Verified Document

Consensual Agreements For Cra: In Reviewing The Case Study

Consensual Agreements FOR CRA: In reviewing the current literature on the issue about sexual intimacy on the job, one might wonder why people bother to go anywhere else for fun. It has become clear that sexuality and romance are significant in many contemporary workplaces, which means that businesses of all types have to begin to bring a discussion and specific responses to this issue home. More employees work either online or in businesses that depend on online activity. As such, few employees are far away from resources that involved open and frank discussions or that outright promote or advertise sexuality and romance.

In a future job I expect to work in a company that is connected to and encourages business innovation on the Internet. I would love to work with a Facebook or Twitter-type company where I could work with creative people and new technologies. A place like this will want to find employees who have special skills, and to get those people to come to their company they will have to allow them to be who they are. This would set up a work environment were having an appropriate, organizationally sensible Love Contract (or CRA) would make sense as companies deal with their employees or seek new employees who fit in to their environment (Pierce, et al., 2011:2). Under these circumstances, there is evidence that suggests a CRA will help ensure a sense of fairness and respect in the workplace. It will also be a vehicle for helping to put the ground rules of honesty on the table so everyone can see and experience what they mean in practice and take the issue out of the realm of legal challenges alone (Pierce et al., 2009). Most people who are technological wizards are familiar with and take User Agreements seriously. A CRA can be seen in the same way, except that it will spell out both the general rules of openness and respect as well as enable individuals who are involved in romantic or sexual relationships to be honest with what is happening. If the rules are spelled out first in this way and taken as part of the company's human resource activities, it may be harder for this to cause problems for the company or for the individuals involved. It does appear that proactive legal agreements do have a positive impact on protecting companies from harm (Lickey et al., 2009:101.)

Studies on organizational issues for the creative sector suggest that attracting and keeping good employees requires that the organization itself reflect the kinds of values it expects (Freeman and Stewart, 2006). This is particularly important in workplaces where teamwork and even distance working occurs, and perhaps even where employees make use of online chat sites to learn more about their products. While no one likes unfair or restrictive policies, the evidence suggests that if there are going to be policies about sexual and romantic issues, they should be fair and just (Pierce et al., 2011). This will make the workplace appear more fun and welcoming, and that will make the work better. I expect to work in such a setting and thus believe that having a User Agreement for Love Contracts makes sense and will help protect the company from many other discrimination or harassment problems. Contracts of this type are proactive and open for all to be aware of before problems develop (Lickey et al., 2009: 107). If this occurs, the employees are less likely to be concerned as well that their private elements of work will become an issue if love or romance happens.

AGAINST CRA: Society is becoming more openly sexual and romantic and so is the workplace. There is no getting around that. The use of and access to online dating or sex websites is one indication of this, but in many ways this just reflects how people are willing to have frank discussions in public online forums. Because of this, there is good reason to believe that the kinds of people that I expect to work with in a future technology job will be comfortable with these kinds of resources and will expect to be able to use them in their work. This should mean that they too will be more open and honest about even the most intimate elements of the work environment, including that dating and sexuality that happens. Because of this naturally occurring openness and honesty, I do not believe that a CRA is a good option. Instead, what is needed is the development of a fair and just environment using other practices that can be more easily seen and more often discussed...

There is a good deal of information that suggest that romantic interactions alone are not the problem at work; instead, the problem comes when there is an unhealthy and even humiliating work environment that allows power and authority and even secrecy to hide abuse (Fisk, 2001). A CRA may feel open to some but too much of the time it can just cover up other more serious challenges.
There are a number of indicators that suggest how CRA's may fail to adequately address all problems of romance in the workplace (Jessen, 2005). They can be seen as intimidating and invasive to new employees, which means some people will not use them. It is also much concern that statements of the kind that discuss relationships will be used against certain employees more than others (unmarried more than married). Most Love Contracts are used to control relationships between employees of different levels of authority, and thus they are perceived as being biased in favor of higher-level administrators or special types of employees. This sense of unfairness does nothing to suggest that the company cares about all of its employees in an equal way (Lickey et al., 2009). The job place world be better if social, racial, gender and other types of injustice were dealt with across all parts of the business, even in small ways. In this way the topic will not be hidden in legal or other arrangements. Studies that show that even organizationally sensitive policies have to be either so lenient or so vague that they serve little usefulness as an agreement (Pierce et al., 2009). It would be better to have a stronger company environment that simply values fairness and justice at all levels (Freeman and Stewart, 2006).

CRA ETHICS: Sexuality and romance are morally intense issues (Jessen, 2005:3). This means that employees and employers will give a good deal of consideration to their importance as elements of the work structure, not just as topics of the underlying issues. Ethical issues are of the same nature. And there is plenty of evidence that suggests that for companies to be healthy ethically they have to have a strong and pervasive set of operational and management values.

Sexuality and romance offer many opportunities for companies to make ethical mistakes. Companies are fearful of having open discussions about them, and very concerned about bringing the issue up for fear of employees thinking the company is suggesting something negative about them (Lickey, et al., 2009). There is also the issue of the fact that sexuality and romance are not always dealt with across all levels of authority. Most policies focus on single individuals, and most focus on relationships between lower- and higher-level staff. This ignores many other types of relationships between the people who work closely together, and it hides the kind of activities that are often seen as most inappropriate -- relationships between or involving a married employee. It is also very much the case that these most secretive of activities will be the ones that could lead to unfair benefits to one employee based on that relationship instead of based on merit. Unfair pay, unfair opportunities, unfair impact on business or product opportunities can hurt a company's reputation and set it up for major legal and reputational concerns. An ethical business assumes a stronger set of values in a company, including values that top management not only endorses but also practice and make clear (Freeman and Stewart, 2006). Any types of understandings about consensual sexuality or romance have to account for this if they are going to be effective and protect the company.

