Verified Document

Conflict Management Collective Security's Affect Essay

For instance, Hamilton recalls two examples of democracies rising from authoritarian governments that are often used to justify the United States' current occupation of Iraq -- Japan and Germany. Hamilton argues that the "accomplishments of Japan and Germany depended in part upon the framework of 'collective security' that guided American foreign policy from World War II through the Cold War" (para. 2). The collective security arrangements that Hamilton credits, in part, with the success of Japanese and German democracy are NATO, the UN, the World Bank, the IMF, and the WTO (para. 2). Although they aided Japan and German's journey to democracy, these organizations are not simply a means by which the United States attempts to perpetuate imperialism. Instead, these organizations often fail to achieve results because of sovereignty. Member nations refuse to ratify treaties and support actions, and their sovereign power allows them to do so. On the other hand, these collective security agreements impose on the sovereignty of member states by persuading them to view interests in a collective manner. In this regard, however, collective security may be more likely to fail because of exertions of sovereignty, but sovereignty is not generally compromised, as passing binding resolutions is often hindered by a state's ability to exert its sovereignty. Still, these organizations often prove somewhat successful, as Hamilton argues. For instance, they supported Japan and Germany's rise to democratic powers. Thus, collective security organizations are marked by success and failure. The failure of collective security institutions is often rendered by the exertion of sovereignty on the part of member states. While member states do feel pressured to change sovereign decisions in these organizations, however, they are not prevented from exerting these sovereign decisions, obviously. Thus, though they are not always successful, collective security agreements, with their respect for state sovereignty, do often succeed in part. Hamilton's example of Germany and Japan's eventual turn to democracy can be viewed as a case study. Collective Security and State Sovereignty in the Future

Thus, as organizations that do not undermine state sovereignty, will collective security agreements continue to...

Hamilton addresses this point when he remarks that "new partnerships and coalitions must be forged to combat common threats like drug production, terrorism, and weapons proliferation" (para. 4). To do this, collective security agreements will begin to form among not only states, but also among intergovernmental organizations, like political organizations, multinational corporations, and possibly even terrorist groups. When this occurs, questions will be raised for state sovereignty on a much greater level. Will this put these other organizations at the same level of importance as states? Will states begin to loose sovereignty to intergovernmental organizations? Will collective security agreements lead to the reorganization of the world as we know it? Will these new order collective security agreements work? These questions can only be answered in time, but the history of collective security agreements allows for informed opinions to be made.
Conclusion

Collective security agreements have occurred throughout the history of international relations, but the modern era of multinational conflict management through collective security began shortly after the First World War. Collective security agreements have had a mixed review of success and failure. When they fail, member states' exertion of sovereignty is often to blame. On the contrary, collective security agreements often pressure member states into changing their positions, but do not remove their ability to make sovereign decisions. Thus, collective security agreements today to not encroach upon state sovereignty, though the future, with its new order coalitions, may prove more complicated.

Works Cited

Hamilton, Lee H. "21st Century Collective Security." Woodrow Wilson's International

Center for Scholars. 2009. 6 March 2009. http://www.wilsoncenter.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=news.item&news_=13959

League of Nations: Background." History Learning Site. 2000-2008. 6 March 2009. http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/leagueofnations.htm

Stromberg, Roland N. "Collective Security." Encyclopedia of American Foreign Policy.

2008. 6 March 2009. http://www.americanforeignrelations.com/a-D/Collective-Security.html

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Hamilton, Lee H. "21st Century Collective Security." Woodrow Wilson's International

Center for Scholars. 2009. 6 March 2009. http://www.wilsoncenter.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=news.item&news_=13959

League of Nations: Background." History Learning Site. 2000-2008. 6 March 2009. http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/leagueofnations.htm

Stromberg, Roland N. "Collective Security." Encyclopedia of American Foreign Policy.
2008. 6 March 2009. http://www.americanforeignrelations.com/a-D/Collective-Security.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Collective Bargaining Agreements Refer to a Document
Words: 1182 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Collective bargaining agreements refer to a document of agreement signed between the management of a firm and its employees prepared by representative labor union that specifies terms of employment such as duration, wages, work conditions etc. In nursing profession, CBA are not something new and while some may oppose it, most still believe that these agreements are for the benefit of nurses and hence must be signed as they offer

Managing Organizational Culture
Words: 9860 Length: 34 Document Type: Dissertation

Human Resources Managing Organisational Culture The values and behaviors that contribute to the unique social and psychological environment of an organization make up the organizations culture. Organizational culture is the summation total of an organization's past and current suppositions, incidents, viewpoint, and values that hold it together, and is articulated in its self-image, inner workings, connections with the outside world, and future prospects. In dealing with the management of organisational culture, it is

Security Issues of Online Communities
Words: 15576 Length: 60 Document Type: Term Paper

This researcher rejects the existence of online communities because computer mediated group discussions cannot possibly meet this definition. Weinreich's view is that anyone with even a basic knowledge of sociology understands that information exchange in no way constitutes a community. For a cyber-place with an associated computer mediated group to be labeled as a virtual settlement it is necessary for it to meet a minimum set of conditions. These are:

Human Security in Asia
Words: 3327 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Threats to security are seen to come not only from external military aggression but also from a myriad of internal challenges -- separatist movements, social unrest, or the collapse of the political system." -- Anwar 2003, With the international attention given to "military aggression," especially external military aggression, in recent years, it is easy to allow one's idea of was security means to become clouded with Hobbesian and Machiavellian notions

The Background and Future of the Arab Israeli Conflict
Words: 6146 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

History and Development of International Conflict Management: Israel-Arab ConflictToday, the 22 member-states of the Arab League are scattered across the Middle East and North Africa where the lands have long been the source of conflict. Indeed, since antiquity, the lands that are currently occupied by Arab nations have been the fountainhead from which humankind emerged, as well as the source of relentless wars between the Arab and Israeli peoples based

Collective Bargaining
Words: 1514 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Labor Relations Collective Bargaining in Labor Relations -- an Overview of Chapters 5-8 of Labor Relations, by Arthur a. Sloane & Fred Witney In an effective relationship of labor relations and management, the entities representing labor and management must not view one another simply as adversaries, but as potentially complementary parties in the pursuit of a general, common goal of agreement. This does not mean that representatives of labor and management cannot

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now