Verified Document

Confucius In Traditional Western Culture, Term Paper

Confucius

In traditional Western culture, especially in its Puritan and Kantian form, duty was usually contrasted with pleasure-- the highest moral ideal was to be able to do one's duty despite deriving no sense of pleasure from this. For Confucians, the highest ideal was to so integrate moral goodness into one's personality that one would find pleasure in being good."

People in the Western world often judge an action not on its actual merit or on its results, but rather, on how much suffering the person was willing to undergo. This is true somewhat in other cultures, such as Confucian societies, but as the author shows, Western notions of duty, pleasure, and goodness conflict with Confucian notions of duty, pleasure, and goodness in that "the Confucian ideal is the thorough integration of goodness into one's personality, so that one would spontaneously want to do what is right, without a sense of having to force oneself to do it by will power.

In many non-Confucian, especially Christian cultures, people feel obliged to do good deeds. For example, people need to be motivated by guilt in order to help someone in need, or motivated by the law. According to Confucianism, on the other hand, the desire to help others in need can and should arise naturally. The desire to help others therefore becomes a pleasurable activity, not a chore.

Part of the reason for the difference in approach to duty and goodness among these different societies is that Christian mythology is based on martyrdom. Jesus Christ died; he made the ultimate sacrifice of his life in order to help other people. Because Confucian society is based more on personal responsibility for moral action rather than on faith, it makes sense that for the Confucian, good deeds come from within, not from external motivation. Christians are often motivated by a fear of God or of retribution; they are taught that they will "go to Hell" if they do this or don't do that. Confucians, who are not taught this concept of morality, view goodness as something positive to be cultivated, and consequently view pleasure not as a negative but as a positive aspect of human existence.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

New Culture May 4th Movements. Why Considered
Words: 995 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

New Culture May 4th movements. Why considered important modern Chinese history? 2. What Han synthesis? Who principle figure process elements bring create ? 3. As suggested by the terminology, the New Culture movement refers to the attempt to rise against traditional Chinese culture. The movement was initiated by various Chinese intellectual circles around 1916 and was related to the perception that Confucian tradition contributed to the country's stagnation and national

Humanities in Western Civilization the
Words: 3242 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

In some cultures, however, dance is also used for spiritual purposes. The art of creating dances is known as choreography. Outside of the performing arts, one of the most important features of the humanities is philosophy. Philosophy is derived from an ancient Greek term that means "the love of wisdom." Philosophy studies life, the nature of existence, and what it means to use one's reason. Philosophy is one of the

East, Culture, History Beijing, Previously
Words: 1777 Length: 5 Document Type: A2 Coursework

One of those buildings was the International Foreign Trade Center -- Shenzhen's first skyscraper and the tallest building in China (36). Hong Kong is commonly referred to as a place where "East meets West" because of its hybrid nature. That is, there is a culture mix occurring that is part traditional Chinese as well part British due to its colonization by the British. Hong Kong is quite a modern place,

Gender Roles in Traditional East Asia
Words: 2267 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Confucianism is one of the major factors that influenced gender views and perception in traditional East Asia, particularly in relation to the treatment of women in these societies. Confucianism is primarily a teaching that was brought by Confucius, a philosopher, political figure, and educator. The teachings of Confucius formed the foundation of education in the traditional societies in East Asia, especially in China, Korea, and Japan. Confucius teachings affected many

Confucianism in East Asian Cultures
Words: 2254 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Confucianism in East Asian Cultures Confucianism is often characterized as a system that involves social and ethical philosophy as opposed to being purely a religion in the traditional definition of religion. As a matter of fact Confucianism is based on ancient religious foundations for the establishment of institutions, social values, and transcendent ideas of traditional societies. The paper is a critique of Confucian legacies in East Asian modernities, knowledge as well

Cultural Cues of Eastern and Western Schools in Today's World
Words: 1756 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Education in the East and West The difference between education in the East and the West is primarily a difference in culture. Today, cultural differences are less pronounced than they were a century ago. Globalized society has seen cultures meld and melt into one another, so that in many senses the East resembles the West in more ways than one (Igarashi). However, deeply rooted cultural cues still represent a fundamental

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now