007. http://www.ussc.gov/judsurv/execsum.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Court System the Basic Structure of the
Words: 1077 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Court System The basic structure of the United States legal system comes from the Constitution. Constitutions are living documents that lay down principles and rules, as well as overall functions of how law should be used within society. Constitutions tend to be macro in scope, in that they define responsibilities between the three organs of U.S. Government (Judicial, Legislature and Executive). Laws are individual (micro) edicts that are made to define

Court Services Management
Words: 1519 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Court Systems The structure and platform on which the legal system is based upon is very important in understanding the total landscape of how justice is carried out within the confines of the government. The purpose of this essay is to explore the inner workings of both the federal and state court systems and highlight their similarities and differences. Also, this essay will investigate the roles of court administrators in the

Court Analysis Justice and Court Administration and
Words: 1185 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Court Analysis Justice and Court Administration Administration and management of courts is filled with challenges. Often depending upon the geographical context of the court, such challenges will include resource shortage, a perpetual docket of criminal cases and the broader complexity of providing civil order and justice to communities while balancing constitutional law and local ordinance. Moreover, the complexity of administering justice in and of itself plays a part in the difficulty of

Dual Court System in the
Words: 4296 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

S. COURT SYSTEM FUNCTIONS (http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/itdhr/0999/ijde/fine.htm)." The highest tier of this federal system is the United States Supreme Court. This court has nine Supreme Court Justices who are appointed for the term of their life unless they choose to step down. A majority is not needed to win a Supreme Court hearing request. If four of the nine think the case brought before them is worth hearing then the case will be

Nklenske Courts the Dual Court
Words: 1432 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

More people are currently incarcerated than at any other time. In fact, prisons are so over crowded that it is now common practice for judges to simply use deferred sentences and probation as a means of sentencing. Further, the costs of housing so many criminals is one that many states simply cannot afford. As a result, much of the prison industry is being outsourced to private corporations. The net effect of the

Expert Witness in Court Role
Words: 4040 Length: 14 Document Type: Research Proposal

Armstrong was unable to retreat to the safety of her environment to rebuild her mental strength and defenses and to begin to feel safe. Her environment became fearful, because she would wait there for Mr. Payne to return, and when he did, as she had feared, he began violently physically abusing her. Her level of fear and anxiety would have been high at the time Mr. Payne arrived home,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now