Verified Document

Concept Of Power Dissertation Or Thesis Complete

Power Stone presents a model of power that identifies nonofficial and invisible types of power that are more important than visible electoral clout. Social capital, cultural capital, and economic capital are within the province of this invisible type of power. Specifically, Stone identifies several types of unofficial and invisible power including potential power, nondecision making, and anticipated reactions. Nondecision making is defined as "the capacity of elite groups to restrict the scope of community decision making," effectively "not making" decisions while effectively making decisions that are of great importance to the disenfranchised community and the individuals that comprise it. Stone also refers to contextual forces that impact the manifestation and usefulness of power, and conceptualizes "systemic power," which is defined as "the impact of the larger socioeconomic system on the predispositions of public officials," (979). Lukes presents his argument about power from the perspective of the oppressed. His research question is related more to how persons in positions of power secure and ensure the compliance of the subjugated. Lukes also introduces an individual-level aspect to subjugation, which is the alteration of personal and community identity that accepts the projection of inferiority, thereby facilitating the oppressor. Both Lukes and Stone present useful models of conceptualizing power in society, and these two approaches are not mutually exclusive.

Both agree that power is not the exercise of power but the potential of having and wielding power. In this sense, the two essays present similar conceptualizations of power as having an invisible or nonofficial component. Power is linked to cultural capital, in the sense that the dominant culture controls discourse and normative worldviews. The dominant culture also controls social codes and issues like gender norms. These nonofficial or tacit types of...

Stone calls this "systemic power," and Lukes addresses the same issue but with different language and terminology. Lukes uses the term hegemony more frequently, but both authors refer to precisely the same types of systemic power.
Power is most simplistically defined as power or dominion over something, but both Stone and Lukes acknowledge other types of meaningful power including cultural and social power. Neither Stone nor Lukes needs to spend much time on economic power, since economic power is inextricably linked with political power. However, it is implied that economic power does confer both legitimate and invisible types of power. Stone does directly mention the connection between those who possess economic clout and the disproportionate amount of power conferred upon them. Marxist ideology would frame the same argument in terms of the owners of the means of production possessing more than just the factories but also the power over the workers, the power to control the labor market, and therefore ultimately the power to control economic conditions prevalent in the society.

Stone and Lukes acknowledge the role of power as the possession of the means by which to subjugate, and to dominate political and economic spheres of influence. Both refer to nonofficial sources of power vis a vis cultural hegemony and patriarchy, even without having to mention patriarchy per se. Yet Lukes does point out the role of power in unbalanced social hierarchies and does mention Ibsen's A Doll's House to substantiate his claims. Both Stone and Lukes effectively distance power from things like electoral potency or even the possession of weapons. If power cannot be located in official positions only, then it becomes crucial to locate power elsewhere.

It is also critical to locate both causes and…

Sources used in this document:
References

Arendt, Hannah. "Communicative Power."

Lukes, Steven. "Three-Dimensional Power." In Power: A Radical View.

Stone, Clarence M. "Systemic Power in Community Decision Making: A Restatement of Stratification Theory."
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Powers and Rights of the Constitution Institutional
Words: 3017 Length: 10 Document Type: Assessment

Powers and Rights of the Constitution INSTITUTIONAL POWER: The Constitution gives the federal government the right to form a military service, including what is now the National Guard (Army National Guard, 2011), though it does so in cooperation with the states and localities to serve their interests as well. This section is important for a number of reasons, including the fact that it reinforces the differences between the state and

Power Elite Then and Now a Half-Century
Words: 844 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Power Elite Then and Now A half-century after it was written, C. Wright Mills's The Power Elite remains relevant to American society. Mills's analysis of the ways in which powerful people in different sectors of society share economic interests and so share concepts and access to power remains true of the United States now. We can see many of the same dynamics at work in this election year, for while some of

Power, Conflict and the Making
Words: 2153 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

However owners of this people were highly prohibited to mistreat them as it was against the customary law of the community to do so. The following is the list of the title given to different people in Lao community depending on their job and duty performed in the community. Huu muang (transl. "ear of the muang") - head of foreign affairs, diplomat Taa muang (transl. "eye of the muang") - scholar, wise

Power, Authority & Influence Among
Words: 729 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

My colleagues at work know me for being honest yet diplomatic and congenial. To my staff, I am an authority figure who knows how to empathize with them, as I also rose through the ranks before I became a middle manager. However, in order to preserve the authority, respect and influence I have over my staff, I also make it a point to assume the role of a superior

Power and the Use of Language, Orwell's
Words: 1281 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Power and the Use of Language, Orwell's 1984 And Beyond George Orwell's 1949 dystopian novel 1984 has become almost iconoclastic in its meaning for contemporary society. Almost like the term Machiavellianism, 1984 evokes images in popular culture, along with the author's name as an adjective, and phrases that were used in the book. Even the term "Orwellian" denotes a certain type of society; phrases like "Big Brother," "Newspeak," "Thought-Police," etc. are

Power & Conflict Power's Role
Words: 1255 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

After all, a person's sense of self-worth depends on feeling competent and able to influence what is happening in one's life. How much power we perceive ourselves to have directly influences our sense of self-esteem. In a discussion of power currencies, Hocker & Wilmot (2007) say how much power we have depends on whether we have "currencies" other people want. In other words your power over another person rests on

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now