Verified Document

Consent Embodies The Idea That As A Essay

¶ … consent embodies the idea that as a matter of ethics and law patients are entitled to be exposed to all of the relevant information that would influence and guide their decision making concerning what treatment that they should follow. However, should clinicians provide medical information to terminally ill patients when they suspect that such information could potentially be used to facilitate their suicide? The issues surrounding full disclosure, beneficence, and therapeutic privilege as they relate to patients and their families are discussed and recommendations regarding how such cases should be conceptualized are discussed. Should clinicians provide medical information to terminally ill patients when they know or suspect that such information will be used to facilitate their suicide? This dilemma affects patients, their families, physicians, other medical professionals. The notion of "informed consent" as a guiding principle in medicine is at the center of modern professional medical ethics. Informed consent embodies the idea that as a matter of proper ethics and law patients are entitled to be exposed to all of the relevant information that would influence and guide their decision making concerning what treatment, if any, they should follow. If a patient does not have the capacity to make medical decisions themselves then a substitute decision-maker (previously assigned by the patient or by the court) should be provided with such information. Even though the ideals of full disclosure and informed consent are often referred as fundamental directives in many other professional fields, the notions of full disclosure and informed consent evolved within the context of American medicine. These directives have traditionally been emphasized as the result of a moral concern with the basic human and...

There is a long history of this basic right being upheld in the court system and therefore as a matter of both proper ethical behavior and law physicians have a duty to disclose information about the patient's diagnoses, prognosis, and the risks and benefits of any proposed treatments (Paterick, Carson, Allen, & Paterick, 2008). When these disclosures are made the ethical principle of "beneficence" should be applied. Beneficence states that physicians should reveal information in a manner that is beneficial and not harmful to patients (Shatz, 1986).
The ethical principle of beneficence has led to the notion of therapeutic privilege, an exception to the need to provide full disclosure. Therapeutic privilege allows a physician to withhold information from a patient or surrogate decision maker out of the concern that full disclosure could either be psychologically harmful to the patient and thus jeopardize the patient's physical health or when a full explanation of a procedure might lead to the patient to forego a treatment or operation that the physician believes is in the patient's best interest or is the sole option. In addition, family members will occasionally ask physicians to withhold information from patients. Such requests from family members are most often performed out of feelings of wanting to protect the patient as the family may believe that full disclosure will be more harmful than beneficial.

These types of requests can often be difficult to honor because hiding a diagnosis from a patient can be difficult especially if treatment is needed because patients can figure out that they are seriously ill by the type of treatment they are exposed to. In any event, in order to withhold information from patients there must be a justifiable…

Sources used in this document:
References

Monagle, J.F. (1998). Health care ethics: Critical issues for the 21st century. Gaithersburg, MD: Aspen Publications.

Paterick, T.J., Carson, G.V., Allen, M.C., & Paterick, T.E. (2008). Medical informed consent: General considerations for physicians. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 83(3), 313-319.

Russell, B.J. & Ward, A.M. (2011). Deciding what information is necessary: Do patients with advanced cancer want to know all the details? Cancer Management and Research, 23, 191-199

Shatz, D. (1986). Autonomy, beneficence and informed consent: Rethinking the connections. I. Cancer Investigation, 4, 257-269.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

American Identity the Idea of
Words: 1287 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Many other languages are indeed spoken in America, making language less of a required element in a definition than some might like. The widespread use of Spanish in the southwest is usually cited as a problem, but Chinese is common in large cities like Los Angeles, San Francisco, and New York, and waves of immigrants form different parts of the world add to the number who speak a second

Servant Leadership Does Service-Learning Experience
Words: 8247 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Proposal

Conceptually, many agree as to what constitutes a servant leader, although many variations of these characteristics can be found in the literature. The terms "servant" and "leader" may seem contradictory, which is one of the greatest barriers to operationalizing the concept of the servant leader in modern organizations. The following will examine key literature regarding the ability to operationalize the concept of the servant leader. What Distinguishes the Servant Leader? The

Gender and the Fashion Industry:
Words: 1943 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Also, all women must be pressed to ask why they seek to embody the female ideal of beauty, and are willing to sacrifice so much to do so. Even if the fashion industry were to ban all models wholesale beneath a BMI of 18.5, while male chauvinists might delight in the curves of the models gyrating on the catwalks of Milan, the ideals held up for women to fulfill

Criminal Procedure
Words: 3499 Length: 12 Document Type: Questionnaire

Crime Control/Procedures The term "play in the joints" refers to flexibility within the law that allows for a certain amount of discretion to occur within the prosecution and judge. Even though there is discretion within the manner in which the Judge may interpret sentencing, procedure and rulings, there are still formal rules of law that provide for a basis for upholding the Constitution. In a given situation, for example, the Judge

Ethical Standards in Research Has
Words: 3506 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Moreover, the researcher who falsifies the data is prone to legal action as has been the case in the past when researchers have falsified research results (Normile C, 2006). Therefore, in order to deal with this grave issue, it is important to ensure that the data being incorporated in the research paper has been properly handled and it is being reported correct. Ensuring this would satisfy the ethical standards

Civic Project Entry 1: Selection
Words: 3117 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

A try to help my Little Brother find positive voluntary associations. I encourage him to volunteer at his local church, and to seek afterschool enrichment programs and tutoring. But this is not always easy. He often says that he feels that people do not care -- his teachers, his parents, and even his friends who try to uphold a 'straight and narrow' path. He also says that he wants to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now