Verified Document

Compensation And Benefits Trends In 2015 Term Paper

Savannah Engineering, Inspection and Insurance Company (SEIIC): Trends in compensation and benefits

Savannah Engineering, Inspection and Insurance Company (SEIIC) is a service-based company and thus must cultivate a strong and committed performance from each and every one of its employees to thrive. However, currently its compensation and benefits programs lacks the ability to reward top performers and merely gives annual pay increases to all employees of 2-5%, regardless of the employee's level of productivity. Seniority rather than performance is given preference in terms of the company's evaluation and rewards system. Its benefits are competitive given that it offers health insurance and other benefits but the structure of the benefits is rigid and only includes such traditional benefits as health insurance, life insurance, retirement plan (defined benefit) and a 401(k) plan (defined contribution). This paper will offer suggestions to improve evaluation and rewards systems to ensure that top earners are adequately compensated.

Different types of appraisal and compensation

The most popular, traditional method of appraisal based on performance versus seniority is that of a behavioral checklist. "Behavioral checklist has a list of criteria that an employee should workup to be a diligent worker. The behaviors differ according to the type of job been assessed. This method is considered favorable as the evaluation is done on the basis of individual employee performance without comparisons" (Elan 2015). Managers meet and discuss the employee's performance with him or her. The downside to the process is that the checklist may not fully take into consideration all of the employee's input over the year. However, this method is fair in the sense that employees understand how and why they are being appraised and if they will receive a pay increase or promotion based upon their performance.

A more contemporary method of evaluation is that of management by objective, another method which...

"In MBO method of performance appraisal, manager and the employee agree upon specific and obtainable goals with a set deadline. With this method, the appraiser can define success and failure easily" (Elan 2015). Setting the objectives is a mutually-agreed upon process. There is no peer input but the employee does give input into how he or she will be evaluated. The specificity and the directness of the goals ensure that employees feel that the process is fair and they know how they will be evaluated. They also have a sense of control over how they will be evaluated. The downside is that having such a rigid system can in some instances cause a focus on the 'trees rather than the forest' and hamper productivity because compensation is tied to making objectives. In one organization, according to an employee: "One of our production manager's main goals was to keep his employees 100% utilized ... he blocked most of the lean initiatives...worried that if the team figured out a way to improve the process, they might get stuff done faster and if they ran out of things to work on, his employees' utilization rate would drop" and thus fail to meet the predetermined goals (Dyer 2013). Goals can become arbitrary and fail to serve the organization.
Another popular type of performance appraisal used to allocate compensation is that of 360 degree appraisal which "involves feedback of the manager, supervisor, team members and any direct reports" (Elan 2015). The great advantage of this system over the current one is that it provides specific and targeted feedback to employees from a variety of sources. "In this method of appraisal, [an] employee's complete profile has to be collected and assessed. In addition to evaluating the employees work performance and technical skill set, an appraiser collects an in-depth feedback of the employee" (Elan 2015). Peer input as well as managerial input ensures that employees' efforts on a team…

Sources used in this document:
References

Buckingham, M. (2011). The fatal flaw with 360 degree surveys. Harvard Business Review.

Retrieved from: https://hbr.org/2011/10/the-fatal-flaw-with-360-survey

D'Onfro, J. & Smith, K. (2014). Google employees reveal their favorite perks about working for the company. Business Insider. Retrieved from: http://www.businessinsider.com/google-employees-favorite-perks-2014-7

Dyer, J. (2013). Does Management By Objectives Stifle Excellence? Industry Week.
Retrieved from: http://www.industryweek.com/lean-six-sigma/does-management-objectives-stifle-excellence?page=3
Elan. (2015). What are the different types of performance appraisal systems. HR Zone. Retrieved from: http://www.hrzone.com/community-voice/blogs/elan/what-are-the-different-types-of-performance-appraisal-system
https://connects.hubinternational.com/three-emerging-employee-benefits-trends-to-watch-in-2014/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Globalization Trends Globalization Means a
Words: 3218 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

By 2050, it is projected that only India would be recording growth rates significantly above 3%. Incomes and Demographics By 2050, despite much faster growth, individuals in those countries are still predicted to be poorer than those persons living in any of the now G6 economies . Russia is the exception, essentially catching up with the poorer of the G6 in terms of income per capita by 2050. By 2030, China's

Benefits Package for Employees
Words: 2581 Length: 8 Document Type: Business Plan

employee benefits and compensation package for the post of a secretary for Guardian, hired by the firm's Human Resources department. This package will incorporate particulars such as whether the employee will be non-exempt or exempt, and handling of overtime. Government regulations will also be discussed. As firms are continually faced with growing pressure from competition, they strive to do more using fewer resources, and also strive to do this with

Trends and Best Practices in HR
Words: 1767 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Business, Legal and Financial Environment SEIIC is in a technical insurance business. While the business has changed from its traditional characteristics since 9/11, those changes were not outlined in the case so we actually know very little about the challenges that the company is facing in the industry today, just that they are struggling. The business environment is getting more competitive. This could mean that there is competitive from foreign

Benefits of Employee Motivation
Words: 6125 Length: 20 Document Type: Chapter

Organizational Behavior & Culture Complete summary of chapter 4 The chapter illustrates that the perception process is based on stages such as stimulation, organization, registration, and interpretation. The individual's acceptance and awareness levels for ascertained stimuli play critical roles in the perception process. The authors add that receptiveness towards certain stimuli remains highly selective in limiting a person's existing personality, motivation, attitude, and beliefs. People select various stimuli that satisfy certain needs

Human Resources and Compensation Philosophy
Words: 1461 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Compensation Philosophy Introduction Compensation philosophy refers to the approach that a company takes to determining compensation. Total compensation is a mix of pay and benefits, and the structure that the pay takes as well. The compensation philosophy should be aligned with the company’s overall strategy. For example, Wal-Mart pays at low rates in order to help it compete on a low cost basis – a lower cost of doing business is conducive

Latest Trends in Workplace
Words: 1662 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Workplace Key Functional Areas of HRM The entire aim of the human resource management function is to augment the personal and joint productivity of the employees and deliver stellar results for the organization. The key components of a human resource management are: Retention Development Succession But in the past few years, human resource characteristics are becoming more complicated and broad to say the least. Simultaneously, the focus has been on the fact that human resource practices

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now