Verified Document

Contract-Capacity And Legality Tommy Mccartney, Case Study

Some of the contracts which minors can't disaffirm include education loan contracts, insurance (health and life) contracts, armed forces enlistment contracts etc. Further, in some states, if a minor who seems (in terms of appearance) to be of majority age misrepresents his age at the time of entering into a contract with a competent party, such a minor is treated as an individual who has attained the majority age and in such a case, the minor may not be able to disaffirm the contract. In most cases, when a minor enters into a contract whereby he or she is provided with a necessity by a competent party, his or her right to disaffirm such a contract becomes limited. Though the minor may still disaffirm such a contract (technically speaking), he or she still remains liable for a significant value of the consideration. This exception is designed to ensure that minors are still able to access necessities such as food, shelter and clothing when their parents or guardians fail to provide for the same. However, it sometimes becomes difficult for courts to determine whether a specific consideration is a necessity or not. Analysis

Based on the fact that Tommy is a minor, the contract between him and the competent seller is voidable. This effectively means that Tommy has the option of disaffirming any contract to which he is party to until a specified time after he attains the majority age. In this case, Tommy has already demonstrated an intention to disaffirm the contract by handing over the keys of the automobile to the seller and asking for a refund of whet he paid at the time of the purchase. If state laws allow the return of the consideration regardless of its condition without any requirement for restoration, then Tommy is...

However, where the laws of the state dictate that restoration be done if the consideration has lost significant value; Tommy will be entitled to the difference of what he paid for the automobile and the value of the automobile at the time of its return.
It should also be noted that Tommy's disaffirmation rights could be limited based on some technicalities. For instance, should it be established that Tommy misrepresented his age when he was making the purchase; his resolve to seek a refund could hit a snag. However, for this argument to prevail, the seller should prove that at the time of the actual purchase, Tommy's appearance was akin to that of an adult. Again, this is largely dependent on the specific laws of the state.

In my opinion, though the minor's right to disaffirm a contract he is subject to is tailored to protect such a minor from being taken advantage of by an individual of a majority age, it does expose a competent party to unethical minors who could be knowledgeable of their actions. For instance, in this case, the seller of the automobile would be clearly disadvantaged given that the vehicle was returned in a worse condition than it was at the time of purchase. In this case, a fair remedy would be restitution.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis above; while it is legal for Tommy to escape his obligations in regard to the contract, is not ethical for him to escape the same. From a legal perspective, the contract between Tommy and the competent seller is voidable and hence Tommy is entitled to a full refund of the $6,000 paid to the seller at the time of the purchase. However, this is dependent on the specific legal provisions of the state.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Contract Law
Words: 642 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Contract Law In modern society, contracts have become an integral part of determining who is responsible for performing various actions in an agreement. It spells out the terms, conditions and how each party must behave in order for it to be enforceable under the law. To fully understand the way that this is occurring requires carefully examining key issues, the offer / acceptance / consideration, the different points-of-view and ethical issues.

Contract Law
Words: 3399 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Law of Contract Contract law As to concerned definition of law there are many definition among various schools of thought of law such that no particular definition is acceptable to them as universal definition of law, but nevertheless there is a common acceptable definition as to what the law is composed of and that it is a collection of rules and regulations governing human conduct prescribed by human beings for the obedience

Contracts Law
Words: 2081 Length: 8 Document Type: Capstone Project

Contracts Law: Disney World Jurassic Park Amusement Ride The first question at issue in this study has to do with the termination of an employee for poor sales performance who entered into a non-compete agreement with the company, specifically that of Disney. The employee, Simpson agreed that he would not directly or indirectly compete with Disney as an agent, employer, broker, or contractor for one year from the date of termination.

Contracts Law
Words: 1043 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Contracts Law Case Study- Contracts Law There were two offers. There is an offer is a meeting of the minds can be reached by the recipient of the offer accepting the terms of the offer. The first offer was by Galaxy Computer store and consisted of Galaxy placing an ad in the paper for Pentium 4 computers for $3,000. The second offer was by Gabrielle and consisted of her offering a her

Contract Law Lies at the Center of
Words: 2189 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Contract law lies at the center of our legal system and serves as the basis of our whole society. Our society relies on free exchange in the marketplace at every stage. Contract law is what makes this probable. Exchanges in the marketplace always rely on voluntary agreements between people. These voluntary agreements would never if there wasn't contract law. Contract law works to make these agreements enforceable, which typically means

Contract Law / Australia the
Words: 3019 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

However, it must be noted that the doctrine of consideration has changed and therefore seems to have fixed many of its most impractical elements, or at least that is what has been argued. One example of a change is the fact that in regards to consideration, the requirement for a benefit has moved from the requirement to show a legal benefit to simply a practical benefit. Another aspect to the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now