CONNECTIVITY AGREEMENTS: People in workplaces use new technologies to their advantages. They also use and sometimes abuse interpersonal relationships for work advantage. As such, why should the issue of how we connect with each other in face-to-face or through Internet connectivity be seen so differently? If a company created a set of policies or rights governing how people can connect with others during work hours -- in fair and respectful ways -- the issues relating to sexuality and romance could be discussed at the same time. A Connectivity User Agreement could not only include these topics but could do so in ways that make it evident that the company recognizes how these issues interact and give all employees the chance to…

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

Fisk, C.L. (2001). Humiliation at Work, 8 Wm. & Mary J. Women & L. 73. Viewable at http://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmjowl/vol8/iss1/3.

Freeman, R.E. And Stewart, L. (2006). Developing ethical leadership. Business Roundtable: Institute for Corporate Ethics. Viewable at http://www.corporate-ethics.org/pdf/ethical_leadership.pdf.

Jessen, P. (2005). Ethical Decision Making About Sexual Harassment Complaints that stem from dissolved workplace romances: A policy-capturing approach. Thesis: Montana State University. Viewable at http://etd.lib.montana.edu/etd/2005/jessen/JessenP0505.pdf.

Lickey, N.C., Berry, G.R., and Whelan-Berry, K.S. (2009). Responding to workplace romance: A proactive and pragmatic approach. The Journal of Business Inquiry, p100-119. Viewable at http://www.uvu.edu/woodbury/jbi/volume8/journals/RespondingtoWorkplaceRomance.pdf.
Pierce, C.A., & Aguinis, H. (2009). Moving beyond a legal-centric approach to managing workplace romances: Organizationally sensible recommendations for HR leaders. Human Resource Management, 48 (3), 447-464. Viewable at http://memphis.academia.edu/ChuckPierce/Papers/295971/Pierce_C._A._and_Aguinis_H._2009_._Moving_beyond_a_legal-centric_approach_to_managing_workplace_romances_Organizationally_sensible_recommendations_for_HR_leaders._Human_Resource_Management_48_447-464.
Pierce, C.A., Karl, K.A., and Brey, E.T. (2011). Role of workplace romance policies and procedures on job pursuit. In press draft. Journal of Managerial Psychology. Downloadable at http://umwa.memphis.edu/fcv/viewprofile.php?uuid=capierce.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Online Dating the Internet Provides Society With
Words: 648 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Online Dating The internet provides society with a wide selection of things to do, people to communicate with and items to purchase. It is important to pause occasionally and examine how this invention has both helped and hindered people since its use became so widespread. The purpose of this essay is to examine how this online platform affects the practice of dating. This essay will argue that the dating rituals of

Online Dating Services Offer Access
Words: 1482 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

"Idealists" need a unique identity to be fulfilled and, therefore, value authenticity. They are often skilled in interpretation and tend to be impressionistic. Finally, "Rationals" need mastery and self-control to be satisfied and value logical consistency. They are skilled in analyzing situations but they are often oblivious to the world around them. These characteristics can be used to model how people with certain temperaments will respond to potential online dating

Online Dating: Socializing for the
Words: 1763 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Furthermore, online dating appears to offer users a passive means of obtaining feedback and improving their own behavior including adding new interests and correcting the perceptions of others. Overall, it can be concluded that online dating will continue to be a prominent source for those seeking relationships. Baker, a. (2002). What makes an online relationship successful? Clues from couples who met in cyberspace. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 5 (4), 363-375. CBC News.

Online Dating Vs. Traditional Dating
Words: 2257 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

In that regard, there is nothing sinister or unusual in the way the online dating platform is structured. Online dating does indeed have its own pitfalls. As a matter of fact, no approach to dating can be regarded absolutely safe or trouble free. Traditional dating also has its own unique challenges (Paludi, 2012). However, based on the arguments presented in this text, the benefits online dating presents cannot be overstated.

Online Dating Collecting There Are
Words: 6545 Length: 20 Document Type: Thesis

This is very common for college age people because some do not realize on how to self-disclose to a romantic relationship, therefore, they seek relationship satisfaction elsewhere (Aviram, I., and Amichai-Hamburger 2005). Taking into consideration the self-disclosure that an Internet relationship permits, we expected that an Internet affair would be especially appealing to individuals who feel that their "real life" relationship does not allow them enough self-disclosure. Since self-disclosure has

Online Dating and Identity
Words: 7046 Length: 23 Document Type: Research Paper

Online Dating Scams and Its Role in Identity Theft ONLINE DATING SCAMS AND IDENTITY THEFT The increased use of the Internet in modern communications has contributed to the emergence of cyberspace, which has become an alternative medium for developing and experiencing new relationships. The cyberspace is currently used for various purposes including communication and for developing creative romantic endeavors with less spatio-temporal restrictions. While online love platforms have proliferated and blossomed in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now