Qantas and Geoff Dixon attempt to avoid Alinta's problems by keeping Dixon away from the actual buyout dealings. However, the sizeable payout and other financial perks given to Dixon, especially in light of the other corporate abuses going on, seems suspect at best. Overall, the Takeover Panel's suggestion that individuals who are involved in the buyout of their employing company should step down seems the most solid advice in avoiding conflict of interest.
IV. The Takeover Panel and Conflict of Interest
In their Guidance notes, the Takeovers Panel attempts to alleviate or prevent negative outcomes, citing that private equity bids and other buyouts can have major effects. Many of the items outlined by the Takeovers Panel have specific applications in the deals and issues related to Qantas, Alinta, and Macquaries bank.
The Panel cites that its major concerns are to ensure that buyout bids are considered in an unbiased manner, without the influence of participating insiders to move forward with one bid or another. The Panel also lists that companies should ensure that any disclosure of information to buyout bidders is appropriately controlled.
In the case of Alinta, the MBO involving Browning and Poynton was subject to influence by the two men, who kept their positions within the company. Macquaries Bank similarly used its inside influence to make bids for buyout that took advantage of their position. It is unlikely that other bids were provided with the information furnished by the inside parties, causing an unfair advantage for those involved in the Alinta MBO buyout.
The Takeovers Panel additionally suggests ways to address potential conflicts of interest, with few of the suggestions being incorporated into the buyouts in question. The Panel's suggestion to inform the board as soon as participants are approached by a potential bidder may have made it possible to avoid problems in the case of Macquaries, Browning and Poynton. Poynton and Browning in fact went against the board's intentions by seeking out Macquaries' help rather than seeking out board consent before taking action, as the Panel suggests. Overall, the Takeovers Panel outlines a number of cautionary suggestions that could have helped the three companies discussed here to avoid the conflicts that arose from their buyouts.
V. Summary
The cases of Qantas, Alinta, and Macquaries Bank are high profile cases -- they involve large sums of money and the participation of numerous other workers and investors. It appears that poor decision-making on the part of individuals and entire institutions resulted in the abuse of the power and duties entrusted to those participants. If this sort of poor decision-making can happen even in the closely-watched large-scale businesses mentioned here, it can certainly also happen at other levels of business and investment. Where it is happening, loss of confidence and loss of business threatens the markets, individual businesses, and individuals.
To mitigate this risk, businesses can adopt the rigorous guidelines suggested by the Takeovers Panel. In particular, companies involved in a buyout or possible buyout should appoint an IBC to manage the protocols and processes involved. Beyond these internal checks, the most effective way to regulate these issues is sadly through the self-management of the market. By allowing the market to self-regulate some individuals may be taking larger risks; however, investing and other finance procedure is never without risk. In the process of self-regulation, institutions and individuals like Browning and Macquaries Bank will be passed up for others who have maintained a reputation of trustworthiness and avoidance of conflict in interests.
Works Cited
Davis, Mark, and Scott Rochfort. "Revealed: Millions for Qantas Chiefs." SMH.com, Business: Feb. 21, 2007. Available: " http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2007/02/20/1171733762447.html
Evans, Michael, and Stuart Washington. "Conduct Unbecoming." SMH.com, Business: Jan. 20, 2007. Available:
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2007/01/19/1169095975162.html.
Gray, Joanne. "Conflicted Chiefs Push the Envelope." Australian Financial Review, Jan. 13, 2007: 11.
Macquarie. "Fact Sheet - Macquarie Bank and Alinta." Available:...
Ethical ChallengesTable of ContentsIntroduction: Impact of accounting on corporate performance 1Ethical Challenges Faced to Maintain Cost Accounting 1Ethical Issue in Cost Accounting 1What are the Factors that Influence Ethical Behavior in Cost Accounting? 2Conflicting Interest and Corporate Influence to Maintain Performance Measures 2How Does Self-Motivate Interest Lead to Unethical Decisions? 2Direct and Indirect Conflict of Influence by Corporations? 2Conflicting Interest and Corporate Influence 3Impacts of Budgeting and Financial Reporting Misinformation
Conflict Policy Conflict of Interest Statement The Hangout is committed to high standards to prepare young adults from economically disadvantaged areas with education and skills necessary to achieve success and enrichment in life. It is essential that members and the general public uphold this commitment with the highest quality of confidence. Even the smallest appearance of a conflict of interest, or a potential conflict of interest, should be avoided. In order to
Financial Derivatives This study emphasized the importance roles of financial derivatives, which has been known for the last decade and its effects on the Global financial crisis. It further analyzes the impact of financial derivatives and how it can be controlled to prevent corporations from incurring a lot of risks. It also explains the existence of financial derivatives since 1970, to the recent Global Financial Crisis which occurred in the 2006. Risk
Financial Scandals and Management Financial Management Management Financial Actions, Controls, and Decisions Financial Scandals and Management Following the rise of financial scandals in the recent past, external and internal audits are carried out to review the management's financial controls and actions, and keep tab of the outside and internal auditors. However, despite the best efforts, accounting scandals like the Cendant Corporation's $300 million bogus revenue indicate that external auditors and managers are not doing
Conflict and Conflict Resolution Conflict & Conflict Resolution A theoretical perspective Discussion of Various Theories Rational Choice Theory Charles Tilly's from Mobilization to Revolution Durkheim's Concept of Anomie Relative Deprivation Theory Suicide Bombing in the Light of Rational Choice Theory & Tilly' Collective Action Palestine-Israel Conflict & Relative deprivation theory Burton's Version of Conflict Management Tilly's Conflict with Relative Deprivation Theory Discussion of Various Theories Rational Choice Theory Economics is one of the governing fields when it comes to social sciences. It presents an
Conflict and adversity is an inevitable part of all of our lives. Yet, many people have different reactions to the conflict they face in their own individual scenarios. For a lucky few, conflict can serve as a point of resistance where the individual can rise above adversity and embrace a strong sense of inner pride and strength as seen in Mia Angelou's poem "Still I Rise"; however, there are other
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now