Verified Document

Comparing Sun Tzu With Other Military Greats Essay

Sun Tzu and Military Classics Sun Tzu believed in freedom of action, mobility, surprise, deception and indirect attacks rather than frontal assaults. His method was always to "entice the enemy, to unbalance him, and to create a situation favorable for a decisive counter-stroke," while avoiding sieges and prolonged wars of attrition (Harvey, 2008, p. xlii). This was the opposite type of strategy from the commanders of the First World War or the American Civil War, who hurled masses of men against powerful defensive positions and inflicted mass casualties on their armies for no real purpose. Basil Liddell Hart, who was "horrified by the waste" of World War I, agreed with Sun Tzu that the indirect approach was superior, particularly using the mobility that tanks and air power provided (Harvey, p. xxxv). Most of the great commanders of history, like George Washington, Bernard Montgomery, Douglas MacArthur and George Patton have followed these principles, and also put heavy emphasis on both morale and morality of purpose in warfare, while they also had "an almost political ability to charm and inspire their men" (Harvey, p. xv). Like Sun Tzu, they were generally not from an elite or aristocratic background but more self-made men who were talented enough to break through the barriers of social class, which were much higher in the past. Commanders who followed these principles in warfare, including Gen. Vo Nguyen Giap in the Gettysburg, who kept launching futile attacks against an opponent who had the high ground and strong defensive positions.
General Nguyen Giap, the great North Vietnamese commander, was one example of the successful adaptation of Sun Tzu's methods to the 20th Century battlefield in the wars against the French and the Americans. Gen. William Westmoreland failed to understand the strategy of his enemy in the Vietnam War and therefore had no idea how to counter it effectively. He was fighting a war of attrition and search-and-destroy missions against an enemy that was prepared to take large casualties over many years, and keep coming back for more. Even worse, Westmoreland never realized that the enemy set the times and terms of almost all the battles, at least 80% of the time. Giap's Tet Offensive caught him completely by surprise in January 1968, especially when the Viet Cong launched over 100 separate attacks simultaneously in one night with over 80,000 troops.

It took Giap nine months of careful planning and preparation to organize the Tet Offensive, making use of many of Sun Tzu's principles like deceit, misdirection, diversions and surprise. Like Sun Tzu, Giap had great faith in intelligence and espionage, and his spy network was so effective that he knew exactly where and when the Americans would attack. He used camouflage and deception to smuggle weapons into South Vietnam and conceal them in large, underground tunnel complexes. Before the beginning of the actual Tet Offensive, he ordered diversionary attacks at Khe Sanh to misdirect and confuse the Americans, and in this he was successful right up to the level of President Lyndon Johnson. In all of…

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

Harvey, R. (2008). Maverick Military Leaders: The Extraordinary Battles of Washington, Nelson, Patton, Rommel, and Others. New York: Skyhorse Pub Co Inc.

Sun Tzu. The Art of War. History.com http://www.history.com/topics/the-art-of-war
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Normandy Crossing Elementary School According to Pryor,
Words: 1484 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Normandy Crossing Elementary School According to Pryor, Anderson, Toombs, & Humphreys (2007), there are 5P's of strategy implementation. The formation of strategy has long been studied, but the implementation of that strategy has not been as clearly addressed. Most of the planning that companies do on a strategic level is wasted because they invest a significant number of resources into the implementation of the strategy only to have it not work

Landing at Normandy During the Second World
Words: 3418 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Paper

Landing at Normandy During the Second World War, the Allies which were comprised of the United States, England, the Soviet Union, Canada, and several other smaller nations took arms against the Axis Powers. On June 6, 1944, the Allied forces landed on Normandy Beach in France, soundly defeating German forces at that location. This assault, also known as the D-Day Invasion, would be the turning point of the war and

Allied Invasion of Normandy During
Words: 1456 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

" In England, hundreds of fake tank and truck-shaped balloons simulated non-existent tank battalions to Nazi recognizance flights. As preparations neared combat readiness for Operation Overlord, Allied counterintelligence units even went so far as to float the corpse of a soldier outfitted in a high-ranking uniform and equipped with fabricated plans for an invasion of the Calais, in many way, the most logical invasion point because of its geographical proximity to

World War and Normandy
Words: 931 Length: 3 Document Type:

Battle of Normandy is deemed one of the most important events to have taken place during the Second World War. The invasion took place in Normandy, between June and August 1944, where soldiers of the Western Allies, including America, Canada, Russia and Britain, were in defense against the Nazi soldiers. From the standpoint of the United States, Sir Winston Churchill, General Dwight Eisenhower and Tar Robertson were key individuals that

German Preparation for the Invasion of Normandy
Words: 1695 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

German Preparation for the Invasion of Normandy On June 06, 1944, the biggest combined naval, military and air operation ever contrived took place, code-named Operation Overlord (Commemorative pp). When the Allied armada arrived off the Normandy coast in France, it launched the largest amphibious assault in history, and by the end of that day, American, British, and Canadian troops were firmly established on each of the five beachheads (Zuljan pp). A week

Monet S Normandy Train Impressionism in Paris
Words: 706 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Museum GalleryThe Chicago Art Institute is currently housing Arrival of the Normandy Train, Gare Saint-Lazare (1877) by Claude Monet. Dimensions of the work are 60.3 × 80.2 cm (23 3/4 × 31 1/2 in.). It is part of the Museum’s Painting and Sculpture of Europe, Gallery 201. It is an oil on canvas done in the Impressionist style, which is a style I find attractive and is the reason I

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now