Verified Document

Controlled Experiments Are Those In Which Groups Case Study

Controlled experiments are those in which groups are separated into control and experimental. Neither group knows what they are receiving, so they may or may not be receiving a sugar pill or something else. The control group is essential for comparisons -- what happens in the control group often determines how the experimental data is interpreted (Scientific Control Group, 2008). A double blind experiment is one in which some of the participants are prevented from knowing certain information about the study that might lead to bias (conscious or subconscious) thus skewing the results. Blinding can also be imposed on researchers, subjects, funders, or any combination in which one wishes to protect the data integrity. In the use of new drugs, blinded experiments are necessary because a patient might feel better if they think they are receiving a powerful new medicine -- the placebo effect. It is impossible, however, to double blind all studies, for ethical and humanitarian reasons, for instance. Using double blind studies is one of the reasons 20th century science advanced -- observer bias can affect an experiment (Double Blind Experiment, 2008).

Part 1 -- C -- Based on the results of Study A, there seems no scientific reason for Max to take Vitamin C during the winter months. Both the control and experimental groups showed no difference in the disappearance of cold symptoms...

If Max is getting at least 90-100 mg of Vitamin C daily, his daily health, based on this study, is supplemented appropriately. If there are other reasons Max might wish to supplement his diet (e.g. excess stress, poor diet, excess caffeine), then there might be a reason for supplementation. But, if the reason is only to prevent the severity of a cold, and this Study is the basis for his research, then there is no reason for Max to supplement.
Part 2 -- A -- Study 2 was controlled, although perhaps not well controlled. We do not know the variables of the individuals in the study (age, exercise or health level, attitude, gender, etc.). We also do not know whether these individuals are susceptible to colds (liver issues, immune issues, etc.). For the control to be robust, the populations would need to be more alike, and the delineation of the variables of the participants would need to be disclosed; likely 20 individuals would not be a large enough experimental group. Finally, we only know that the subject consumed the same amount of dietary item C. And spent 4 hours in the same room; we do not know what they ate outside of the experiment, what environment they were in, how much rest they received, or how close they were to the individual with the cold. For instance, some might have felt a cold coming on, therefore drank more fluids and rested; this…

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

Double Blind Experiment. (2008). Experiment-Resources.com. Retrieved from:

http://www.experiment-resources.com/double-blind-experiment.html

Scientific Control Group. (2008). Experment-Resources.com. Retrieved from:

http://www.experiment-resources.com/scientific-control-group.html
http://www.rsds.org/pdfsall/Peek_Letter_2010.pdf
http://apjcn.nhri.org.tw/server/info/books-phds/books/foodfacts/html/data/data4i.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Market Is a Controlled Experiment
Words: 624 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This is really a new-old idea. In the past, Johnson and Johnson has experimented different color band aids not only for children, but also for adults. Previously, there have been such band aids made for adults, but only in limited, special editions. Now, a new series of such band aids are being issued in special day glow colors to see if the adults will begin to use more of

Theoretical Approaches to Group Counseling: Group Psychology
Words: 2826 Length: 9 Document Type:

Group Psychology: Theoretical Approaches to Group Counseling Case Vignette 2: Phil, the Japanese-American Phil, a Japanese-American expresses his discomfort and anxiety during the second meeting of his group. A keen listener, he is having difficulty speaking up whenever he is required to, and he is contemplating leaving because he understands that all members are required to participate. Moreover, he fears rejection so he prefers to sit back and watch during the group

Group Therapy: Stages and Process Group Therapy
Words: 1249 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Group Therapy: Stages and Process Group therapy has become a popular method for treating a wide range of addictions, disorders, and grief processes. As Corey and Corey (1997) state: "Groups provide a natural laboratory that demonstrates to people that they are not alone and that there is hope for creating a different life" (p. 5) Other benefits of group therapy include information-sharing, a sense of belonging, catharsis, emotional support, progress through

Group Counseling Attitudes and Perspectives
Words: 5248 Length: 19 Document Type: Research Paper

Group counseling helps to advance self understanding and awareness which may combat repressive tendencies. Teaching coping skills in a group setting can help participants to develop needed tools and stimulate psychological growth (Lambie & Sias, 2009). Participants in group counseling also learn positive interpersonal/social skills that can be generalized beyond the hospital setting and applied in daily living (Shechtman, 2004). Cancer patients learn to adapt to novel social situations and

Canadian Forces, Small Group Military Relationships Within
Words: 3017 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Proposal

Canadian Forces, small group military relationships Within the Canadian Forces, how are small group military relationships on operational deployments in Kabul, Afghanistan? A group is mostly defined to be two or more people interacting together so they can achieve a common specific goal. The main purpose of the group would be towards a shared and desired outcome. With this in mind, Military groupings are formed to achieve a common interest like

True Experiments Vs. Quasi-Experimental Designs What Qualities
Words: 594 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

True" Experiments vs. Quasi-Experimental Designs What qualities of the quasi-experimental design are evident in this study? This study was specifically designed to test the efficacy of a new program designed to improve police responses to cases involving domestic violence. Through the Second Responders Program, trained social workers would follow police after domestic violence-related calls and provide victims with counseling and information about social support services if the victims wished to leave

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now