Verified Document

Constitution The Underlying Position Of Term Paper

" (Berns, 28). The assertion that these rights are innate places them before the structuring of society and government, and makes the task for a society built out of these principles to find some way to attain them. This broad perspective sets the stage for Berns' handling of the segments of society that were understood to be unworthy or unwilling to enter into the social contract of the United States. The Tories are the first subset of colonial society that Berns addresses. To him, they occupy a unique place in the discussion of constituting the people of the United States because they categorically opposed the premises of the United States upon philosophical or political grounds. He notes that many were loyalists to the crown simply for personal and economic reasons and others for religious reasons -- like the Quakers -- but the most interesting, to Berns, are those who were dedicated monarchists. They first two subsets of Tories were somewhat assimilated into American society, but he implies that the exile of the third subset was essential to the continuity of the United States. After all, the United Empire Loyalists still exist today -- their beliefs could not be overcome simply through warfare.

The next group that Berns discusses is the American Indians, who have yet to truly attain equality. Once again, he summons John Locke to explain why they were considered undeserving of protection under the natural law; "Of greatest significance is the fact... that men and peoples are not equally civilized, a consideration to be weighed when deciding with whom to contract when constituting a civil society." (Berns, 39). So, because they were perceived to be barbarous peoples, Indians were denied to opportunity to become part of the United States.

Berns has a more difficult time explaining why the American social contract could not be extended to black Americans, but he nonetheless seems...

He quotes Lincoln as having said of slavery that it should be regarded "as an evil not to be extended, but to be tolerated and protected only because of and so far as its actual presence among us makes that toleration and protection necessary." (Berns, 44). Thus, its toleration is to be understood as an act of utility, not a blatant violation of morality.
Finally, Berns ends his debate by mentioning how close the founding fathers of the United States came to putting religious restrictions upon citizenship and office holding. He argues that holding fast to the bases of the Declaration of Independence is what prevented this measure from being adopted.

Overall, Berns puts the acts of exclusion by American society into a philosophical perspective that grows out of the Declaration of Independence. It is a significant argument because it adds a certain amount of continuity to an aspect of history that is, on some levels, fraught with contradictions. However, his explanations seem somewhat superficial in that major political moves can rarely be understood as direct consequences of political philosophy. He is forced to face this fact when he discusses the perpetuation of slavery after the Constitution, and some of the more tangible motivations behind emancipation. Most damning of all is the fact that he fails to attend to the inequities associated with social class. He seems to argue that since many of the loyalist aristocrats were dispatched after the revolution, American society started upon more equal ground than its European counterparts. Even if this is an accurate assessment, it cannot justify the stratified society that took hold in the United States in the face of a philosophy that held fast to universal equality.

Works Cited

Berns, Walter. Taking the Constitution Seriously. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1987.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Berns, Walter. Taking the Constitution Seriously. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1987.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Constitution Provides Depicts What Is Necessary to
Words: 974 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Constitution provides depicts what is necessary to amend the Constitution. Either two-thirds of both Houses of the Congress, or an application by the legislatures of two-thirds of the several States, can call for a convention proposing amendments to the constitution. Ratification requires that the Legislatures of three fourths of the several states or Constitutional conventions in three-fourths of the states approving the ratification of those amendments. Therefore, the Founding

The Consolidation of Power Ratification of the US Constitution
Words: 1570 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Confederation and Constitution The differences between the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution of 1787 were significant. The former entrusted power to the individual states while the latter relinquished the majority of power to the central/federal government. This was evident in the way in which representation was established and legislation enacted. For example, under the Articles, Congress was unicameral -- that is, one house. Under the Constitution, Congress was bicameral, consisting

Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution Governs
Words: 1061 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution governs the issue of double jeopardy and states in pertinent part, "No person… shall… be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb…( )." The Amendment was a codification of the common law that had long recognized the doctrine that a defendant should not be subject to multiple attempts by the state to convict him for

Denominationalism Examine Some of the Underlying Causes
Words: 681 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Denominationalism Examine some of the underlying causes of denominationalism in the U.S., including ethnicity, social class, and regional factors. Denominationalism is the process by which human beings have separated themselves while still under the umbrella of a common religion. Throughout the world, there are a plethora of denominations of Christianity including Catholicism, Baptism, Methodism, Lutheranism, and a host of other groups all of whom consider themselves to be following the true Christianity.

Constitutional Originalism
Words: 1059 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Constitutional Originalism A living constitution is a concept that is found in the United States, it is also referred to as loose constitution. This is because it is a constitutional interpretation that the constitution is dynamic in meaning. It claims that the constitution has human properties since it constantly changes .I hold a strong opinion for the constitution to be interpreted as a living constitution due to several reasons. The idea

American Civics the American Population
Words: 4097 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

The proposal must first be promoted to a sympathetic Representative in the House who has sufficient power and support in Congress. This representative will introduce the bill while the House is in Session. The bill will then be assigned a number at referred to a standing committee, which studies the merits and deficiencies of the bill. Witnesses and experts will then be allowed to present their case for or against

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now