Verified Document

Comparison Of Constitutional Reforms In France And Germany Term Paper

Reforms in France and Germany Divided Government and Constitutional Reform

When it comes to government, there are many forces within the framework, which influence political change for a nation and its people. When it comes to the governments of Germany and France each are structured and managed differently, however, the same force of divided government has resulted in profound constitutional reforms for both countries. This paper will discuss the forces that expand the potential opportunities for change to result and influence the legislative process. This issue of divided government is present in both governments and its effect on legislation has both short-term and long-term ramifications. How each country is willing to accept divided government as a part of the political machine is where each country forms its own identity and path for the future decision-making environments. It is the country's ability to embrace divided government or its ability to reject it that frames each country's present political machine and defines its overall global success. This paper will explore how Germany has embraced the element of divided government within its political framework as a means for maximized representation of its people and as a form of checks and balances for future reform. This paper will also examine how France has taken a more conservative approach in choosing to not embrace divided government as a means of political reform. If anything France has put into practice a government, which understands divided government has been a factor in the past and they are working to eliminate this factor for the better. Does this mean that one country is more open to change while the other is more resistant? The paragraphs below will explore similar and different governmental characteristics between the two countries and how these characteristics have shaped constitutional reforms.

France and Germany: Divided Government and Constitutional Reform

Many factors contribute to a government's management. Before defining divided government, one must understand, first and foremost that people are the...

Still there is a direct relationship between human agency and sociopolitical outcomes. As Kirk Buckman explains, " human agency impacts the social world only through concrete political, social and economic structures" (28). Divided government can be defined as "gridlock, deadlock or stalemate" (Buckman 26) but what it really describes is "opposition partisan control of separate branches of government that can produce institutional paralysis" (Buckman 26). In layman terms, this means one political party outweighs another in terms of power and reform. Ironically, it is divided government that makes American democracy possible. Divided government can affect changes for the governments of France and Germany but it is not responsible for these countries reactions to it. Nor, can it account for such divergent reforms. For both France and Germany, divided government means different things. The definition can be applied to work within each political structure each resulting in constitutional reform during the process.
For France, it defines divided government as cohabitation. This occurs when "the President and Prime Minister are from opposing political parties" (Buckman 26). Also cohabitation has occurred in French government "because of different electoral cycles: prior to the 2002 presidential election, the President was elected for a 7-year term, while the National assembly, to which the PM is responsible, was and continues to be elected for a 5-year term subject to a presidential dissolution" (Buckman 37). This proved to cause much unrest as the constitutional separation of executive power between the President and PM became unclear. Thus far, France has experienced two periods of cohabitation and it appeared to be accepted by the public. However, there was a call for reform as the French found "cohabitation is inconsistent with constitutional conventions or normative expectations and therefore would be best to reform" (Buckman 38) to…

Sources used in this document:
Work Cited

Buckman, Kirk. "Divided Government and Constitutional Reform in France and Germany."

French Politics 2 (2004): 25-60.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Executive Factors Among France, Germany
Words: 2356 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Also unlike the president, it is entitled to be part of the political party. This is an important aspect because its adherence to the party ensures its support for the political figure and for the measures to be taken throughout the mandate. This enables the administration to avoid potential situations when political support lacks. Political accountability rests in the power of the Parliament to hold accountable the Government. In this

Germany Research Project Germany Is a Prominent
Words: 4788 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

Germany Research Project Germany Germany is a prominent country in Europe as it stands as the second most crowded nation and the biggest economy in Europe. Seeing how it has the largest economy, it does alter the links between the prominent nations in the world. German history is filled with social and political movements. Adolf Hitler and the era of Nazism is an unfortunate and prominent part of the History of the

Authoritarian Modernization the Reforms Undertaken
Words: 5553 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Proposal

Kemal Ataturk Kemal Ataturk, founder of modern Turkey and its first elected president, was born as Mustafa on March 12, 1881 in Salonika or Thessaloniki, in Greece which was then under the Ottoman Empire. His father, Ali Reza Efendi, was a customs official who wanted his son's education to take place in a secular school. However, his father died while he was still a child. It was his mother Zubeyde Hanim

British Cannabis Policy Reform
Words: 11793 Length: 37 Document Type: Essay

Cannabis in the UK: De-Penalisation, Decriminalisation, or Legalisation? In October of 2015, the Parliament of the United Kingdom was forced to debate whether the current prohibition on cannabis should end in some way. "Forced" is the correct word here, because Parliament seems otherwise unwilling to address the issue, but in this case it was obliged by its own policy, whereby any petition signed by at least one hundred thousand people must

Italian Unification Process Unification Processes
Words: 5952 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Paper

[footnoteRef:5] Although Cavour could not pursue Napoleon III to continue war with Austria due to Napoleon III facing pressure domestically and abroad, there were long-term gains made by him. Kingdom of Piedmont was recognized by many world powers. Pope's power along with hat of Austrians was significantly reduced after wars in 1950s and 60s. Nonetheless, it was due to the valor of Giuseppe Garibaldi that enabled the unification to be

New Pattern of Integration Through Governmental Coordination European...
Words: 7020 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

New Pattern of Integration Through Governmental Coordination: European Perspective The beginning of the European Union was with the coalition of six nations (namely France, Germany, Italia, Belgium, Holland, and Luxembourg) who entered into a treaty back in the year 1951 to determine the ECU Coal and Steel Community. The next signed treaty was in the year 1957 to determine the ECU Economic Community. The Coal and Steel Community were also built

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now